Forum GOTY Thread

Hm, I think it's gonna be a tie between KCD, Warhammer II and Stellaris.

Yes, there is games of older. But I got them in 2018 with content of 2018 (Pirate Coast DLC for Warhammer II and Megacorps DLC for Stellaris).

Honourable mention is Warframe, which I played almost half a year coming back from a hiatus. And half a year is playing a game for an age when I look at my usual procedure. Of most good games I don't play much more than a month continuously.
 

Jenner

I wish I was English like my hero Tj.
X4 foundations!

Of all the new games in 2018, I've sunk more time in to X4 than anything so +1 to that.

It's buggy and I don't think I've ever seen a game less willing or able to explain itself, but I love it.
 
Last edited:
For me... Battletech. I think I only purchased three games this year: Battletech, Surviving Mars, and No Man's Sky. The former is great, the middle is decent, while the latter... is not my cup of tea.

Yeah, Battletech was surprisingly good. It'd be on my list as well, but I warped my interpretation of 2018 games a bit.
 
I have 'video gamed' since the mid 70's and loved it.

But I really didn't see anything in there as being a 'hobby', meaning one game. Video gaming itself is a hobby, but I didn't find one particular game that I saw as 'long term', very long term.

I started to see that possiblilty with OFP, but couldn't get others to change over from the wargaming we were playing, so I didn't pursue it. Just dabbled in there on my own. It was because of the 'Editor', I have never played a campaign from the series. It was that editor that held the key, for me at least. I could see those possibilities.

Everything changed for me and those around me, with Arma (1). I and my friends worked hard in the Arma editor, being very used to it by then via OFP. I brought others around me to see, that what we had been playing for more than a decade, which 'vision wise', was in a great part, just in our heads (SL & ASL 'vasl'). That we could bring all that and transfer it to the screen 'fully', in all it's splendour.
We played the hell out of Arma, now as a hobby, rather than just another video game. Building a wargaming world within it.

Having the 'Editor' was the catalyst for our wargaming moving from board/pc to pc only. Within that editor you could build a whole wargaming environment and when using mods, that meant a huge gaming environment. Taking parts of the much earlier SL & ASL (plus vasl) into consideration. But it was all there before you, on the screen, unlike anything we had done earlier mil-sim wise. From the smallest unit part, to a whole army, airforce, armour, etc. You could play either and every part within that world, whichever you wanted at the time.

With Arma 2 OA + all the dlc's we moved our gaming world from Arma to Arma 2, then A2OA. This is by far, my overall all time 'video' game within that or any other series. I'll never stop playing A2OA + dlc's. I really have too much invested in it. It's simply a joy that no other game will come close too really. Although I play others and love them and will play some games for many years (which I do and have done). But the Arma series stands alone for me, it's truly my hobby. But that is because my first love in games, is military stuff, I guess. ;)

We could possibly have moved from A2 to A3, but certain mods, that we saw as 'must have' didn't follow through to A3. A3 seemed and was, aimed more at mainstream, and away from the war sim it was prior.
So was stuck with A2 and haven't looked back at all. It was the best decision we made, to stay with A2.[yesnod]

Just thought I'd say. :D
 
Last edited:
I have 'video gamed' since the mid 70's and loved it.

But I really didn't see anything in there as being a 'hobby', meaning one game. Video gaming itself is a hobby, but I didn't find one particular game that I saw as 'long term', very long term.

I started to see that possiblilty with OFP, but couldn't get others to change over from the wargaming we were playing, so I didn't pursue it. Just dabbled in there on my own. It was because of the 'Editor', I have never played a campaign from the series. It was that editor that held the key, for me at least. I could see those possibilities.

Everything changed for me and those around me, with Arma (1). I and my friends worked hard in the Arma editor, being very used to it by then via OFP. I brought others around me to see, that what we had been playing for more than a decade, which 'vision wise', was in a great part, just in our heads (SL & ASL 'vasl'). That we could bring all that and transfer it to the screen 'fully', in all it's splendour.
We played the hell out of Arma, now as a hobby, rather than just another video game. Building a wargaming world within it.

Having the 'Editor' was the catalyst for our wargaming moving from board/pc to pc only. Within that editor you could build a whole wargaming environment and when using mods, that meant a huge gaming environment. Taking parts of the much earlier SL & ASL (plus vasl) into consideration. But it was all there before you, on the screen, unlike anything we had done earlier mil-sim wise. From the smallest unit part, to a whole army, airforce, armour, etc. You could play either and every part within that world, whichever you wanted at the time.

With Arma 2 OA + all the dlc's we moved our gaming world from Arma to Arma 2, then A2OA. This is by far, my overall all time 'video' game within that or any other series. I'll never stop playing A2OA + dlc's. I really have too much invested in it. It's simply a joy that no other game will come close too really. Although I play others and love them and will play some games for many years (which I do and have done). But the Arma series stands alone for me, it's truly my hobby. But that is because my first love in games, is military stuff, I guess. ;)

We could possibly have moved from A2 to A3, but certain mods, that we saw as 'must have' didn't follow through to A3. A3 seemed and was, aimed more at mainstream, and away from the war sim it was prior.
So was stuck with A2 and haven't looked back at all. It was the best decision we made, to stay with A2.[yesnod]

Just thought I'd say. :D

I only moved over to ARMA 3 because it was new...nothing more. So far I've played less ARMA than I ever did previously because the community I played with didn't follow on.
 
I'd still pick Elite over any other games, overall, but I play a lot of games, and I often re-play older games that I really like.

But for games that came out this year, in terms of hours I wound up putting in:

X4 Foundations
Phantom Doctrine
Farming Simulator 19
Assassins Creed Odyssey
 
Of the games I've played it would be Subnautica, Hollow Knight or Into the Breach for me.

Would probably have been Red Dead Redemption 2 if I had a console (finger crossed for PC)!
 
A console only goty. That's funny. Low end consoles getting the award is a joke.

"Wrong" is your middle name, isn't it. :p

On topic, I'm enjoying Monster Hunter World. I don't own many of the others listed, though RDR2, Nier: Automata, Subnautica, and Spiderman are on my "must buy" list.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, RDR2 I would really recommend. If you like getting lost (in a good way), in a game. Then RDR2 (sp) is a great way to do it. ;)
 
I only moved over to ARMA 3 because it was new...nothing more. So far I've played less ARMA than I ever did previously because the community I played with didn't follow on.

It did split quite a few groups up unfortunately. I'm glad we stuck with 2, it's a better game (imo), especially for ai mods.
 
It's the little moments like this that made my choice so definitive...masterful...but simply 1 out of 10,000 moments just like this throughout the game :)

[video=youtube_share;RgMN0Jwn6UE]https://youtu.be/RgMN0Jwn6UE[/video]
 
Last edited:
Snobbery, stupidity and ignorance all in one sentence.
Funny, I don't remember using any terminology like that about console users. Hmmm

But yet...your previous one sentence reply displays all of those traits :)

All of us posting in this thread to date have been long term PC gamers recognising that a 'low level' console game is simply one of the best games of this decade...I did note not one person expressed any deliberately derogatory and ill informed commentary on that fact with the exception of you.
 
Last edited:
To make it simpler. Console platform only game a winner? No. PC platform only game a winner? No.
If it's not across all three major platforms, it doesn't mean much.
Remember Wii only getting goty?
It might be a fabulous game. I can't play it so it's a down vote as it doesn't mean much when 2 of 3 major platforms only can play.
 

verminstar

Banned
To make it simpler. Console platform only game a winner? No. PC platform only game a winner? No.
If it's not across all three major platforms, it doesn't mean much.
Remember Wii only getting goty?
It might be a fabulous game. I can't play it so it's a down vote as it doesn't mean much when 2 of 3 major platforms only can play.

Obviously meant something to you when ye posted a comment about ¨low level¨ consoles being a joke. Ye didnt take part in the discussion, just posted what could be described as a troll comment cos not one single person had a single issue until you came along...now thats something I do find quite amusing considering ye still havent given yer choices and all yer doing is arguing and creating an issue where no issue existed before.

Back to talking to non toxic people...and there was me thinking there were only two alternative endings in rdr2. Last night, I experienced a third that I didnt know existed till last night...game still manages to surprise me even after all this time and on the third playthrough. It would mean a spoiler alert explaining what actually happens so yer gonna have to play the game yerself to find out...or search youtube.

Yer gonna need to git gud at knife fighting though cos thats the only weapon available, and the fight itself can have two possible endings depending on whether or not ye actually win the knife fight or not. The ultimate fate of Aurthur stays the same, but specifically how it happens and where...thats what sets the scene fer the final chapters as John ^
 
Back
Top Bottom