I posted
this nearly three years ago, and aside from some financial speculation that turned out to be wide of the mark (if FD had resource issues it was people rather than funds) I'm sad to say I have no reason to feel any different.
If anything it seems even less likely to me that we'll see atmospheric planets than it did in 2016. As I understand it, although no timescale was ever given, the game was supposed to get landable volcanic worlds as a stepping stone towards more varied landscapes and the beginnings of atmospheric modelling. I haven't seen a recent hint that we're even close to moving in that direction, unless it's one of the mysterious 4.xx features that are going to blow our collective socks off next year.
And that's the problem, isn't it? Five years after launch and we're still largely in a world of hopes, guesses and wild speculations.
As I said in that 2016 post, there is nothing I'd rather be wrong about than this (well, there's one other thing now but we're not allowed to do politics here). I would love for
ED to keep pushing the envelope and blowing our footwear across the room. I want to experience again that jaw-drop moment when airless planetary landings had their surprise reveal. Because when FD actually commit to something they are really,
really good at this literal world-building stuff.
ED still offers, IMO, the best depiction of space environments on a home PC. Even the much vaunted and spectacular
Space Engine, impressive though it is in scale and scope, can't compete directly with the stuff
ED already does better in my estimation. Some lighting issues notwithstanding,
ED's airless moons are much more convincing to me than the majority of
SE's.
But the scale of the challenge is enormous, and so many resources have been spent on added-in aspects of the game that feel poorly conceived and half-baked in execution. It pains me to say this, but I don't feel any sense of confidence that FD can bring much more of David Braben's KS/DD-era vision to life. I didn't feel it in 2016, and despite
Planet Coaster and
Jurassic World showing that the seeds of the
technology exist, I'm feeling it even less in 2019.
Please, FD, prove me wrong. I
want you to prove me wrong. I have a whole drawer full of socks on standby.