You only need to look at the lack of forum interactions to see what happened to this game.
Anyone who was here at the beginning knows how many were posting and it was great to see, as well as entertaining.
Slowly it dwindled and based on all available data will finally end with Stigbob and Babel congratulating themselves on how right they are in an empty forum.
Look at this thread alone, nearly a hundred pages but how many would there be if you removed half a dozen people, of those half dozen, how many of their posts were actually constructive or unique?
I hope FDev come through this, I want this game to succeed and I think it is a beautiful endeavor worthy of much pride but they are trying to do the impossible, and that never ends well.
You can not be all things to all people, concessions to one variable will always affect another.
I would like to see FDev split what they have so that they can give each "faction" what they want.
They should keep the original game as the kick starter and leps have legal and moral rights to expect what was sold to them to be honoured.
They should then use the engine to create what people are looking for but do so on a subscription basis, either themselves or licensed to another developer, preferably the latter.
It is unreasonable to expect continued development at no cost in a capitalistic society, code monkeys cost money and they eat a lot of peanuts.
My particular faction is with the open only PP crowd, that does not mean I do not recognize or value other players perspectives and needs, just that we get in each others way.
Instead of a zero sum equation where all play styles are hamstrung due to their inherent incompatibility, why not just split the servers and use some of the subscription money to allow more devs to work on giving each market what it wants?
Take my particular faction, the open only PP and bgs crowd, we would need tweaks to the actual p2p model to be changed to a client/server model, we do not require the vast reaches of the universe because we are all fighting in a vastly smaller bubble.
I would also make it 18+ and turn Galnet and lore over to the players themselves, if you don't think the market is there, then head over to the good old days where thousands of people were commenting and the intrigue and propaganda from all factions was a lot of fun, though not often family friendly.
Suppose I am mistaken and after a year the whole thing goes up, FDev still have $10 a month from every player and much of the development would still be compatible with the original game.
I am willing to pay $10 a month for that and I know I am not alone.