Newcomer / Intro Ship Destroyed due to spontaneous "Criminal Activity" | Rage-Quit

Troll, troll, go away!

I'm not trolling at all. If after 2 hours of gameplay and a fairly minor setback due to not focussing on the game your position is

at the moment my attitude is just that I should uninstall and abandon this in the steam library graveyard,

Then it probably isn't the game for you. There are much greater challenges ahead.
YOU suggested throwing the game away, not me
 
Thanks for that. :D



Okay I opened the settings I never stepped away from the keys. I was actively exploring the UI, adjusting graphics, audio and controller settings. I understand the sentiment that there is little difference. Beyond that. If I need to consider myself afk any time I don't have my path of travel in FOV; Saving key #2 the chat. (which as of yet is still out of contrast for reading) The sub assemblies have terrible peripherals, it wouldn't be an issue to glance left and run a scan while actively piloting, without running into things, if I were sitting in the cockpit actual. The UI makes the process unrealistically difficult in this regard.
The best place to adjust settings are the various tutorials/training missions not only because they don’t affect your ship in game but because they are repeatable so you can clearly see the effects of what you did.
you can best access them from the main menu but they are also available from in your cockpit via the right hand menu but it is best to have your ship in a safe place first.
 
I'm not trolling at all. If after 2 hours of gameplay and a fairly minor setback due to not focussing on the game your position is



Then it probably isn't the game for you. There are much greater challenges ahead.
YOU suggested throwing the game away, not me

Look, I tried to make my original post clear that I was not definitively scrapping the game. While I admittedly took part in making some exaggerative and even sarcastic remarks conveying my frustrations. I came for discussion, on a topic of a game I am very interested in. Not because I need someone to "show me the light!" so that I can have "the will to command again!" -_- So, if all you are willing to offer in the discussion is negativity, I kindly ask that you sow your discord elsewhere.
 

Instead of devoting your energies to disputation on the forum, if you had just accepted it as a learning experience and got back in your rebuy or started again you would be well past the progression that you were at when you messed up.

Seriously, there are many things in the game that will wind you up (collective you) but the overall magnificence more than makes up for its foibles. ;)

Get back in there and enjoy yourself. (y)
 
Hi Op o/ .
1st sorry for you , it seems you had some bad experience with the docking computer. As many have stated before, you should try to learn how to dock manualy as it is way faster , and IMO great fun.

2nd Elite unfortunatly heavly relies on 3rd party software for many details, but i recommend you to check theses later ( when you feel you need it) on reddit / google/ these forums.

3rd crime and punishement are made in some wierd way as some newcommer feel heavly punished for really small mistake while hi-end griefer know how to avoid the system and are nearly unpunished. But lets be honest unless you are really unlucky being arrested / put into detention wont happen alot if you play the "clean" side.
Just to help you understand , at some point in the game people started to take really big ship and were blocking starport entry to annoy other or to deliver a message.
This is why station are a bit angry when you stay to long in the wrong place.

4th : I totaly understand why and support creation of some journal were you could see what leaded to your death IN GAME , and think it is a great idea.

Lastly , if you enjoyed your 1st 1hour and 50 min , I'd advise you to give it a second try as for me and many other , it is a great game.

(Also to people that nearly trash talk , a newcomer that have 2 hour in game and take the time to make a post at the forum, not being "IM DEAD THIS GAME IS TRASH OMG", please grow up, as I understand elite is for you an "elite" game, totaly discouraging new players because they point out their experience and not actually help them is really lame and not an "elite" attitude.)
 

Deleted member 38366

D
Ah, one of the oldest - and still unfixed - bugs comes back around to bite. For the 100.000th time (likely far more than that).

Short Version
  • Station Instances populated by Players can quickly trigger a bug that'll cause NPCs normally departing the Station to stall and go AWOL (they'll sit "lost" and passive inside the Station or do weird stuff until the Station destroys them)
  • attempting to depart a Station with the Advanced Docking Computer these days will queue the own Ship behind other NPCs... including stalled ones, meaning the own Ship will remain stuck until it is destroyed as well
  • manual intervention (leaving the Station manually) is mandatory to prevent undue loss of time and/or eventually loss of own Ship under these circumstances
  • notably, this bug will typically not occur when alone all the time or i.e. in Solo Mode

Cause of Bug :
  • failed Island Merges and Transfers to a new host, causing NPC script malfunctions on one or more NPCs in the Instance
  • lack of sanity checks on NPC scripts to detect such a stalled condition

Age of Bug : Over 5 years, been there forever. Bug-Reported many times but never fixed.

The introduction of the Advanced Docking Computer has amplified the bug, as it transforms the own Ship guidance into an NPC basically - with the exact same logic flaws as regular NPCs and the same outcome.
Previously with the regular Docking Computer, all that would happen was that the own Ship would remain stuck outside until the Docking Clearance Timer ran out.
Annoying but technically no harm done. The Standard Docking Computer killed Player Ships in multiple other ways ;)

Welcome to ELITE... Don't ever expect Docking Computers to operate correctly all the time. This has never worked, not in >5 years. Not once.
They can be useful - but always check for signs of failure and be ready to intervene. They're not "AFK safe" by any means, far from it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Instead of devoting your energies to disputation on the forum, if you had just accepted it as a learning experience and got back in your rebuy or started again you would be well past the progression that you were at when you messed up.

Seriously, there are many things in the game that will wind you up (collective you) but the overall magnificence more than makes up for its foibles. ;)

Get back in there and enjoy yourself. (y)

Disputation is always a good use of energy, sharing experiences with other allows us perspective, I was perceiving frustration, and sought out those that were in a mindframe of logic. To have " just accepted it" is too much of an "It is what it is" response IMO, and frankly just not how I go through life. Thanks for your view of this one, I'm not done yet, hope to see you out there CMDR. o7
 
Okay I opened the settings I never stepped away from the keys. I was actively exploring the UI, adjusting graphics, audio and controller settings.

Never do that in an area where there is danger, taking off, docking, even using the DC, anywhere around other players and NPC's, flying over planets and moons, even just sitting on the surface of a planet in the bubble can be dangerous, in SC in the bubble, although I do that quite often out in the black far away from civilisation. What I mean by taking the eye off the ball is being in a situation where you can't see the radar and have view through the canopy, it's a spaceship, fly it as if every moment could be your last.
 
Thanks for that. :D



Okay I opened the settings I never stepped away from the keys. I was actively exploring the UI, adjusting graphics, audio and controller settings. I understand the sentiment that there is little difference. Beyond that. If I need to consider myself afk any time I don't have my path of travel in FOV; Saving key #2 the chat. (which as of yet is still out of contrast for reading) The sub assemblies have terrible peripherals, it wouldn't be an issue to glance left and run a scan while actively piloting, without running into things, if I were sitting in the cockpit actual. The UI makes the process unrealistically difficult in this regard.

Most of us cope.

Regarding glancing left (or up, down or right - there are five additional UI screens in your cockpit, four of which can be influenced by the pilot - plus the main screen, which can show station services or other stuff like powerplay, codex or engineers which you can select from the right screen), there are two major options:
  • the screen comes up (and gets the focus) automatically by looking at it. That's an option that is more often selected by flatscreen players
  • the screen comes up and gets the focus when you press a specific button (per default 1-4 on the keyboard IIRC). That's the option more often selected by VR pilots.
But, like with driving a car (or any other vehicle, really), you'll need to learn when it's safe to do so. Checking the right screen for your synthesis materials while you're taking fire from a Corvette is possibly not exactly the best idea - and very likely not something you're going to do twice.
 

Yaffle

Volunteer Moderator
Please all - play nice or don't play*.

*absence of ability to play may not necessarily be voluntary.
 
Stay alert. Learn to dock. Save lives.

That way, you won't violate the lockdown with unwarranted trips to detention centres.

Regardless of attitudes to the harsh punishments for docking violations, they just don't happen when you're doing it yourself.
 
Thanks Bud.

Hey, no problem. It's actually the best advice in this thread.

You're new to the game, we all were at one point, but... there was no starter area, and this whole auto docking thing, I don't remember having the opportunity for that, and I'm grateful for that.

After doing the tutorials, I do remember taking nearly the entire time allowed trying to dock after my first mission, and by the time I had run as many as you, my docking time was down to a solid 2-3minutes - a fraction of the time you sat in a queue waiting for the ADC to sacrifice you.

So ya, sounds like you need to throw off those training wheels and actually learn how to fly your ship.
 
Ive been playing for just about 2 hours now. Taking my time getting to know all the IU, hotkeys, etc. Liking the game so far but I just experienced a pretty serious buzzkill tbh.

I'm running a few random items from Matet to Dromi, I pull into the system, reorient to Mawson Dock, disengage the Friendship Drive, come up within 7.5, throttle down, hit 1, contacts, request docking (t-10:00), add a little throttle, autopilot takes over.

Ship flys over, orienting with the dock, comes to a halt. "Waiting in queue" (~t-9:20)

I'm looking around in the contacts interface, scan a ship, look at whats was scanned, exit. look back at the AP "Waiting in queue" ~t-6:30

Continue reviewing the scan and decide to go over to chat, thinking about messaging the pilot I scanned // At this point I realized I may have breached etiquette with an unprompted scan. //

Looking at the chat I notice that the opacity is so low I cannot read the CMDR's names at all. That just wont do!

Exit the chat, check the AP "Waiting in queue" ~t-2:30. Curious, I bump the throttle again. AP takes over once more does a big circle only to stop again to sit stationary in about the same spot it was. // "Okay maybe the station is busy." // "Waiting in queue" ~t-2:10.

ESC, go over to graphics looking for the chat opacity setting (still haven't found that yet) while I'm looking for it I get pulled out of the settings window to this.
View attachment 174180

Your ship is gone.
You are a criminal.
You have been incarcerated.
You are now labelled as an undesirable.


I have done a bit of research in the forum before posting this, I am assuming that the queue expired while I was inside, prompting me to be attacked by security for unauthorized docking? // But I wouldnt know, as apparently, Elite Dangerous takes place in a dystopian society where you can be shot out of the sky, locked up, fined, and outcast from society, without ever being told what law you broke. "Trust us you broke it" "Because we said you did" //

I suppose my question, summed up, is: Really?!

I not really too upset about dying, I get that realistically nothing has changed for me gameplay wise
// I mean it would have been nice to actually have the opportunity to immerse in the game, build some sort of fondness for whatever reputation I decided my CMDR to have. Despite agreeing fully with the concept "it's just a game" that sense of accomplishment (i.e having not died before playing for X Hours, or earning X credits) is part of the experience I enjoy //

What burns me is that huuge Gaping continuity hole in the game. I cannot look up my own criminal history? to find out what caused my ship to get destroyed? so that i can avoid it ever happening again... only session log entries that say "committed crime" and "Ship lost" with no details. looking to what the community has to say its possible the docking timer expired, but... to be shot down for trespassing, without a comm signal, not any iota of a warning. I fully understand that elite dangerous does not hold your hand. I've had my eye on this game for some time, watching streamers play it, reading lengthy articles about the Fuel Rats( good chaps, them.) However; sadly, at the moment my attitude is just that I should uninstall and abandon this in the steam library graveyard, all because the docking computer autopilot is garbage, and killed all enthusiasm I have. I hope the bad taste this has left doesn't stick around too long I really wanted to play this game.

If you've got any ideas why this has happened, or have a similar experience to share; I'd like to hear from ya.
Some times autopilot just messes up, and you need to override it. Keep eye on counter telling you your docking/undocking remaining time. If you run under minute take over and do manual docking/undocking. Otherwise, yes station will kill you, and you get punished. (That one minute rule is my own idea, enough time to do it properly...)
 
Last edited:
Never mounted one of those, but I was mildly surprised to see it queues you up for that long. Good grief.
In my experience since coming back it doesn’t ... maybe for a minute to leave but I have always been docked straight away on request so maybe put in a ticket to Frontier?
 
Never mounted one of those, but I was mildly surprised to see it queues you up for that long. Good grief.
In my experience since coming back it doesn’t ... maybe for a minute to leave but I have always been docked straight away on request so maybe put in a ticket to Frontier?

I wonder if in fact the OP had overridden the DC more than just the once, as they said "...Curious, I bump the throttle again..." - overriding the DC then re-engaging it by zeroing throttle does not reset the timer (I just checked to be sure) so maybe the OP lost their place in the queue by doing so? In any event, all it needs is for someone to muck the queue up, be it stalled NPC or a commander stuck in the toast-rack for the timer to run down.
 
Back
Top Bottom