Well I think we can agree that it's very subjective. I just went from a CV1 rift to an Odyssey + (coz the rift died after maybe 3 years, prob the ribbon cable) the build quality of the Odyssey is not as good as the rift, the controllers are not as nice and they burn through AA batteries. The tracking is not as good but it's fine for ED coz you are sitting down not jumping around playing beat saber. The graphics are a little better as the resolution is on par with an Index (less the sub pixel thing) with no SDE at least for me. The blacks are good coz it's OLED which is a big deal for ED. I have not tried an index but I suspect that it's a better product all round. Various versions of Pimax are high on the list too. Thing is I am finding it hard to justify spending a $grand and maybe more than twice that if I upgrade my 1080 to a 2080 to max out the new HMD, when it's a 1.5 upgrade and the Odyssey + cost $300. I am saving my $ for VR 2.0