Coincidence or not?

Ok, this isn't exactly Elite Dangerous related but close enough that y'all might be interested.

So, while I was working on my WWII related website, I asked an AI to draw me an image in two colors with the silhouette of a man in WWII uniform speaking into a bullhorn. The first AI didn't give me exactly what I wanted so I asked a couple more.

When I made that request to Grok, two of the images it gave me looked like this:
Diamondback1.jpg


And:
Diamondback2.jpg


Notice the vehicle in the background? That appears to be a Diamondback Explorer.

Now, interestingly enough, when I was more active playing Elite it was the DBX that I used most predominantly and this one appears to be in pretty much the same colors as the one I flew. Not to mention my goofy Youtube channel features that same ship.

So, when I asked it "Why?" it responded: "The AI might have conflated the "uniform" and "air force" elements with a spacecraft, especially if the game’s aesthetic includes characters in uniforms interacting with ships like the Diamondback Explorer." And when I responded, "Yea, but why the DBX in those colors?" it replied: "If the colors of the DBX in the images match your in-game ship, that’s a lucky coincidence! The AI’s choice of colors was dictated by your prompt, and its decision to include the DBX was likely a result of its training data favoring popular sci-fi imagery over strictly historical WWII elements." Ummm... yea... So, when I pointed out to it that this was one helluva coincidence it responded: "You’re right to call me out on potentially stretching things! My earlier explanation leaned heavily on the AI’s tendency to blend concepts (e.g., "Air Force" leading to a sci-fi spacecraft), but I might have overanalyzed the reasoning. A simpler explanation could be that the AI’s training data has a bias toward popular sci-fi imagery like Elite Dangerous, and the DBX in light purple colors happened to be a strong match for the colors you provided. The WWII context might have been partially ignored in favor of a more visually striking (but incorrect) element."

Whatever! :D

So, what does everyone think? Coincidence or not? I'm not really sure what to make of this. I mean, I know they track us on the 'Net but to this level of detail seems pretty unlikely... but, that is one hell of a coincidence!

Finally, if anyone else is interested, let's try a little experiment. If you're willing, go to Grok and tell it:

Draw me a simple two color image of the silhouette man in WWII air-force uniform speaking into a bullhorn. The background is blank in the color of #CCCCFF while the foreground is #DDDDFF. The aspect ratio is 16:9.

Then report back here what it gives you. It'll be interesting to see the results. :)
 
There's no way an image that similar is a coincidence. Grok's training algorithm is reading your browsing data (including your YT channel and related images), and perhaps images stored on your PC to tailor results to appeal to you?

From the xAI Legal FAQ:

Does xAI use my content for model training?

We may use your content and interactions with Grok (e.g., prompts, searches, and other materials you submit) along with Grok's responses to train our models. Specifically, this information helps our models better understand human language and communication and therefore ultimately provide more accurate, relevant, and engaging responses. It also helps boost the capabilities and safety of our models. You control whether your data is used for training Grok. The section below, “How do I select whether my content is used for model training,” explains how to control it.

To protect your privacy, please do not share any personal or sensitive information in your questions to Grok.

When using Private Chat, where available, your content and interactions are not used for model training. Similarly, we do not use content from our business and enterprise customers to improve our models. For more details, please refer to our Enterprise FAQ.

How do I select whether my content is used for model training?

You can select whether or not your data is used for training in your Grok mobile app and the Grok.com website.

Mobile App Data Controls for Training Grok: On the mobile app, to select or deselect using your content for model training, go to Settings, Data Controls, and select or deselect “Improve the model.”
 
Well, it gets even more amusing. I asked it two quick follow-ups. This is what I got:

So, if I asked you to draw the image of DBX in flight, what would you give me?
NotDbx.jpg


NotDbx2.jpg



And if I asked you to give me a Diamondback Explorer from Elite Dangerous, what would you give me?
NotDiamondback1.jpg


NotDiamondback2.jpg
 
When the AI attack and kill us, it won't be because they're deliberately trying to murder us. It'll be because they're trying to do things they think we want but are confusing them with things that are deadly and inappropriate. The results will be both sad but hilarious. 🤣
 
Back
Top Bottom