Personally I don’t have any major issues by OA using click bait etc to help views in some of his Elite videos. It is his business to manage after all. But it shouldn’t be too hard for us all to just acknowledge that and move on.
It is just a bit of a shame that those who defend so adamantly OA click bait and critiques to FDEV feel obligated to stop any critiques directed at him. You can’t have your cake and eat it. Fair is fair no? Those critiques to OA also have their place and I am even sure they are a valuable source of feedback for OA too. Pretty sure he can take it (weather he agrees or not, although I can obviously understand he does not). Up to us then to decide if we want to watch his content or not anyways. In my case I just prefer to watch other Elite content
Feedback is always valuable.
It's not that you don't have a point, because in part you do. It's just that your point isn't 100% correct.
Of
course there is an element of clickbait. YouTube is YouTube, and unfortunately that is how the platform works nowadays. I will link a video to Veritasium at the bottom of this post, he explains it very well. He is also spot on in his assessment, and that is clear for those of us YouTuber's who have been fortunate enough to visit Google HQ in London, and who also have a direct contact at YouTube (a YouTube Manager). YouTube thrives on clickbait.
So your point is that "OA shouldn't use clickbait." My point is that "Clickbait" thumbnails and titles are ok, so long as they are well balanced with the content of the video. (Also your definition of clickbait and my definition are clearly different).
Example: My "Sinking ship" video, wasn't about calling Elite a sinking ship. I've never once said Elite is a dying game. I do not believe it is dying.
However, it does "feel" like it is a sinking ship. And this is due to Frontier's communication policy. Taken together, my video title, thumbnail and content address this issue in the manner I perceive it. I appreciate you don't agree with that.
On a broader note, your opinion that I'm using clickbait to drive high levels of views is wrong. If I wanted to drive a lot of views by creating drama and abusing clickbait, I could be way more effective with it. Examples: Regularly using clips of CMs, Devs, Frontier Execs. Creating parody and satire. Quoting user forum posts, Tweet's and more that I disagree with. Creating "response" videos on other YouTuber's videos. All of these are proven techniques that generate many 100's of thousands of views. A lot of channels thrive on that content. I'm well positioned to take advantage of that, and could easily double (at least) my viewing figures.
I don't do that, because I'm not out to create drama. (Also, if I wanted to create drama for views, I wouldn't even post on these forums. Why would I even care what a few people here think?)
I'm also not out to target Frontier, or cause them problems. For those who are concerned about me causing "harm" to Frontier, or Elite. I know for a fact that Frontier don't have any issues with my content (even the most recent videos). Arf has said as much on a recent livestream - but over the years, I have also had many conversations with the CM team, devs and even some of the execs. They have no problem with my any of my content (even the current videos).
But all of this is besides the point. Anyone is 100% within their rights to critique my content. For those that don't like my style, that is completely fine. Feedback is also very welcome. For those who don't want to watch my videos and prefer to watch other content creators, that is also great, it's how it should be. There's a load of awesome Elite content creators.
The only reason I address a few points here, (like the ones you have raised), is because you are categorically wrong in saying that I'm out to generate drama to create views. Whilst some of my videos undoubtedly create drama, that is never my goal. My goal is simply to express my opinion.
So, the bottom line really is this: I always like to hear feedback on my content. There's always room for improvement. I will listen to feedback on that, and use it to improve my content.
But when someone questions my
motivations, then that is a separate subject to questioning my content. I've told you my motivations. I've been honest, genuine and upfront about that. You are free to either believe or not believe that. Although I hope you can accept what I have said on that.
On the subject of questioning my content though, that's always welcome, and I appreciate the feedback.
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2xHZPH5Sng