Insta-billionaires DID exploit (a theory)

Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
devaluation of time and work others have put in to achieve something which has suddenly become "worth" a lot less
Dude, get a job. It's just a game, and supposed to be fun.
Your "wealth" here doesn't "worth" anything to anyone else.
 
Ok so I take it from that you either didn't read it or didn't understand. It's not the simple jealousy issue you want to simplify it to, I know from where you're sitting that's all you can really wrap your brain around but that's not it. It's about the devaluation of time and work others have put in to achieve something which has suddenly become "worth" a lot less through the actions of the people responsible for maintaining the integrity of the game.

So you have an opinion on what is fun, and because others disagree with that opinion they are wrong. Because that's all you have is an opinion.

"It's my opinion that people should have to spend time and effort into earning ships in this game. Even though bypassing those requirements has no actual impact on how the game plays and develops, and it's entirely possible that I'll never even see any of these people, the fact that my opinion on how this game should be played is not being upheld makes them wrong and ruins the game for me."
 
So, why are you so mad that I "cheated" when my "cheating" has no impact on your experience? If I were playing pinball on my computer and found a way to rig the game so that I got ridiculously high scores, would you demand to the developer of that game that my game be fixed and the high scores on my computer be removed?

I would hope not because that would mean you really have some personal issues that you need to get checked out.

If Elite Dangerous ever gets to a point in development where my Billions effects others that don't want to be effected in an unfair way, then I will acknowledge that keeping the credits is wrong. Until then, I see no harm in me or anyone else holding on to the money.

Eventually, it is not about who feels affected by an incident like that or not, but how FD handles those irregularities and how transparent they are about them and their resolution. That's why they have to follow-up reasonable suspicions like stated in OP and utter a public clarification afterwards. Otherwise, this will give rise to conspiracy theories and distrust between parts of the player base and the devs.
 
Last edited:
Eventually, it is not about who feels affected by an incident like that or not, but how FD handles those irregularities and how transparent they are about them and their resolution. That's why they have to follow-up reasonable suspicions like stated in OP and utter a public clarification afterwards.

Have they not been clear enough? They stated what happened. They stated what was being done to fix it. They stated that those players who they could confirm were intentionally exploiting a bug to make extra money would be set back, and those that just fell into their billion through no fault of their own (myself being one of them) would be able to keep their credits at the expense of being eliminated from the Race to Elite.

What else are you expecting of them as far as being open and transparent?
 
If Elite Dangerous ever gets to a point in development where my Billions effects others that don't want to be effected in an unfair way, then I will acknowledge that keeping the credits is wrong. Until then, I see no harm in me or anyone else holding on to the money.

When the time has come, it is too late to take the money away from the cheaters. They have to do it now or never.
It is already worsening my gaming experience, knowing that a cheater can cross my way any time I play in open. So I am forced to play solo if I want a somewhat fair experience.
 
Have they not been clear enough? They stated what happened. They stated what was being done to fix it. They stated that those players who they could confirm were intentionally exploiting a bug to make extra money would be set back, and those that just fell into their billion through no fault of their own (myself being one of them) would be able to keep their credits at the expense of being eliminated from the Race to Elite.

What else are you expecting of them as far as being open and transparent?

To clarify OP's concern. Specifically, if the amount of ~5 billion is just coincidental or if there could be a connection.
 
So you have an opinion on what is fun, and because others disagree with that opinion they are wrong. Because that's all you have is an opinion.

Eh?

You asked for my reasons, I gave them to you, you then skewed those reasons into "you're just jealous", I corrected you.

"It's my opinion that people should have to spend time and effort into earning ships in this game. Even though bypassing those requirements has no actual impact on how the game plays and develops, and it's entirely possible that I'll never even see any of these people, the fact that my opinion on how this game should be played is not being upheld makes them wrong and ruins the game for me."

Well you're twisting it a bit but essentially yes. Just one clarification, it's not *me* who's saying people must spend time and effort to earn ships, it's Frontier since they created the game.
 
Last edited:
Have they not been clear enough? They stated what happened. They stated what was being done to fix it. They stated that those players who they could confirm were intentionally exploiting a bug to make extra money would be set back, and those that just fell into their billion through no fault of their own (myself being one of them) would be able to keep their credits at the expense of being eliminated from the Race to Elite.

What else are you expecting of them as far as being open and transparent?

Where did they state that because despite asking a number of times I've still not seen an official statement, which for reasons of transparency should not be buried in a long thread but should be in the News and Update section?
 
Last edited:
When the time has come, it is too late to take the money away from the cheaters. They have to do it now or never.
It is already worsening my gaming experience, knowing that a cheater can cross my way any time I play in open. So I am forced to play solo if I want a somewhat fair experience.

You are absolutely ridiculous. Hahah!

I'll make a bet with you. You fly around in Open Play and the first time you show me evidence that a "cheater" has interacted with you in any way, I'll delete my save instantly and start from scratch. Your fear is completely irrational, and over-the-top ridiculous.
 
You are absolutely ridiculous. Hahah!

I'll make a bet with you. You fly around in Open Play and the first time you show me evidence that a "cheater" has interacted with you in any way, I'll delete my save instantly and start from scratch. Your fear is completely irrational, and over-the-top ridiculous.

I think you are so obsessed with your new found shiny stuff you are not seeing the bigger picture.
 
You are absolutely ridiculous. Hahah!

I'll make a bet with you. You fly around in Open Play and the first time you show me evidence that a "cheater" has interacted with you in any way, I'll delete my save instantly and start from scratch. Your fear is completely irrational, and over-the-top ridiculous.

That makes it even worse: I can't even detect and avoid them. There will allways be this uncomfortable feeling of being in a game with cheaters. I don't want to play with guys like you, so I play solo. Multiplayer is broke.
 
Have they not been clear enough? They stated what happened. They stated what was being done to fix it. They stated that those players who they could confirm were intentionally exploiting a bug to make extra money would be set back, and those that just fell into their billion through no fault of their own (myself being one of them) would be able to keep their credits at the expense of being eliminated from the Race to Elite.

What else are you expecting of them as far as being open and transparent?

Just in case it's not obvious, people are questioning this bit :

"those that just fell into their billion through no fault of their own (myself being one of them) would be able to keep their credits"
 
You are absolutely ridiculous. Hahah!

I'll make a bet with you. You fly around in Open Play and the first time you show me evidence that a "cheater" has interacted with you in any way, I'll delete my save instantly and start from scratch. Your fear is completely irrational, and over-the-top ridiculous.
Evidence is not his strength.
Lol. wait a sec! I'll cheat and go to find him just to laugh.
 
That makes it even worse: I can't even detect and avoid them. There will allways be this uncomfortable feeling of being in a game with cheaters. I don't want to play with guys like you, so I play solo. Multiplayer is broke.

I wonder how you can function even here, on the forums. There are probably people here with multiple accounts who rep themselves. You should open a notepad and play forum with yourself, lest you run into any cheaters.
 
Look here's your circumstantial evidence which isn't "hard proof" I agree, I have no footage of this actually happening or anything as unfortunately I don't have cameras in Frontier's offices at this time.

Exhibit A, bugged shield generator that you can't sell, cost : 4,294,967,295

25tg6pt.jpg


At a later point, "refunded" by a dev via some automated system, with a 20% bonus : 4,294,967,295 * 1.2 = 5,153,960,754 credits

Exhibit B, a player in receipt of 5 billion :

90q06h.jpg


The balance is 5,159,650,234.

The figures are remarkably close yes? <snip>

4,294,967,295 = 2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2 - 1

It's just the biggest number that will fit into 32 bits, if interpreted as unsigned.

The usual programming reason for 4,294,967,295 to crop up is mixing up signed and unsigned interpretation... because the above is also how you represent...

-1
 
I wonder how you can function even here, on the forums. There are probably people here with multiple accounts who rep themselves.

I don't play the rep game. I am here only for the discussion. I don't care about fake accounts too. I am dealing with arguments, not with accounts. That is the way I see it.

You should open a notepad and play forum with yourself, lest you run into any cheaters.

This would be pretty boring as I usually know what I write before I do it. But playing Elite solo is a lot of fun. At least more fun than playing with cheaters.
 
Last edited:
4,294,967,295 = 2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2x2 - 1

It's just the biggest number that will fit into 32 bits, if interpreted as unsigned.

The usual programming reason for 4,294,967,295 to crop up is mixing up signed and unsigned interpretation... because the above is also how you represent...

-1

So the REAL reason is that Frontier messed up in their code and / or their support messed up trying to fix their accounts.

The players do not deserve the credits due to the error, they should be swiftly removed. I don't understand how anyone can say this doesn't affect your game when this is a multiplayer game where credits are the only means of improving your ship!
 
Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom