my idea is higher fines would hurt the farming I presume
But would presumably mean higher bounties, encouraging the player BH base and maybe encouraging more actual players to take the BH route instead of pirating.
That way combat orientated players still get the combat they crave, but miss out on the thrill of being a bad [donkey] lawbreaker - so I presume not all will go for being a BH.
And at least higher bounties will help the BH players keep up with the traders. [Oooh, getting a little political there!]
.
But as I have said repeatedly on this forum, I'm not against pirating in general, just brainless pirating.
If I get interdicted by a player, and asked [yes, asked. Not expecting a "Please", but decent language.] to drop a
reasonable percentage of my cargo, then I probably will. It would be nice for someone to have put a little thought into the act - maybe someone has turned to pirating because of having been swindled out of almost everything they have, and need to make enough money before they go home to pay off a gambling debt or something. Let's have something a little more three dimensional from the pirates, not just the same old "Drop your cargo or die" psychopath routine that EVERYONE uses.
.
Yes, in the [hopefully short] times I have to act as a trader to pay for exploration gear, I do accept that there is a certain risk. Last night my DC malfunctioned and drove me into the outside of a station, destroying my ship and cargo. [Bleep] happens. But if you want something from me, make sure you're not basically asking me to work for you without pay - and yes, if you're asking me to give up more than 50% of my profits, I'm basically playing the game for your benefit, not mine! Keep it under 20% and you will get a much better reaction. [Oh, and again, if you can't carry 20% of my cargo, don't ask for 20%. Same difference if a wing of 5 of you are looking at me. You split your 20% between you, you're not getting 20% EACH!]