The problem is everything to date has been paper hulls with Guardian stuff... yet Guardians supposedly tore Thargoids apart when forced into actual conflict... yet if our SLF are anything to be a basis on... they are weaker than human tech (because Frontier and it's precious "game balance" despite everything Guardian is utterly superior to human made stuff). I'd pray that at least for Thargoid combat that the Guardian-human hybrid actual ships would be utterly GODLY against Thargoids, but then Frontier would have problems balancing it for human conflicts or PvP. Honestly I wish Frontier would throw the idea of "balance" out the window and just make a damn fun game, it's clear anything this vast of a game won't have a true semblance of balance.
From the logs from the original Ram Tah mission, Technology 10:
"In terms of flight and small-class spaceships, humanity has surpassed the Guardians, but in other respects their technology outmatched ours."
Plus it's worth bearing in mind that the Guardians only repelled the Thargoids from a disputed area of space, and the Thargoids hadn't entered that area of space prepared for a protracted conflict. (They'd returned to an area seeded previously with barnacles and there being another spacefaring species there was a surprise to the Thargoids - so we're likely talking the Thargoids being the equivalent of colonists/harvesters, not a battlefleet). Plus that was 2 million years ago. It doesn't really add up to Guardian tech being hyper-effective against Thargoids.
Also why would there be a balance problem anyway? We're talking about a tech that was designed to be effective against a type of tech which is different to that which we use. Thargoid tech is biomechanical. Ours isn't. There's no reason that something designed to be highly effective against bio-tech would be particularly effective against non-biotech.
Here's where we are effectively:
- Human tech - designed to be effective against other Human tech
- Guardian tech - designed to be effective against 2My old Thargoid biotech (and presumably to some extent other Guardian tech as a legacy of their second civil war).
- Thargoid tech - anyone's guess. Compared to the age of their civilisation, the conflict with the Guardians was a miniscule blip as has been their encounter with humanity.
- Human/Guardian hybrid tech - designed to increase effectiveness against current Thargoid biotech. (And decreased effectiveness against other types of tech a possible consequence.)