No Single Player offline Mode then?

Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Disapointed

Just adding my disappointment that there will be no single player offline mode. I don't want to _have_ to deal with this, so I'm considering a refund...
 
Jonbe54, if DBraben can play it fine, on a train, over a cellphone tether - which, from experience is dropout city as one moves from cell to cell at high speed - then I'm pretty sure that any internet connection you can find will be sufficient for Solo play.

Hmmm well if that's the case I'm back in the ballpark thx bog do you have any links to the braben interview where he says that?
 
Just as a warning to those denied a refund:

You have to prove you can't use the product to get a refund on it. Otherwise they will deny it. With the exception of just the pre-order, these don't count...

If you can sometimes play
just bought it to see what the game was like
that you don't like peer-to-peer
just decided that wasn't the game you thought...
or anything like that...
well... sorry from FD side but legally you don't have a valid reason to get a refund. You don't OWN the game, you never bought the game. You paid for a concept of a planned game that will come with a game in the future. But you didn't actually buy the game.

A refund in this case is based on the complete inability to play the game without the offline mode, OR your machine is so old you should never have owned the game (I know that was a problem with one of my friends). But to be honest, buying the Beta is saying you are paying FD to create a game based on FD ability, not your personal idea of how it should be done. That's pretty much it.

Not liking someones idea AFTER you paid for the idea is not a valid reason. That would make most products in the world get sued.
 
Food for thought - it may not be just internet connection - He/she may not want to share the universe with anyone. Being "affected" by other players is a lot more than just avoiding player pirates and unwanted dogfights. Found a sweet trade route that you want to exploit? That's great, but if you log off and then come back a few days later when you get some more time to play, there'll be dozens of other players who will have found it and flipped the market upside down because, surprise, FD is forcing you to use the same market simulation as all the open-play people.

So you'd prefer an exploitable AI that allows you to farm the same route over and over?

Edit sorry that sounds so pointed...but playing eve as I do I find single player simulations of such things become incredibly boring in comparison.
 
Last edited:
No, it's not forcing you - you're deciding to, by playing the game. I understand where you're coming from, Papa Smurf, I really do. And I admit, this business with the troll poet1960 has me on edge. But nevertheless, this is the way the game has developed, and it is a bit of a lottery where game dev goes, especially for titles which are pushing the boundaries of what can be done with today's tech.

I hope that we can continue this conversation without further inflammation from people who are nothing to do with this. Emotions are high enough, and feelings inflamed enough, without people coming in to just see how angry they can make people.
 
Papa Smurf, Poet1960 has refused to say whether or not he or she has even pre-ordered the game. With their evasions, and the way they only registered yesterday and only posted in this thread, it's a reasonable assumption that they've just been attracted by webnoise to come troll here to try to break Frontier beacuse that's vandalism for the 21st Century.

Any day now, we are expecting riots here in Oakland, when the Grand Jury in Ferguson, MO. decides whether the officer who shot the black teen should be indicted.
Most will protest peacefully, many will pillage and loot. Those causing trouble are predominantly from outside the community. They come in to incite civil unrest.
They don't give a damn about the the issues being protested, but they make the whole group look bad.

It is not as extreme but it is happening on these forums and it makes those with legitimate complaints look bad.
I am not personally pointing the finger at any one individual.
 
Last edited:
Any day now, we are expecting riots here in Oakland, when the Grand Jury in Ferguson, MO. decides whether the officer who shot the black teen should be indicted.
Most will protest peacefully, many will pillage and loot. Those causing trouble are predominantly from outside the community. They come in to incite civil unrest.
They don't give a damn about the the issues being protested.

It is not as extreme but it is happening on these forums and it makes those with legitimate complaints look bad.
I am not personally pointing the finger at any one individual.

I would tend to agree with that except for one thing, they don't really seem to give darn about the people anyway, so looking good or bad isn't helping or hurting one bit.
 
No, it's not forcing you - you're deciding to, by playing the game. I understand where you're coming from, Papa Smurf, I really do. And I admit, this business with the troll poet1960 has me on edge. But nevertheless, this is the way the game has developed, and it is a bit of a lottery where game dev goes, especially for titles which are pushing the boundaries of what can be done with today's tech.

I hope that we can continue this conversation without further inflammation from people who are nothing to do with this. Emotions are high enough, and feelings inflamed enough, without people coming in to just see how angry they can make people.

I got nothing against limiting this forum/thread to people who supported/bought/etc a copy of ED. Realistically I am SHOCKED that FD has allowed this to go on this long without doing something... no damage control, no statements, etc, etc.

They are not only losing face here but this is spreading to other "non-elite" boards.
 

Yaffle

Volunteer Moderator
Everybody, take a deep breath.

Stop. Typing. Now.

If what you are about to post is about another user, directly or by some snide indirect route, you are on thin ice and should watch your inbox for a warning/infraction.

Debate the topic, or at least what's left of it after over 8,500 posts, not each other.

Read your post before you press the submit button. See if you would like that said to you. Now, continue.
 
My opinion is that I bought two products from the Elite store, that where delivered with promises in mind.

I don't want to take the future game away from you guys, I just feel like Frontier pulled a bait-n-switch on me.

A simple refund would shut up many of us. Apparently we are a small group, so it should be possible.


No action is an action... Frontier Developments silence here speaks volumes.
 
No it's been answered, you just didn't like the answer :p

This is simple, they aren't going to change their mind. The reason for which is almost certainly that it would take many more months to get offline mode ready. They just aren't going to do it at least "short term". Maybe in an expansion, who knows, but definitely not in the original release.

So, you're saying that when Theodrid asks MB "F: D are not going to put out an official statement about this beyond what has already been said?", that the response, "The decision was made so that we could focus on getting the game done and to match what we desired from the game - so of course we're continuing with work." is an answer?

Sorry, but I see absolutely nothing in his reply that addresses the question about will FD make an official statement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mods are the same the world over - always the voice of reason - or giving you the reason to button it up lol.

Seriously I post on Australian rules football forums and political forums and while you may be dismayed by the lack of respect some show here you would be horrified by our political forums.
 
I think I've said everything I can productively say here, and probably a few posts past that, for which I apologise. The blood gets hot sometimes. Thanks, Yaffle, for giving me pause.

I'll see you Commanders in the deep dark sky, I hope.
 
Let's just for a second ignore the offline problem itself.
Was I really the only one who had great hopes for the future of the game because an offline version would have been mod-able?
I thought that the community would come up with amazing mods that would take the responsibility a little bit away from the devs, because in the end everything would be possible.
Now that this happend we ended up with a system like WOW, where the only new content has to come from Frontier
 
Last edited:
Mods are the same the world over - always the voice of reason - or giving you the reason to button it up lol.

Seriously I post on Australian rules football forums and political forums and while you may be dismayed by the lack of respect some show here you would be horrified by our political forums.

To be fair the way we talk and debate issues in Australia among mates would shock a lot of people.
 
this issue has escalated and FDs are doing everything to ruin their reputation.

phase 1:
-FDs : support us , we are planning multiplayer along with offline experience

phase 2:
-FDs : thanks for the support, multiplayer experience is really cool and exciting

phase 3:
-FDs : game is soon to be released. BTW, we scrapped offline mode but multiplayer experience is really cool and exciting

phase 4:
- offline community: Why? You have promised us offline mode, we have paid for it!
-FDs : offline is not good for you and is not making us happy. It was so "tough" decision for us but we have to cut something out and multiplayer experience is so exciting. Why are you not excited?!
- online community: We got what we wanted, so shut up

phase 5:
- offline community: we feel betrayed and can not enjoy the multiplayer for various reasons. Can we get the explanation and refund
-FDs : we'll pretend nothing is happening
- online community: Take the refund and shut up! You are ruining the game!

phase 6:
- offline community: can we get some answers on refunding and why offline mode was abandoned?
-FDs : It was a tough decision. But details are very secret. What is done is done! anyway, offline mode might work if we want it to work... maybe when servers are not going to be profitable any more. ofcourse, we'll give you a refund. Now, let's talk about new anaconda skins and how exciting multiplayer is!
- online community: lets build a stake and burn the offliners, they want to destroy everything

phase 7:
- offline community: hey, all refund requests have been denied
- FDs: let's pretend we did the right thing...
- online community: see, you like the game, so shut up!

Ofcourse, that is somewhat simplified.

anyway, the saddest thing is that FDs managed to split community in two. the ones that got what they wanted for their money. And the others , who feel let down, betrayed and basically decived. Some that have paid for the game will not be able to play it at all. The others are getting something they didn't want or backed at all.

but the most tragic thing is that FDs are not doing anything to live up to the reputation they have been carefully building all this time in with this wonderfull fan base. and some of the attacks and hate expressed by some comunity members toward the people that feel dissapointed and let down are particularly disturbing.

all of us wanted what we have paid for. Offline mode was promised to be integral part of the game. Those of you who are enjoying multiplayer, try to understand. for some of the players, your fellow Elite fans, multiplayer and online mods are either not enjoyable or not playable for various reasons. And just as you enjoy multiplayer we enjoy single player. we gave money for single player offline we planned to enjoy. Now with offline singleplayer gone, we have really got something we didn't wanted. Refunds, without any tricks and law excuses would be the least FDs could do, a sign of goodwill, to try to keep their reputation within community. And that is not about someone trying to destroy the game. It is about good customer service and support. That makes the difference between developers we coul'd trust and the ones we coul'd not. The fact that you got promised multiplayer and some other guys did not get promised single player does not entitle you to attack them or hate them. We have all supported the FDs for the things they have promised us. And nobody can tell me that single player offline mode is just a minor feature, cause it's not!

the whole thing about FDs promising single player offline ,then forcing players to like multiplayer, then finally scrapping single player offline before release and after fundraising is over, then wondering why people want single player and forcing fans again to like multiplayer with words and limiting their choices leaves a really bad taste in the mouth. and we even didn't mentioned refunds requests being refused.

FDs, what have happened to you?! the last 2 years I have been pointing you out as an example of how developers shoul'd work and treat their players. It is really hard to find the words now...

Well said. And this is nothing compared to what will happen when the servers crash and burn on release. Frontier Developments has killed Elite. :(
 
Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom