Playing with 'a spirit of the game'

There are many topics about mission rewards, groups, relogging, combat logging, and of course griefing.

I do not want to judge anyone or tell them how they should play.

I would like to share with You with my opinion about playing with 'spirit of the game'. Why we have griefing? Why we have trolls? Is that our human nature? This is a fundamental question of who we really are, but i as i wrote, i would like to not judge.

What caused a community and playing game becomed toxic and who is most affected?

Unfortunately a game mechanics is fault. A game is encouraging players to cheating and brinding form them the worst primal instincts.

Lets take a look from a 'newbie' position. Our colleague who just joined the Elite, he want to play a multiplayer space ship game in difital world.
At first, if this player want to achieve *any* progress in *reasonable* time then he need to cheat. Yes, he need to stack missions. Few months ago players was brought up on using exploit at robigo and combat logging during scan, then they just need to stack passenger/combat/hauling/whatever mission through the relogging.

Ok then, lets back to the point, a short story:

Ok, our 'newbie' do not want to play that way because he is feeling this is not exactly right. Good, then he is flying in a universe full of Cutters, Vettes and people who are billionaires... well, he is taugh, he got his ASP or Python and he is trying to play fairly.
What is next? He is thinking - cool - community goals - i will try it! And what happening? Then he is being lured to the massive grindfest.. but there are some moneys so he is hauling a fish or biowaste.
During that hauling our newbie is bein interdicted by Cutter, of course destroyed (because our newbie is playing fair and do not combat logging), and then he need to pay 8 mln of rebuy, when earning from CG is around 5.
OK he thinks - i will try again. Then he is leaving a station and he is hearing 'target destroyed'... what? And station is killing him because he *incidentally* rammed a fighter-drone and got death sencence from a station. Yepp, another rebuy. Expensive for him, because he is playing fairly.

So then, game is encouraging to:
1. Cheating to make 100% fast enlarge of wallet and ranks. Stacking using relogo exploit.
2. Combat logging to avoid expensive rebuy
3. Ganking, bacause there is no punish for ganking, this is not a crime (and everyone have sacred right to be a ganker, but this should be connected with in-game consequences, like temporary lack of access to modules, weapons, ships, or destroying a ship by a strong police forces, some crime and punish system is needed, of course not everywhere in the galaxy... or temporary FSD ban for some systems, like a revoke permit)
4. Trolling, because there is a death sentence for ramming unmanned drone
5. Influenting on other group BGS through the stacking cheating in group/solo modes (to avoid a counter)
6. Gathering a progress/stuff/cash on private groups like Mobius /solo and using them with impunity against weaker players who are just trying TO PLAY A GAME FAIRLY for a God sake, in Open MMO mode, with other people.

Are humans bad? I think it depend in most of education, of how them were raised by parents. Our parents - FD - through the game mechanics and rules, taught us the cheating and using exploits is a good way to do fast progress and being more powerful.

Now tell me, is that famous 'spirit of the game'?
 
Last edited:
This game has lots of spirits - mostly poltergeists that disconnect you from the server at the least opportune times. or malevolent ones that ensure no matter how many times you spin that Engineer Roulette Wheel, it will not land on an special effect.

But I suspect you're talking about something different here... Are humans bad? Absolutely. They're small, fleshy, taste bad, have endoskeletons, bare live young, act as individuals, have no regard for their own hives, fight among themselves, are arrogant, self-absorbed, think the universe revolves around them, are not nearly as clever as they think they are, their females fear us, scream at us, and throw shoes at us. They can't weave webs, only have two eyes, very few redundant organs... a bad design over all. But what do I know, I'm just an evolved spider.
 
Nerf the game spirits! I'm tired of them waking me up at night with all of their howling. They sound exactly like my dogs, but I know it's them. Those sneaky spirits,.

I was abducted by them once. They're after our ear lobes and quartz. I know this because they measured my earlobes and one of them said to throw me back until I matured. My watch stopped working, so the only logical conclusion is that they took the quartz from it.

Spiders are cool. I saw one outside once.
 
This game has lots of spirits - mostly poltergeists that disconnect you from the server at the least opportune times. or malevolent ones that ensure no matter how many times you spin that Engineer Roulette Wheel, it will not land on an special effect.

But I suspect you're talking about something different here... Are humans bad? Absolutely. They're small, fleshy, taste bad, have endoskeletons, bare live young, act as individuals, have no regard for their own hives, fight among themselves, are arrogant, self-absorbed, think the universe revolves around them, are not nearly as clever as they think they are, their females fear us, scream at us, and throw shoes at us. They can't weave webs, only have two eyes, very few redundant organs... a bad design over all. But what do I know, I'm just an evolved spider.

Brilliant!

I do have one small point of contention. And that is, once you get over the smell, I find humans rather tasty!:D

LLaP

S1E
 
This game has lots of spirits - mostly poltergeists that disconnect you from the server at the least opportune times. or malevolent ones that ensure no matter how many times you spin that Engineer Roulette Wheel, it will not land on an special effect.

But I suspect you're talking about something different here... Are humans bad? Absolutely. They're small, fleshy, taste bad, have endoskeletons, bare live young, act as individuals, have no regard for their own hives, fight among themselves, are arrogant, self-absorbed, think the universe revolves around them, are not nearly as clever as they think they are, their females fear us, scream at us, and throw shoes at us. They can't weave webs, only have two eyes, very few redundant organs... a bad design over all. But what do I know, I'm just an evolved spider.

Rep to you sir, At first I was agreeing with a slight concern with a few things said; then that took a turn that made me laugh.


To answer the OP; Humans are bad, yes, but they have shining moments. If you play the game in open long enough you'll come across both ends of the spectrum.

I've had BH players desperately try to save me from an Annie when things went south for me and they noticed, I've had people come to my rescue as I drift through space with no fuel, I've had another player sacrifice himself to a station so I would be able to dock at the only station in a system while being wanted allowing me to refuel and leave, among many other things. However I've also had player kill me for nor reason with a 200 wanted status from accidental friendly fire, players target and destroy me so they could make sure they get the bounty on that wanted ship in the lawless system, I've had players interdict and destroy me outright while trading, and again among other things.

Humans, by nature, are both good and evil; it all depends on many things which takes over.

With your question about spirit of the game; are all of the above spirit of the game? In all honesty, yes. I think it is. Humans have a right to be who they want; whether that be the hero or the villain. And I in all honesty feel like the community of Elite varies well enough to feel right.

About FD allowing "exploits" is something different and has nothing to do with spirit of the game IMO, but a lack of mechanics that allow the "exploits" to be more of a tolerable work-around.
 
Never done anything like that. Anyway, looks like all your issues are related to multiplayer. Simple fix (not necessarily the best): Remove it.
 
When I first started the game (after release) I sat in my Sidewinder for approx 4-5 days (with rather few hours being pumped into the game whithin this timeframe) getting the Hauler and than the Viper and approx a month later the Cobra MK3 felt awesome, It was in a time when I did missions for 2000CR and such, and never thought of "Logging" to gain missions or just to get away from a scan... Now i have my conda and am still far from achieving any rank of Elite, YES i keep bigger brakes than I used to but thats mostly because of other games (tons of those actually... backlog is a pain) Elite is one of those games that just sticks with me over the year(s), its an experience worth taking in and not "min maxing" out... its not World of Warcraft, I dont want to be the biggest baddest thing in the galaxy (the thargoids are going to be anyway :p) Just wanna play it in "my own way" which means not by following some guide on the internet, not by copying what the "meta" is... that is not what i like and that is why i love elite, it lets me get away with playing like that.

A friend of mine is the polar opposite of this ideology... and when the engineers dropped he dropped as well as "Omg the grind" me? i just flew around, did my missions, scavanged here and there... and now not too long ago my conda just received its A category FSD with a 5rated mod for jumprage (rolled 40% range :p) only had materials for one, only rolled once... enjoying the game and meantime unlocking stuff is how i feel elite wont get boring... The keyword i guess is... Dont Grind? :)
 
There are many topics about mission rewards, groups, relogging, combat logging, and of course grefing.

I do not want to judge anyone or tell them how they should play.

Yet you then go on to claim certian ways of playing the game or exploits and or cheating.

Lets take a look from a 'newbie' position. Our colleague who just joined the Elite, he want to play a multiplayer space ship game in difital world.
At first, if this player want to achieve *any* progress in *reasonable* time then he need to cheat. Yes, he need to stack missions. Few months ago players was brought up on using exploit at robigo and combat logging during scan, then they just need to stack passenger/combat/hauling/whatever mission through the relogging.

Robigo was not an exploit, when you sold the slaves you took a reputation hit.



OK he thinks - i will try again. Then he is leaving a station and he is hearing 'target destroyed'... what? And station is killing him because he *incidentally* rammed a fighter-drone and got death sencence from a station. Yepp, another rebuy. Expensive for him, because he is playing fairly.

So speeding, AKA gaining a time advantage and putting others at risk is playing fairly?

So then, game is encouraging to:
1. Cheating to make 100% fast enlarge of wallet and ranks. Stacking using relogo exploit.
2. Combat logging to avoid expensive rebuy
3. Ganking, bacause there is no punish for ganking, this is not a crime (and everyone have sacred right to be a ganker, but this should be connected with in-game consequences, like temporary lack of access to modules, weapons, ships, or destroying a ship by a strong police forces, some crime and punish system is needed, of course not everywhere in the galaxy... or temporary FSD ban for some systems, like a revoke permit)
4. Trolling, because there is a death sentence for ramming unmanned drone
5. Influenting on other group BGS through the stacking cheating in group/solo modes (to avoid a counter)
6. Gathering a progress/stuff/cash on private groups like Mobius /solo and using them with impunity against weaker players who are just trying TO PLAY A GAME FAIRLY for a God sake, in Open MMO mode, with other people.

1. Not an exploit.
2. Using the menu system you can legitimately log out very quickly, this is not an exploit. Even though I would love it to be set at five minutes.
3. There is punishment, but it is weak and quite easy to avoid if you know what you are doing.
4. Don't speed. You get both audio and visual warnings when speeding. Your HUD tells you and the station traffic control tells you. If you speed and hit something then the station kills you, it is 100% your fault. Kill you speed, not your credit balance.

What I've read here is that you have a self impossed set of rules and all those that don't follow it are either cheats, trolls or exploiters. Perhaps you need to learn and understand the mechanics and the spirit of the game. I'll leave you with two direct quotes from Elite's store:

Elite: Dangerous Store said:
PLAY YOUR WAY
400 BILLION STAR SYSTEMS. INFINITE FREEDOM. BLAZE YOUR OWN TRAIL.

Upgrade your ship and customize every component as you hunt, explore, fight, mine, smuggle, trade and survive in the cutthroat galaxy of the 34th century. Do whatever it takes to earn the skill, knowledge, wealth and power to stand among the ranks of the Elite.

Elite: Dangerous Store said:
COMBAT

Help rebels overthrow an oppressive regime, put down a rebellion, or just hunt other Commanders. Your combat skills will keep you safe in a cutthroat galaxy.

- - - Updated - - -

Forgot to reply to 5 & 6.

5. FDev put in solo/group and allow those in those modes to influence the BGS. Not cheating, as it is clearly endorsed by the people who make ED.
6. See #5.
 
Last edited:
Tell me, do you think a stricter crime and punishment system is going to really scare off anyone devoted to what you call "ganking"? FWIW such system will attract more people who want to have proper difficulty while having a blast playing their favourite role, like a "l33t-pirate-ganker". There are a hundred different places where you can find human pilots and by the time you've committed crimes and got punished in every single one of them you interest in the game fades anyway. That is even before you got caught. Now, what kind of punishment? OK, I am fined for everything I have in my bank account for assaulting one player. Finally. Now they actually have to catch me to claim the fine. So, let's say in the end they caught me. They took all my cash and I am back to square one with a sidewinder and no money. Cool. What is your guess I am going to do next? The answer is in the spoiler below, but take your time, try to guess...

That's right! I am going to earn some cash for a decent pirate ship, which shouldn't take longer than a day anyway, and then I am back to ganking to a heart's content.

Surprising?

I have an opinion about a way to rid ED of "gankers". The game has to have facilities, where wings and good individual players can be pitted against each other on a regular basis. Precious resources, clans, ownership of certain stations, POI, areas of space, industry..whatever. A working, flowing economy. If that eventually arrives, there is no more need to gank some newb somewhere, instead, real agenda is created. You can forge a band of criminals and take an area of space for yourself, then another band arrives and kicks you out. You can accumulate various resources and keep expanding until you are on a collision course with another group. The war for the worlds begins and most will die, but such is life. [insert favourite war theme here] Even in this case "ganking" will persist imo, but at least it will finally gain a purpose and probably a counter, if done right.

Or, you can have a theme park, where you can do a bit of this, a bit of that just for the fun of flying a cool looking spaceship through a very beatiful galaxy, where other people can be met once in a while and tiny meaningless wars can be fought. Then you do some ganking, log out and forget about the whole thing for a few months. Come back for a new patch.

Me? I am fine with both options. Explored, pirated, bounty hunted, traded and wandered. Killed one hundred players and never been killed by another player through 1k hours of ED. Perhaps I was too cautious, but that's my thing. ;)

Short version: need to remove underlying reasons for ganking (which is boredom) and all will be well.
 
Sooo much moralising happening on this board atm makes want to turn to the darkside and go on a gankfest.

[rant] Guys I'm playing this game how I want to, keep your in-game morals to yourself because part of the reason people like to play games is to get away from finger wagging politically correct jerks and their gad awful safe spaces etc etc. [/rant]
 
Never done anything like that. Anyway, looks like all your issues are related to multiplayer. Simple fix (not necessarily the best): Remove it.

So why should people how like to play with friends have a feature they use and enjoy removed? Your post is literally the most ridiculous thing I have seen this year on the forum. I can just assume you are trolling.

- - - Updated - - -

part of the reason people like to play games is to get away from finger wagging politically correct jerks and their gad awful safe spaces etc etc. [/rant]

Erm, speak for yourself lol. That might be YOUR reason, I play games because I enjoy them.
 
You cannot have a PvP and PvE game co-existing. One will kill off the other.

PvE should be Offline Mode. Frontier could wipe/reset the whole galaxy to start, give everyone a clean start, and the PvE players would gladly pay up for a AAA price to never be bothered with other players again. Sliding NPC difficulty, of course. We will gladly accept the insults, and bid the PvP crowd a fond farewell.

It's only the Holy, Must Not Be Mocked, All Worship The Background Simulator decision at the beginning of development that keeps this game from satisfying both audiences.
 
You cannot have a PvP and PvE game co-existing. One will kill off the other.

PvE should be Offline Mode. Frontier could wipe/reset the whole galaxy to start, give everyone a clean start, and the PvE players would gladly pay up for a AAA price to never be bothered with other players again. Sliding NPC difficulty, of course. We will gladly accept the insults, and bid the PvP crowd a fond farewell.

It's only the Holy, Must Not Be Mocked, All Worship The Background Simulator decision at the beginning of development that keeps this game from satisfying both audiences.

I really hope this is meant to be funny. Wipe the galaxy, yeah, loose half the playerbase in one easy hit :p

As someone who does both PvE and PvP (and saw the Op on the CG system not a few hours ago as he was pirating traders and I was evading him and others in my trading cutter), all good fun, all good gameplay. I would personally only support splitting the game in teh way you describe if they add mod support.


Either way we are fantasising here, server wipe and splitting the game isn't going to happen. Unlike other things where the mods have been very ambiguous and flexible they have repeatedly and consistently said all modes are valid and that line hasn't changed since before day 1.
 

verminstar

Banned
Brilliant OP...I especially loved the irony of claiming ye dont want to judge how others play the game, then go onto do exactly the thibng ye say yer not gonna do and judge other perfectly legitimate mechanics as cheats and exploits...?

This one of those threads best answered with a meme of a multipe face plant...apart from that...words fail me.
 
You cannot have a PvP and PvE game co-existing. One will kill off the other.

PvE should be Offline Mode. Frontier could wipe/reset the whole galaxy to start, give everyone a clean start, and the PvE players would gladly pay up for a AAA price to never be bothered with other players again. Sliding NPC difficulty, of course. We will gladly accept the insults, and bid the PvP crowd a fond farewell.

It's only the Holy, Must Not Be Mocked, All Worship The Background Simulator decision at the beginning of development that keeps this game from satisfying both audiences.

Hmm, that seems a bit drastic to me. How about another idea: you wipe your save and start over in Solo?
 
Brilliant OP...I especially loved the irony of claiming ye dont want to judge how others play the game, then go onto do exactly the thibng ye say yer not gonna do and judge other perfectly legitimate mechanics as cheats and exploits...?

This one of those threads best answered with a meme of a multipe face plant...apart from that...words fail me.

Triple+facePalm.jpg


Like this?

- - - Updated - - -

Even Jesus can't take anymore of this guff.

o-JESUS-WEPT-facebook.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom