Game Discussions Star Citizen Discussion Thread v12

Its one thing i'm actually grateful to @LittleAnt for, as he did clear up my misconception that large space battles were planned from the start. Of course, the rest of the stuff he say is tripe though :D

Well they sold the Idris from the start. The Javelin from 2014 etc. They sold the principle of large scale capital ship combat before they had any kind of clue how they could deliver it.

That’s still crap ¯\(ツ)/¯
 
I went to a pricey restaurant on my anniversary last week (we dined outside in a secluded corner, because efff exposure risks - and also, I'm sure my attire put off the regular clientele).

I ordered a chicken dish and it was raw on the inside. My wife specified her allergies and her dish still contained tree nuts upon inspection. Now, I'm not a trained chef, and know nothing about braising. I'm not even a good saucier.

Should I have complained or held the kitchen staff accountable?

Or should I have ignored the order and the menu descriptions?

TL;DR Some SC backers love black and white thinking.
 
Same. I handed out copies of my breakout game on tape to my friends when i was a kid! Oh, and a text based adventure game!

Me: 2 CIG: 0
Well on that category Me and my friends: 2 CIG: 0

Couple of nice text based adventures programmed with Pascal at 1990's :D We even did pretty extensive bug testing, program did not puke with unexpected commands and so on. Found some years ago old source code, and it did even compile on modern Linux :) (Ran too...so even Linux version :D Does that count as separate release? )
 
I went to a pricey restaurant on my anniversary last week (we dined outside in a secluded corner, because efff exposure risks - and also, I'm sure my attire put off the regular clientele).

I ordered a chicken dish and it was raw on the inside. My wife specified her allergies and her dish still contained tree nuts upon inspection. Now, I'm not a trained chef, and know nothing about braising. I'm not even a good saucier.

Should I have complained or held the kitchen staff accountable?

Or should I have ignored the order and the menu descriptions?

TL;DR Some SC backers love black and white thinking.
C'mon man. Be fair. The restaurant was still iterating the menu!
 
At this stage I have actually released more games than CIG. :ROFLMAO:

Same. I handed out copies of my breakout game on tape to my friends when i was a kid! Oh, and a text based adventure game!

Me: 2 CIG: 0

Well on that category Me and my friends: 2 CIG: 0

Couple of nice text based adventures programmed with Pascal at 1990's :D We even did pretty extensive bug testing, program did not puke with unexpected commands and so on. Found some years ago old source code, and it did even compile on modern Linux :) (Ran too...so even Linux version :D Does that count as separate release? )
I won't let you silence the existence of Hyper Vanguard Force, you mean people!
 
I won't let you silence the existence of Hyper Vanguard Force, you mean people!
oh wow… I totally forgot about that one.

I think the score is tied… how was the other one called? something something carrack crew?

edit: Actually, CIG might be ahead… wasn’t there a mini-game where you had to locate the pirate in the star map and decide if you ignore or report location to advocay?
 
Last edited:
Serious question - do planets in Star Citizen at least try to simulate orbital mechanics? As in, do the stars and moons rise and set (as seen from a planet's surface), or is it like NMS and Space Engineers where the entire skybox is static and Apollo drives the sun around in his chariot?
 
Serious question - do planets in Star Citizen at least try to simulate orbital mechanics? As in, do the stars and moons rise and set (as seen from a planet's surface), or is it like NMS and Space Engineers where the entire skybox is static and Apollo drives the sun around in his chariot?
AFAIK, no…
 
Have you?

The difference between us is that I’m citing developers, and CIG’s own claims, to support my arguments.

Whereas you’re just pulling claims out of your… magic bag of hopium ;)
Not entirely, they have said that SM requires a bunch of prerequisites:
1641662602836.png

Which suggests designing a 'dynamic meshing' system that ignores that rule was foolish. And claiming a single shard is still possible, with the proposed architecture & gameplay, is an incredibly dubious 'carrot on a stick'. Also known as lies ;)
Yes
You are forgetting the scaling required:

  • No capital ships with interiors have been tested in the PU. (And those without interiors hammer performance as it is).
  • How do multiple capital ships engage with 80+ players & NPCs each? Given performance is currently poor with less, and server caps aren’t expected to get beyond 100, they’re going to hit various walls at once.
You can test this with loading up a bunch of 890 jumps on a server as they've said an Idris or Javelin with an Interior makes pretty much the same performance impact as an 890 Jump. A CIG dev said this on reddit, altough I cannot be bothered right now to scower through endless posts to get a link to it. Out of my experience, the server doesn't care too much about a couple 890s in it.
 
AFAIK, no…
Well that's rubbish... I give Frontier a lot of gruff for not being able to do simple things in Elite, yet they nailed realistic solar systems in a way I guess nobody else can. Is it really that hard? I get why in a game like Space Engineers doesn't, where planets are made out of destructible voxels, and No Man's Sky doesn't even pretend to be a real space simulator, but in a game (Star Citizen) where they simulate liquid dynamics when you swirl your coffee, they can't be bothered even faking planetary orbits?

That just leaves me speechless..
 
Serious question - do planets in Star Citizen at least try to simulate orbital mechanics? As in, do the stars and moons rise and set (as seen from a planet's surface), or is it like NMS and Space Engineers where the entire skybox is static and Apollo drives the sun around in his chariot?

Planets rotate, but they don’t orbit. (IE they don’t orbit the sun / moons don’t orbit planets etc).
 
Back
Top Bottom