I think most of the all group think that private groups and solo players really effect the game for them, what they don't appear to understand is that there are thousands of other players playing in other all instances that are effecting their game but continue to say that its private/solo that is destroying it, maybe they should change the discussion to why are other all instances spoiling my game and stop blaming the private/solo player.
Same thing really. This could go either way, point is, people in Open want Solo players out of their experience, and people in Solo the opposite. Just sepparate the damn things somehow...
- - - Updated - - -
The problem is that ED offers several career choices, only one of them involve PvP and it isn't the most rewarding. I'll try to explain how I think :
- people will PvP (for powers or whatever reason that involves a highly PvP environnement)
- richest players will have the choice of taking expensives ships to battle, with the higher insurance cost. Note that a lot of players won't have that choice and the ship they'll bring to battle is the only one they own.
- players will die. It's bound to happen in a PvP environnement. What will happen when they'll realize they won't be able to pay their insurance next time they die ?
- they'll stop PvP'ing and try to earn money. Let's say they'll trade, as it is the fastest way to make money at the moment.
- why should they do it in Open, where they would be under the threat of pirates/psycho killers ?
I also understand that Dayz appeals to a public, but does ED appeals to the same public ?
Have you tried it ? Does it work ? I certainly wouldn't afk in a conflict zone. In a RES maybe, but not a CZ.
cant try it cuz quivira is broken

. But yeah, i believe most of people, like me, came here for the freedom this game offers. I do not have to sign anywhere if i want to be a trader, i can just do it. Just like in dayz, i dont have to sign anywhere if i want to be a bandit or hero, or trader for that matter.
Related to the PvP things: that is exactly what im saying. The discrepances between mods are too damn high. I also play in Solo or Mobius, cuz Open has lag. I like being torn apart by human players(but then again i like dayz) but as you say, there is no reason to play Open. Just like there is no reason for a parallel universe to interract with another one (solo and open) as parallel lines never touch
