I care about the whole Elite vs Star Citizen debate as much as I care about the Star Trek vs Star Wars debate. Which is to say not at all. We're not bound to one or the other. It's perfectly permissible to like both.
That being said, Star Citizen is still in pre-alpha after all these years, still loaded with bugs, and still only spinets of activity. It's easy to be beautiful and flashy when you can focus on just a couple of really flashy locations instead of a huge galaxy of flashiness. It's a bunch of fancy tech demos and loads of promises that are as of yet still unfulfilled. And that's not even counting the sheer amount of controversy surrounding it's development and the frequent number of times many aspects stalled and had to start fresh. And the very core problem of Star Citizen is Chris Roberts. I'm sure he has a fantastic development team, but Chris likes to promise the world and seems to be utterly incapable of focusing on polishing one aspect at a time. Every time there's a new tech show, he shows off yet another brand new barely functional feature that woos their fans ... who seem to forget that the game's existing features still have many performance issues and are very incomplete in content.
And this is the not the first time he does this either. I played the hell out of Freelancer and enjoyed that game a great deal. But the only reason any one of us got a chance to play is because Microsoft had to put their foot down, boot Chris from it's development, and finally finish the game because, much like Star Citizen, Chris promised the world and the game was going nowhere after years of development.
Don't get me wrong ... if he DOES deliver on all his promises, even if the game comes out 10 years from now, I'll most certainly buy the game. But there's no way in hell I'd invest in that game at the current stage as reality in no way seems to match up to the hype.
Not to mention one simple fact no one seems to ponder: Given how incredibly long it's taking SC to launch (or even hit Alpha, let alone Beta), odds are Elite *will* have atmospheric landings and space legs by then. We already know it's in the game's long term goals and could show up two or three years from now. Does anyone really expect Star Citizen, with both the single player game as well as the persistent universe, to launch by then?