Visual issue with Centrifugal Force in Coriolis stations

By artificial gravity, you mean spinning stuff around right?

Not a magic gravity generator? Pretty sure the lore's always been those don't exist in the elite universe.
I love being in the company of nerds who have to correct one another,
Ahem,

Nore did I state that artificial gravity was a magic gravity generator, I merely mentioned Artificial Gravity as in its dictionary definition -
“made or produced by human beings rather than occurring naturally, especially as a copy of something natural.”
And because the in-game explanation is the
“Spinning stuff” aka the Coriolis Effect
Is also by definition “In physics, the Coriolis force is an inertial or fictitious force that acts on objects that are in motion within a frame of reference that rotates with respect to an inertial frame. In a reference frame with clockwise rotation, the force acts to the left of the motion of the object.”
The coriolis force, which is a fictitious force is used to artificially recreate the effect of gravity which is a of course a natural phenomenon, In short spinning stuff falls under the mantel of Artificial Gravity.

David Braben was using the example of Gravity, albeit“Artificial Gravity” being a premium luxury item. So the further away from the centre of the spin the more expensive the living space becomes because the coriolis effect would be stronger.

This explanation, is also why the imperial capital ships have and In built centrifuge to show off how amazing luxurious the Imperial fleet gets it.

It is soooo good to know there are other devotees of the lore here, it appears I’m in good company.
 
Last edited:
The game wasn't built to stand up to this level of scrutiny. That's all this is. It's possible that with Odyssey (and the switch to a FPS level of presentation), that there will be some graphical tweaks to improve the sense of internal self-consistency, but I doubt it because the overall trend since release has been to pay less and less heed to the world building aspects of the game. I mean, your observations about window placement are the kind of thing Frontier would have noticed and fixed a long long time ago if it were the sort of thing they care about. In the meantime, they've given us stuff like this:

maxresdefault.jpg


Which pretty much tells me that none of the people NOW working on Elite have any clue about the underlying 'Sci' in this sci-fi game, and they're definitely not interested in building anything into the game going forward which takes notions like variable gravity into account. (exhibit "B" is the coffee machine on the Krait, btw).
You appear to be making assumptions that the krait coffee dispensing apparatus and cups rely on gravity with cups open which are “open”

Even with today’s tech news we have drinking sachets with straws, beakers/thermos flasks with self sealing one way valves.

We are talking 1000 years into the future with cold hydrogen Fusion being an every day occurrence that can power stellar and interstellar flights and actual holograms
Hovering in thin air, or even in a vacuum.
We (in game lore) have 3D printing nanotechnology ;
are you telling me they won’t have developed a smart transparent bio polymer that “seals” a cup or a glass, and follows the shift in electric charge generated by the nerves of human skin unseals and bonds temporarily with the users lips allowing them to drink.
But you know, straw with clasp is still available
 
Last edited:
You appear to be making assumptions that the krait coffee dispensing apparatus and cups rely on gravity with cups open which are “open”

Even with today’s tech news we have drinking sachets with straws, beakers/thermos flasks with self sealing one way valves.

We are talking 1000 years into the future with cold hydrogen Fusion being an every day occurrence that can power stellar and interstellar flights and actual holograms
Hovering in thin air, or even in a vacuum.
We (in game lore) have 3D printing nanotechnology are you telling me they won’t have developed a smart transparent bio polymer that “seals” a cup or a glass, and follows the shift in electric charge generated by the nerves of human skin unseals and bonds temporarily with the users lips allowing them to drink.
But you know, straw with clasp is still available
You’re being dumb on purpose, but unfortunately you’re still nowhere near as dumb as the game. There’s a regular open top ceramic coffee mug hanging from a hook on the side of the coffee machine. It is always hanging “down”. There’s also two cookies sitting on the countertop; they don’t move or float away no matter what you do with your ship.

“No artificial gravity” is just something the devs say to make their game world sound different and “more scientific” than something like star wars. It is not reflected in the game design, the artwork, or the world building at all.

Exhibit C: everybody’s hair. There’s more but it only matters if you think it matters. If you want to headcanon all of it as magnetic smart nanoparticles embedded in everything and pulling all of it down exactly as if we were in 1G on an ordinary day on Earth; fine go ahead and do that. But I personally would call that artificial gravity at that point anyway.
 
You’re being dumb on purpose, but unfortunately you’re still nowhere near as dumb as the game. There’s a regular open top ceramic coffee mug hanging from a hook on the side of the coffee machine.
How do we know that's the case? It could be a metal cup with a glaze, attached to a magnetic holder :p

Now, the biscuits on the other hand...
 
You’re being dumb on purpose, but unfortunately you’re still nowhere near as dumb as the game. There’s a regular open top ceramic coffee mug hanging from a hook on the side of the coffee machine. It is always hanging “down”. There’s also two cookies sitting on the countertop; they don’t move or float away no matter what you do with your ship.

“No artificial gravity” is just something the devs say to make their game world sound different and “more scientific” than something like star wars. It is not reflected in the game design, the artwork, or the world building at all.

Exhibit C: everybody’s hair. There’s more but it only matters if you think it matters. If you want to headcanon all of it as magnetic smart nanoparticles embedded in everything and pulling all of it down exactly as if we were in 1G on an ordinary day on Earth; fine go ahead and do that. But I personally would call that artificial gravity at that point anyway.
I was aiming for a polymer that works along the idea of strengthening the surface tension.
What you perceive is a 20century Mug, because what other alternative does your 20century brain have to base it.
As you pointed out they point vertically down like they are held in place. It doesn’t even jiggle.

Now ‘some’ might say this is lazy 20th century artist making 3D static 3D art asserts and many might agree. I included Myself in that said group until you called me a special kind of stupid and I would prefer you to rethink insulting people on the internet as that tends to get them to retort ;)

ahem

So if you really pay attention to the physics of how to handle the Coriolis effect (Inertia working on moving bodies)l - you understand
Already that everything that can be fastened down to any MUST be fastened down or I can float around.

Babylon5 and the expanse showed this off well.

As someone pointed out in one of the final episodes of the second season of B5, Captain Sheridan jumps from the train carriage. Inside the train are handles everywhere and signs warning for low-gravity environment, because the coriolis effect is so weak.
So he can jump out and be almost weightless with very little momentum (except from the jump and the accompanying shockwave of explosion) giving him velocity to gently float to the side of the station which from Sheridan’s perspective is like being lower onto a tread mill filled with city building speeding along at 60miles an hour sidesways.

More to the point, The expanse (season 3?) shows combat manoeuvres when a tool locker door panel wasn’t secured properly and opens up with one pitch and roll, then the tool draw flies open with the next sending nuts, bolts, Screw, screw drivers, drills, wrenches, hammers gently cascading into the middle
Of the cabin.
Then came a flip and heavy burn from the pilot. The tools stay still maintaining their original trajectory, minding their own business just floating around and that damn ship cabin and its occupants just boosted away a few 100m a second.
from the occupants perspective they had mallets and drills flying round like bullets, taking out air-hose pipes and causing damage all over the cabin.
Source: https://youtu.be/mH1NIIx41kU

Just a straight up awesomeScene.

so yeah, “cups” do not “hang” they are fixed and secured into place before takeoff,
Otherwise you get some high-velocity FOD (Royal Airforce-term for Foreign object Damage).

Also the mugs on the rocinate stick to consoles and walls because they have magnets On the bases.
Due to surface tension, liquids cling to the surfaces they are in contact with and don’t float around in perfect bubbles like in the Hollywood movies.
Source: https://youtu.be/lMtXfwk7PXg


So you just need to increase the surface tension to keep the coffee in the cup. But even under
1/3G liquids stay “down”.
Or Are You a special kind of stupid like me who airs opinions without evidence to back them up?
 
Last edited:
Have you seen the concept art for the standard hexagonal(?) decagonal(?) star ports? How hollow they actually are, and the internal structure are built in stepped terraces.
Since you have fusion, the lighting is effectively Natural sunlight :) which can also be the external walls acting as sky and lightsource with a faked day/night cycle, so your got your hanging gardens over the terraces.

And going off the big greenhouses as well, these do need to be pointed outwards in micro-gravity
Because thanks to another ISS experiment we know plants and foliage grows towards light and heat, irrespective of gravity or even in micro-gravity environments.
 
Back
Top Bottom