Hm, probably Gunship, Battle Isle, Civilisation, Master of Orion 2, SM Alpha Centauri, Rome Total War and Mass Effect.
1. Heroes of might and magic III (PC)
Why?
- a very deep and complex game (multiple layers of interconnected and interdependent gameplay elements)
- well balanced
- very rich in content, both gameplay wise (very long campaign + tens of single scenarios + map editor/creator + random map generator + very active and creative community) and graphics/assets wise (multiple models for a single type of thing - just because it adds variety, multiple races, each with its own unique city and units, multiple land types etc.)
- beautiful graphics that have aged incredibly well
- timeless varied music, that is some of the best in the industry and great memorable sound effects https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7PddNlM8kY
- attention to detail all around
- excellent both in solo and in multiplayer
- weather you like short sessions, or 12 hours marathons this game provides, each move is full of hard choices that have meaningful consequences, each minute is fun
- competition does not even come close, even after all those years
2. Frontier: Elite 2 (A500)
Why?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=srlJVE50mCI&list=PL9E1E1F7AA6193498
I don`t think I can say it better that this video (its not mine, thanks to Jim from JIMPLAYSGAMES for making this series) but i`ll try to be consequent
- A marvel, a technical achievement on many many levels,
- seamless planetary landings (unlike E), orrery map, stardreamer
- newtonian physics and flight model based on them,
- unique well defined world
- Excellent use of PG and RNG, it added so much to the game, (Ehas a nice galaxy too but it seems that PG hinders the game more than it adds to it)
- Nice colour palette, excellent for flat shaded polygons
- One of the best intro sequences in gaming
- fitting music
- has many many "firsts", a truly groundbreaking game
For me elite games go like this Fe2 >>>>>>> FFE > Elite dangerous = elite
Fe2 is simply a masterpiece. Eis In my opinion a very poor lacklustre and unimpressive game in comparison especially if you take into consideration the amount of computing power we have today vs 1993...
3. Pirates! (A500 version)
Why?
- Pirates! treasure hunting! evil Spaniards! count me in!
- very nice depiction of the era, close to reality and well grounded in history
- excellent atmosphere
- open ended gameplay that unlike some other game manages to provide motivation and a sense of accomplishment
- working background simulation that reacts to player input as well as historical events
- allows for short or long sessions without huge boredom, has well balanced progression
- a simple, self explanatory yet hard game with a well designed learning curve
4. Quake 3: Arena
Why?
- excellent weapon palette design/choice - i don`t think it can be topped, its just perfect as it is, all possible roles fulfilled
- excellent map design (for the most part)
- well ageing graphics
- Controls/movement - its just perfect
- good training/solo mode
- quick and fun, keeps you on your feet all the time, makes your heart race
- active community
- quick sessions, pure fun every second
- John Carmack
5. Dune 2: The battle for Arrakis
- AMAZING atmosphere
- one of the best soundtracks ever, very memorable synths ( just check it out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WKBjmJCBHw, great for flying in Elite too)
- despite some technical limitations, the gameplay is still top notch and fun on its own, it started the - today classic - RTS formula which only got slightly updated
- Arrakis, Spice, and sandworms - enough said
- Very nice graphics that go perfectly with the music and sounds, excellent use of very limited resources all around, stimulating to your imagination
6. GTA 1 (PC)
- flawless controlls/movement
- a huge lively sandbox that reacts instantly to your input
- pure unrestricted fun but with coherent and well structured campaign and progression
- awesome multiplayer
- humour
7. Carmageddon 1 + splat Pack (now the new carma game because its essentially the same, just improved for modern PC`s) (PC)
- Very impressive physics model that provides variety and fun (each car handles veeeery differently)
- One of the best level designs in the industry, very ingenious and full of out of the box thinking
- feeling of mass and inertia (physics again i know but it deserves another mention)
- revolutionary damage model
- nice humour
- interesting AI
8. Fallout 2 (PC)
Why?
- excellent underlying mechanics (G.U.R.P.S.)
- unique world, atmosphere, characters
- very reactive to player input and non-linear story
- to this day it seems to be the best playgroung for an RPG nut like me
- nice memorable voice acting for the era
- billions of hidden goodies
9 Black tiger (Arcade)
Why?
- very tight controlls
- superb music and graphics that have aged very well
- fast paced,
- unforgiving but fair, very rewarding
- very cool weapon and enemies
- my arcade fun fix
10. Diablo 2 (PC)
Why?
- excellent underlying mechanics
- One of the greatest Soundtracks ever, very very unique (random pick: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uS8hMuHV7Sg)
- excellent sound effects, unforgettable
- overall atmosphere
- excellent use of RNG that adds to the game and provides re-playability
- controls/movement
- very satisfying, short gameplay loops with enormous variety and richness + reasonable challange
- excellent background story with amazing presentation (via pre rendered videos and ingame monologues)
- Despite all the great deeds of Players, Evil wins!! for the second time now!!! HA!
- revolutionary multiplayer mode
I`m sure I have missed many, I used to play CIV a lot but I like HOMMIII better (they are very different but i have time for 1 turn based strategy in my life) there are also games like ,Marvel superheroes (arcade VS fighter), The settlers, master of orion, X-com, cannon fodder., Rollcage, Arcanum, Transport tycoon, Lemmings, Tekken 3, Dark Seal, Wonderboy in monsterland... a lot of them really... but the above 10 are always on my computer
From the more modern games i would have to nominate WOW and FTL, both for very different reasons but i have put a loooot of time into those two
My oh my... creating this list made me think one thing: WE HAVE REGRESSED SO MUCH when it comes to games. Graphics are better but the rest... well those games win by far with almost anything released in the last decade imo (there are some gems, but non as ground breaking as most of the aforementioned titles were in their time)