I personally dont understand the appeal of the rift so early in its development.. The low res simply sucks and although its cplteley immersive, the quality of the visuals is just not there yet.
That, and it makes using a hotas tricky.
Totally not true. That is the entire point of a HOTAS setup, to keep pilot workload down by keeping their hands on the throttle and stick and provide most common functions there. Once you've flown a few times you quickly memorize all the controls ane since they are "right at your fingertips" you don't need to look at them.
I can't speak for the Saitek sticks as I only use Thrustmaster, perhaps the button layout on the Saitek is not ergonomic but I doubt it. That being said I totally fly through the (pun intended) controls with my Warthog. I use the thumb hat on the stick to control the UI cursor and since it has a press feature, it also functions as the select button. The second the menus are up at the login screen I never need to look outside the rift unless I want to chat.
The warthog throttle even has a full mouse control (cursor) laptop style stick on the throttle for the Galaxy maps. Not sure if the other bands do but they all copy each other so likely.
---
As for visuals, there simply is no comparison due to the experience. The first time you dock at a space station in the rift or blast around a platform you'll be hooked. The experience is just that good. The head tracking is perfect and completely destroyed my ability to use TrackIR ever again. I can't even play DCS A-10 anymore as it just feels horrible.
ED due to the dark nature of the screens doesn't look that bad at all in the rift you totally get used to it. Other games like DCS A-10 and others outdoor sims like that look terrible however.
But either way, there is no way I can play without rift now, it, it was and is a game changer. Let's just hope they get the CV right or at least sell an upper model with max res. possible.
Cheers