Would it have same event to create same moon? Would same exact mechanisms evolve from random mutations? Same amount of comets with water (if that theory is even correct). Dinosaurs were already posted, but the first environmental apocalypse on earth was actually done by bacteria:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
Would love FD to actually 'simulate' life generation but... yeah, realistically it will not happen, we've seen spore and NMS
Moon has nothing to do with what I typed. Depends on what you mean by exact mechanisms. Like I said, an earth like planet. You understand how evolution works right? Its not just random mutations, the mutations have to actually have a function that helps the propagation of that mutation. So yes, on an earth like planet, and that is what I said, similar mutations would stick around because the environment would be similar.