100% Proof Planets have lost their colour. [UPDATED with official Dev reason and plan to improve]

To be fair, real color is often quite different to what you see in the system map - that is not representative at all.

Still, you can find such worlds even only using the system map...
http://i.imgur.com/bqghCP5.jpg

I appriciate what you are saying, but we are talking about HMC, and MR planets. The Rocky, Rocky Icy, and Ice objects do not seem affected by this problem.

I was just here this morning, and it's very nice, but these are Icy moons.
F7PrEHh.jpg

S1E
 
Yeah... let me know the next time you see hundreds of real HMC worlds without atmospheres you can land on. :rolleyes:

It's not the poster that needs to prove anything, he just expressed his concern. No need to derail it with such an exaggeration.
Let's not go passive aggressive about this.
EDIT: Perhaps my English fails me and you mean the opposite of what you wrote. In that case I apologies.

Beige is still bad, it was better in a previous version.
 
Last edited:
Although I agree with you on this Ant..I don't understand your attitude sometimes. I often see you say "We should trust Frontier" and "Let them decide" when it suits you, but then when you are opposed to a change, such as "Instant Transfers" or "Realistic Planet Colors", you go on a campaign to change things. It's not that i don't agree, but it's an interesting observation nonetheless.

I have never, ever once said "We should trust Frontier" and I am pretty sure I haven't said "Let Frontier decide". Anyone who knows my way of writing posts and of speaking will know that is certainly not an approach I take. I'm all for contextual discussions, rather than blind judgement calls, regardless of the issue. Of course, it's entirely up to Frontier to decide what they want to do with the game, but I would never blindly dismiss players concerns by using the words claim.

If however, there is a case where I have said that - please do show me where, because it certainly is not the sort of thing I would mean or intend to say.

(And this doesn't mean I think players should be making decisions on the future of the game, or that I am against Frontier...I am a huge supporter of them. I'm just pointing out that I haven't said what you are accusing me of saying).






Oh, and I have also never asked for the beige planets to be changed back. This is not a campaign for change. It is a campaign for information. Also please keep in mind that I have kept the video in my first post unlisted. That means it doesn't go out to my subscribers, which hopefully shows I'm not shouting and stamping here. I'm just asking (well perhaps begging :D ) for information.



P.S. I didn't campaign against instant transfers either.
 
Last edited:
It's not the poster that needs to prove anything, he just expressed his concern. No need to derail it with such an exaggeration.
Let's not go passive aggressive about this.

Beige is still bad, it was better in a previous version.

I don't care to see the discussion needlessly and erroneously derailed into realism vs. fantasy and fun.

Some people thought Pluto was just a boring ice rock too until we actually sent a camera there and showed that it isn't.
 
Last edited:
I have never, ever once said "We should trust Frontier" and I am pretty sure I haven't said "Let Frontier decide". Anyone who knows my way of writing posts and of speaking will know that is certainly not an approach I take.

If however, there is a case where I have said that - please do show me where, because it certainly is not the sort of thing I would mean or intend to say.

(And this doesn't mean I think players should be making decisions on the future of the game. I'm just pointing out that I haven't said what you are accusing me of saying).






Oh, and I have also never asked for the beige planets to be changed back. This is not a campaign for change. It is a campaign for information.



P.S. I didn't campaign against instant transfers either.

I think I've heard you say in a video that "I'm sure Frontier know what they're doing" or words to that effect... It's how it came across anyway.
 
I think I've heard you say in a video that "I'm sure Frontier know what they're doing" or words to that effect... It's how it came across anyway.

That's a bit different to telling people to have blind faith in someone. :D If I said that "I'm sure Frontier know what they're doing", (and I can imagine I certain did that say that), then I am just expressing my opinion on a specifc area of the game. That is very different to making a call for everyone to "Trust Frontier". :D

And even then, I would be very surprised if I said that in a way that dismisses out of hand any concerns someone may or may not have.
 
Last edited:
I'm in agreement with The Ant... I was going to go exploring a while back but since noticing myself that most planetoids are now beige there is simply not enough reason to. And I really want to explore, but like what's the point if everything looks the same. Some of the screenies of pre-beige Elite planets look tantalising. Such a shame. And if FD really want more people to head out to Colonia, way to take the fun out of travelling there being that there's very little of planet variation to explore along the way.
 
Leave the hair alone! Keep your beige planets, as long as I can change my hair colour as often as I do in real-life, I'm happy. ;)
 
That's a bit different to telling people to have blind faith in someone. :D If I said that "I'm sure Frontier know what they're doing", (and I can imagine I certain did that say that), then I am just expressing my opinion on a specifc area of the game. That is very different to making a call for everyone to "Trust Frontier". :D

And even then, I would be very surprised if I said that in a way that dismisses out of hand any concerns someone may or may not have.

Oh absolutely, I agree, but that's the only thing I can think of that might bear a remote similarity to "trust Frontier"
 
Gonna repeat what i said in another thread.

Even if it's realistic, which i'm not sure it is, it's ugly as sin and makes exploration rather depressing, all MR/HMC above 900-1000km radius look effectively the same, they have little color variation (grey, beige, brown) and even less terrain variation, just a smooth ball with proceduraly placed craters in a grid pattern and one or a few large, perfect frying pan craters.




To be fair, Frontier have already responded a couple times about this...

We keep getting second/third hand acounts that FD responded aboput it, but nobody has been able to provide source.

The reason why so many planets are beige is because of the light their local star sends out. Most stars in the galaxy are red dwarfs. Every planet around a red dwarf is going to look red/orange ish.
Then we have the orange and yellow stars who also give a more beige/yellow/brown colour.

But if you go on a planet around a white star, you'll see the surface looks white.

Example: Alpha cygni 2. a planet around the blue white giant star Deneb.

View attachment 114753

I don't believe they're reflecting the colors correctly, we're getting what appears to be a bad color overlay applied, instead of reflecing the light based on the material property of the surface, it just "reflects" the star color as it is, even the SRV and ship (Python with Tactical Ice pain) gets overly beiged up (or pinked up around O class stars).

oEPMqI9.jpg


My post about it in another thread:

I've found some small MRs around a O star and they're not beige, they're pink.


On their dark side, they look brown/reddish

It looks to me that the beigification of planets is a lighting issue more than a texture issue, a filter overlay that matches the star color and simply supresses the terrain colors instead of it reflecting/absorbing the light correctly.

Which reminds me a lot of the horribly terrible and awful blue filter in Battlefield 3

 
+1

I support 100% this thread. Havent been around for as long as you guys, but I had no idea the universe was so... beige.

Bring back the colors!
 
Frontier needs to fix this. The argument of realism doesn't really apply when there is no gameplay to back it up. Make it unrealistic or give us some god damn things to do frontier.
 
Frontier needs to fix this. The argument of realism doesn't really apply when there is no gameplay to back it up. Make it unrealistic or give us some god damn things to do frontier.

And it is not much color needed, just faint hints of pastell hues.

As in my moon idea:
VYMBapY.jpg

"IT IS ALL BEIGE AND GREY!" - Said the colorblind scientific instrument.

Everything has color, depending on how we choose our "visible" spectrum!
 
As an aside (which may be relevant) .... have you noticed that the FD chosen color scheme for the HUD, station announcements and services, Galnet News .... is all a shade of orange, which forms the basis of beige? Very little blue, green or grey. Are the Devs selected for the job based on their preference for red/orange? Does the FD car park have a preponderance for red/orange/beige cars ?

Disclaimer : my car is beige ... I've had it for 10 years and I now want a blue or grey one
 
Last edited:
Who cares about beige moons?

I'm just hyped about 2.4. I hope it's something instant. Instant aliens... or something.
 
Last edited:
I left the Bubble just before the beigeification started... I still love exploring but boy, none of these rocky planets attract me anymore.
Wish I started exploration long before this. :(
 
I have never, ever once said "We should trust Frontier" and I am pretty sure I haven't said "Let Frontier decide". Anyone who knows my way of writing posts and of speaking will know that is certainly not an approach I take. I'm all for contextual discussions, rather than blind judgement call,s regardless of the issue.

If however, there is a case where I have said that - please do show me where, because it certainly is not the sort of thing I would mean or intend to say.

(And this doesn't mean I think players should be making decisions on the future of the game, or that I am against Frontier...I am a huge supporter of them. I'm just pointing out that I haven't said what you are accusing me of saying).






Oh, and I have also never asked for the beige planets to be changed back. This is not a campaign for change. It is a campaign for information. Also please keep in mind that I have kept the video in my first post unlisted. That means it doesn't go out to my subscribers, which hopefully shows I'm not shouting and stamping here. I'm just asking (well perhaps begging :D ) for information.



P.S. I didn't campaign against instant transfers either.

Agony, this must be especially hard for content folks. I mean, how do you show off the game on YouTube...When every planet looks the same?
 
Back
Top Bottom