General / Off-Topic Are we brexiting?

Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
We are addicted elections all of a sudden...glad to see thats not looking likely here again, waste of time and money. I think scotland should have another indypoll, just not right now so clear enough I agree with May. Juggling internal issues on the eve of activating art 50? How in hell can this non elected PM be expected to concentrate on the most important while everyone else stamping their feet and demanding immediate 100% attention right now? Not really a good idea to be multitasking that many major crisis all at once...means everyone gets a bad deal.

You forget the old adage, 'England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity' or never waste a good crisis. It would be foolish from a tactical perspective for the Scots not to push every advantage, as this is exactly what the UK will be doing in dealing with the EU. That is the nature of the beast, also in 18 mths or so the deal will be there for everyone to see as it will be with the EU 27 and the EU Parliament, as well as the worlds media. This is when the SNP are talking about assessing same and having the indy ref.

- - - Updated - - -

You are not listening, the SNP will not call a vote now, because they have said they can not call a refendum with out UK permission, because of the United Kingdom Constitutional Law. They , the SNP have stated on TV they will wait. So your point as i said, is irrelevant.

Did I say they will call a vote now, can you find the quote. See this is the problem with persons such as yourself, you just want to have a conversation with yourself as you seem unable or unwilling to understand what other people are saying.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to Scotland you mean, the Scots have plenty of options, call a ref under international supervision as I stated or just declare a UDI as a last resort. What is Westminster going to do, dismantle the Scottish parliament and send in the military. They tried that in Ireland and they still had to go home in the end.
I wouldn't think they'd send in the military. They've not deployed the British Army in Scotland against Scots since 1919, and I'd like to think things are a lot more civilised these days. That they might close our parliament to teach us our place, though, is a real threat. Either measure would be likely to be greeted with international outrage, but I doubt they'd care too much about that.

ETA - Incidentally, that Westminster can arbitrarily close down the Scottish Parliament is another example, for anybody who still has difficulty grasping this, that the Scot/UK relationship is nothing whatsoever like the UK/EU one.
 
Last edited:

verminstar

Banned
You forget the old adage, 'England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity' or never waste a good crisis. It would be foolish from a tactical perspective for the Scots not to push every advantage, as this is exactly what the UK will be doing in dealing with the EU. That is the nature of the beast, also in 18 mths or so the deal will be there for everyone to see as it will be with the EU 27 and the EU Parliament, as well as the worlds media. This is when the SNP are talking about assessing same and have the indy ref.

The SNP can push all they want but they wont get it and it will only cause to put pressure on already strained situation with brexit. That potentially hurts everyone but thats their choice to take this action, but I still dont think they will get what they want. Just like the little sideshow here...thats all we are to them ye know...an odd little sideshow...
 
Saying that, as the EU, the SNP and others are trying desperately to stop us leaving the EU , i am waiting to see what they get up to next as the SNP are all out to try stop Brexit and many in the EU in the UK are trying very hard to do anything to stop Brexit and the referendum is just one of the tactics they are using. All very amusing to see how they are all on their knees crying and begging us to stop.

Soon as the EU collapses this nonense will stop.

Nothing of the sort is happening. Nobody is desperate to stop the UK from leaving. The rest of us are watching with some bewilderment. There is sadness yet, but increasingly also relief.

People with your particular type of attitude especially will not be missed. Enjoy your Empire 2.0.
 
Did I say they will call a vote now, can you find the quote. See this is the problem with persons such as yourself, you just want to have a conversation with yourself as you seem unable or unwilling to understand what other people are saying.

You blatantly refered to my comments that the SNP could not vote with out UK permission with.....International community and OECD.

Then you said

Irrelevant to Scotland you mean, the Scots have plenty of options, call a ref under international supervision as I stated or just declare a UDI as a last resort. What is Westminster going to do, dismantle the Scottish parliament and send in the military. They tried that in Ireland and they still had to go home in the end.

So YES you answer my comments refering they could, now how stupid do you look now? I would say idiot, But that would be stating the obvious.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't think they'd send in the military. They've not deployed the British Army in Scotland against Scots since 1919, and I'd like to think things are a lot more civilised these days. That they might close our parliament to teach us our place, though, is a real threat. Either measure would be likely to be greeted with international outrage, but I doubt they'd care too much about that.

Yes they have the power to dissolve the Parliament and if they thought they could they would, but that would be a gift to the SNP. As I stated before, Scotland is heading in one direction and that`s indy. The process is already in motion and unstoppable, the British establishment just can`t bring themselves to terms with it but it cannot be stopped, just delayed. This has all happened before, its just every generation seems to like relearning the same lessons.
 
Last edited:
Scottish deputies approved today by a vote of 69 votes against 59, that their Prime Minister Nicola Sturgeon to ask for the organization of a new referendum on the independence ... 10 votes of difference ? Well, we can not say that it is the general enthusiasm. And after Sturgeon must get the permission of May and Wesminster. We can say this evening that the referendum is buried. This evening the Brexit is a reality and the UK keeps the Scotland within it. No crazy the UK, he is not going to give the Scotland to the EU

Parliamentary Votes are by Parties. Not by Popular Vote.
Of course the Parties loyal to the UK will vote against it regardless of what anybody wants.

And well. Thats not 100% sure.
Westminster can Deny an Binding Referendum. But only if Scotland accepts it as their Overlord.
If Scotland was to hold a Non Binding Referendum and then Renounce the UK as its Overlord. It would not really need to care for Westminster.

Paris and London launch a project of missile. Paris and London today signed an agreement for the launch of the future missile project with the European group MBDA, confirming the Franco-British strategic link despite the Brexit. London and Paris have not stopped since the British vote in favor of the Brexit to mark their attachment to the Franco-British strategic relationship and to ensure that it would not be affected by the exit of the UK from the EU ---- And well, here is an additional confirmation which the EU has no interest to weaken the UK

Not really Surprising.
UK will likely be offered to take part in a European Army as well.
The EU will not give the UK the Membership Benefits when its not a Member.
So Single Market Access, Free Movement, Financial Integration etc etc come either together or not at all.

But as People have repeatedly stated. This is not a Punishment. Its simply that you cant get a Clubs Benefits when your not a Member.

Beyond that there is no reason to not have Treaties and Agreements with the UK.


Monday in Glasgow Theresa May reiterated that it was "not the right time to evoke a second referendum on the independence (On the photo, a cordial relationship between Ms Sturgeon and Ms May)

http://savepic.net/9109826.jpg

Woah. That doesnt look Cordial at all to be Honest.
If you look at their Body Language this is an more Icy Image than when Putin and Merkel sit together.

Today in front of members of parliament Mrs May will say : "We are a great union of people and nations with a history of which we can be proud and with a brilliant future"

;)

Not her First Lie on that Day *gg*

Are Scotland able to hold a simple ballot, or at least non-binding referendum, without the approval of Theresa May? A lot depends on that question.

Scotland can hold an Indy Ref without Permission. But not a Binding one.
It is however Questionable if Scotland needs to care.
Even if a non Binding Referendum was to come out for Scottish Independence. That would be an Catastrophe for the UK and it would be Impossible to Deny it without taking massive damages.

Pointless, it would not be legal and no one can check if the votes are fraudulent, as you need police and various agencies to make certian no one tampers with the ballots boxes and the votes are genuine and not massed produced by the SNP. Now the SNP are not even trusted by most Scots who are now angry the SNP have ignored their last vote to stay in the UK Union, Just as the SNP ignored the Scots who voted with the rest of the UK to Brexit as that was a UK referendum not a Scottish referendum.

I place bets that May will hold a snap General election to see if Scots vote out SNP msps before the Brexit deal ends, killing off any Referendum. She is turning out to be a clever authoritarian leader that will not give way and the Brexit talks will either make her or break her as another Thatcher.

It doesnt matter to be honest.
The Brexit Referendum was not Legally Binding either.
But once the People have spoken any Democratic State will say Follow it.

Moreover May would be stupid to run Elections now.
The SNP would come out even Stronger in the current Situation.
And it would not affect any Indy Referendums either.

Most Importand however is.
That Scotland is an actual Recognized State.
If it Demands its Independence there will be massive Pressure from the International Community.

irrelevant

It's Part of UK law that Scotland and England signed up to 100's of years ago when they created the Union. We saw the Judges in action telling scotland can not be part of the Brexit talks as it was a UK government thing, hence their threat of a referendum. Judges will also tell them that UK law states the UK government can only give them their referendum, which they will do AFTER the brexit talks. SNP accept this they have clearly stated on the TV they will wait. They Know the law.

Saying that, as the EU, the SNP and others are trying desperately to stop us leaving the EU , i am waiting to see what they get up to next as the SNP are all out to try stop Brexit and many in the EU in the UK are trying very hard to do anything to stop Brexit and the referendum is just one of the tactics they are using. All very amusing to see how they are all on their knees crying and begging us to stop.

Soon as the EU collapses this nonense will stop.

Not that we did not expect you to come spouting rubbish again. But pls keep your Fantasies to a Minimum.

Nobody is begging you. The SNP is actually threatening you lol.
But well thats typical British Imperialism I guess. Blind to what actually happens and always pointing out ones own Superiority.

Once the UK Breaks apart this Relict of the Past will hopefully be cured from such Dreams.


Also UK Laws are Irrelevant here.
If Scotland holds an non Binding Referendum. And it comes out for Independence.
Then just like with the Brexit Referendum. Denying it would be Political Suicide.
"The People have Spoken" will be the War Cry on that.
And once that happened the UK will be History either ways.

Because either it will Honor the Results and Disband.
Or it will break apart within but one Decade because of Civil War.

We are addicted elections all of a sudden...glad to see thats not looking likely here again, waste of time and money. I think scotland should have another indypoll, just not right now so clear enough I agree with May. Juggling internal issues on the eve of activating art 50? How in hell can this non elected PM be expected to concentrate on the most important while everyone else stamping their feet and demanding immediate 100% attention right now? Not really a good idea to be multitasking that many major crisis all at once...means everyone gets a bad deal.

Well it doesnt really matter to be honest.
Nothing she does would be right or wrong right now.

Brexit is likely an Sailing against an Tsunami Wave.
She could be the Best Sailor in the World. But she will still have the Ship Wrecked afterwards.
The only thing she can do is to try and Minimize the Damage and hope she stays Afloat somehow.

In this case giving Scotland Attention or not changes nothing.
The Demands of Scotland cannot be met anyways. Meaning there is little effect in her giving them attention.
The one thing she could however do. Is to stop treating them like a Colony. This behavior is currently driving more and more Voters towards saying Yes to Independence.
Her outright Denial of Scotland having any Say and her Open degradation of Scotland into an Colony without any Rights is going to bite her Big Time afterwards.



I dont get why you think its unlikely in your Area tough.
If I remember right the Seperatist Parties in your Area are Growing as well.
They seem to have a good shot at being the Local Power after next Elections. Meaning your not exactly far away from such Referendums either.

- - - Updated - - -

Yes they have the power to dissolve the Parliament and if they taught they could they would, but that would be a gift to the SNP. As I stated before, Scotland is heading in one direction and that`s indy. The process is already in motion and unstoppable, the British establishment just can`t bring themselves to terms with it but it cannot be stopped, just delayed. This has all happened before, its just every generation seems to like relearning the same lessons.


This pretty much.
Westminster Forcing new Elections in Scotland now. Would be Suicidal.
The SNP would likely gain another 10% or so because People in Scotland would feel even more annoyed than they do anyways already.
 
Yes they have the power to dissolve the Parliament and if they taught they could they would, but that would be a gift to the SNP. As I stated before, Scotland is heading in one direction and that`s indy. The process is already in motion and unstoppable, the British establishment just can`t bring themselves to terms with it but it cannot be stopped, just delayed. This has all happened before, its just every generation seems to like relearning the same lessons.

!) Incorrect the polls are the same as last time to close to call, NO one knows, so please stop waffling that you know the outcome.

2) If the English were given the vote , we would vote them out, we are now propping the 5 million scots up with UK taxes, majority being the 50 million English.

3) Scots now see with the UK out of the EU , the EU will now go federal and that means if the Scots join the EU, THEY will have to hand their country, with the rest in the next few years, into a EU super state that is being planned and with the EU openly saying that , i doubt they will leave.
 
Last edited:
!) Incorrect the polls are the same as last time to cloe to call, NO one knows, so please stop waffling.

2) If the English were given the vote , we would vote them out, we are now proping the 5 million scots up with UK taxes, majority being the 50 million English.

Your intense denial of Reality is Impressive.
 
You are not listening, the SNP will not call a vote now, because they have said they can not call a refendum with out UK permission, because of the United Kingdom Constitutional Law. They , the SNP have stated on TV they will wait. So your point as i said, is irrelevant.

Did I say they will call a vote now, can you find the quote. See this is the problem with persons such as yourself, you just want to have a conversation with yourself as you seem unable or unwilling to understand what other people are saying.

You blatantly refered to my comments that the SNP could not vote with out UK permission with.....International community and OECD.

Then you said

Irrelevant to Scotland you mean, the Scots have plenty of options, call a ref under international supervision as I stated or just declare a UDI as a last resort. What is Westminster going to do, dismantle the Scottish parliament and send in the military. They tried that in Ireland and they still had to go home in the end.

So YES you answer my comments refering they could, now how stupid do you look now? I would say idiot, But that would be stating the obvious.

I asked you where I stated they were looking to, or would vote now. I had previously outlined the SNP 18 month time frame when details of any deal would be available, and as I said the Scots would have plenty of options. But again you want to have a conversation with yourself and display your ignorance while making a flute of yourself. You`re acquitting yourself nicely on that front, well done.
 
Last edited:
Your intense denial of Reality is Impressive.

Reality: the state of things as they actually exist, as opposed to an idealistic or notional idea of them.

So no vote, latest polls say scots wont leave.... hmmmmmm.

You Still have no grasp of the words used in the English language do you? Please stop using them, you give the impression you are an EU citizen if you carry on pretending you know what the words mean :).
 
Last edited:
Reality: the state of things as they actually exist, as opposed to an idealistic or notional idea of them.

So no vote, latest polls say scots wont leave.... hmmmmmm. You Still have no grasp of the words used in the English language do you?

State of Reality.
Brexit Polls showed Victory for Remain before they happened.
Brexit Referendum was non Binding and just Advisory which Scotland can hold without Westminsters Permission.

:)

Also. I think your Failing to Understand something here.
If Westminster Denies the Indy Ref after it was formally Decided for by the Parliament of Scotland.
This is an Great Booster for Sturgeon. Because it shows once again that Scotland is considered a Colony. Driving even more People into the Independence movement ;)

Learn some Strategical thinking.



Also.
The Polls on Scotland Independence reached from 40% to 55% in Favor of Independence.
Neither side is Clear right now. And the Opinions Change Daily.

Something by far not as fickle tough. Is the Support for the SNP which has gone up tremendously and stays incredible High.
Meaning if Westminster forced new Elections Labour would be down in the Drain and SNP would be reaching incredible Numbers in Scotland.
 
Yawwnnnnnn

Why have the polls not shown a shift towards Scottish independence?



https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/01/27/why-have-polls-not-shown-shift-towards-scottish-in/

Lads such as yourself are comical, you`re like a jihadist in your logic. Firstly the SNP and Scotland are not trying to stop the rest of the UK leaving the EU, they just don`t want the same as you and wish to stay. I`d imagine the 62% vote to remain would be a slight hint in relation to that. Secondly, if you`re confident in the Scots wish to remain let the ref take place and watch in glee as the Scots vote to remain part of the UK.

Of course it could be you`re just full of and a moron.
 
Last edited:
Reality: the state of things as they actually exist, as opposed to an idealistic or notional idea of them.

So no vote, latest polls say scots wont leave.... hmmmmmm. You Still have no grasp of the words used in the English language do you?

"So there will be no vote, the latest polls say Scotland won't leave. You still have no grasp of the [words used in]*strike this the English language, do you?"

He, at least, has an excuse in that English is not his mother tongue. It is probably a bad idea to insult someones use of English whilst making seven separate mistakes within two sentences doing so.

That aside, Scotland has had a vote and has decided for a second referendum. That's an end to it. Sturgeon has the power to call a referendum whenever she feels she has the opportunity - doubtless she is going to wait to see if Brexit creates as much damage and chaos as it appears it might.

Theresa May can, of course, block such a referendum. She can also ignore any result of such a referendum. But to do so would create such anglophobia in Scotland that the relationship between the two nations would be damaged beyond repair, which would almost certainly lead to Scottish independence within a few years one way or the other.

- - - Updated - - -

Yawwnnnnnn

[h=2]Why have the polls not shown a shift towards Scottish independence?[/h]

https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/01/27/why-have-polls-not-shown-shift-towards-scottish-in/


Yes i know , there is nothing you can come back with on this FACT...lol . That why i am not an idiot and you ..........

They have.

https://www.ipsos-mori.com/research...ce-rises-as-referendum-speculation-grows.aspx
 
"So there will be no vote, the latest polls say Scotland won't leave. You still have no grasp of the [words used in]*strike this the English language, do you?"

He, at least, has an excuse in that English is not his mother tongue. It is probably a bad idea to insult someones use of English whilst making seven separate mistakes within two sentences doing so.

That aside, Scotland has had a vote and has decided for a second referendum. That's an end to it. Sturgeon has the power to call a referendum whenever she feels she has the opportunity - doubtless she is going to wait to see if Brexit creates as much damage and chaos as it appears it might.

Theresa May can, of course, block such a referendum. She can also ignore any result of such a referendum. But to do so would create such anglophobia in Scotland that the relationship between the two nations would be damaged beyond repair, which would almost certainly lead to Scottish independence within a few years one way or the other.

- - - Updated - - -



They have.

https://www.ipsos-mori.com/research...ce-rises-as-referendum-speculation-grows.aspx


Exactly.

And right now the Immediate Demand for an Referendum which Sturgeon Knew would be Blocked. Is exactly such an case as well.
She knows very well that England now behaving like an Overlord and Ignoring Scotlands Opinion is creating massive movements against staying in the UK.
 
Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom