First, I should have just read through 69 pages and repped every poster (well, a few exceptions). So...
"they maybe removed legitimate god-rolls"
- the forums have been flooded with everyone and their tail gunner doing the maths that say, "yes, it is theoretically possible that you might obtain a +100 roll on modification X, but it's a tiny little chance, akin to being hit by lightning while holding a lantern and balancing on one foot while reciting the Gettysburg Address on a calm afternoon."
- so, given that kind of odds, when you're seeing multiple god-high rolls on every module on a ship, and then on a fleet, you really can't convince anyone that you beat the odds that many times legitimately. Can't happen.
I agree with the many here; this is light punishment. Blizzard would completely nerf them. So would other game companies. I'd agree with those who would say reset their account; back to a Sidewinder and 100 credits, as a lighter punishment for trying to break the game than a complete account wipe, although I wouldn't blink at the latter.
If you're in a single-player, local game and you decide to use god-mode cheats, have a blast. Modding can be fun. But when a player is manipulating the game to produce out-of-scale enhancements to destroy other players in a multiplayer game, the H-E-double-hockey sticks to you & you deserve your karma. Don't try to break other people's games.