Disclaimer: I’ve been playing the game only since January, so I am fairly new at all this. Also apologies for the lengthy post, but I needed this to get off my chest.
After reading pretty much all the posts in this thread I can’t help but feel a certain hypocrisy shining through. Let me explain:
1. The total number of players is not equal to “the community”. A community is a group of people that love a topic (in this case “the game”) so much that they are willing to share their experiences, give and receive advice, initiate activities for smaller and larger groups and communicate well. If a game can inspire all this I believe it is a good game. A game can also try to support such initiatives and exchange, but even an online multiplayer game has certain technical limits. The logical consequence is to use resources which are better suited for such purposes. The forum, discord, Youtube and websites like EDSM, Inara, to just name a few are better suited for this. In-game chat can only go so far. That is why community project like Distant Worlds 2 have been planned almost completely outside of the game. Getting involved in such community activities is something that requires initiative, which is not a bad thing, to find out “where the music plays”. But the community is typically much smaller than the total number of players.
2. Although much critical feedback given in the thread is justified (like the missing information about the systems), you have to understand that some of this is difficult to replicate in-game. For newcomers Guardians may mean nothing and even additional information will provide little help in deciding. In fact, if information is more than two clicks away “buried” in the codex the likelihood is that people will not read it to begin with (hell, I am not even reading the GalNet news most of the times). For experienced players the information may be superfluous to some extent because they already have all the mods. The right balance is difficult to find. And, in fact, the previous Community Goals have been announced not only in-game, but also via website, mail, forum and launcher. Those are just established channels for the communication with the community and I can’t really see why this now suddenly all has to be in-game only for Interstellar Initiatives. Obviously any in-game support is positive and helps the immersion, but to expect having everything only in-game from now on for an event that is designed to invite people to participate not only in the game but in the community that surrounds it sounds hypocritical for me. That expectation actually degrades the community which enjoys the game even then when they are not playing it. And Elite Dangerous has a great community, no doubt about it.
So let’s give feedback in a polite and concise manner as is the way of adult people (as quite a few have done), but let’s also accept that some things are done better outside of the game (at least at the moment) and that it is quite normal to expect from people in order to get involved beyond the game to sign up for a forum, discord or whatever the community prefers.
Didn't you freeze to death in the Arctic, because Frontier made your food cans out of lead?