Yes, I don't decide what you have to think. Everyone is free to take into account my arguments or not. I was a little joking with my "both way", since the beginning I know not one person will change his mind here with my arguments and I don't post here to convince you. I post mainly to give the lurkers and newcomers a little different voice in the thread and give you some good news about the alpha. The bad news are quickly forwarded here, it's alas not the case for the good news...
New dust effect isn't really positive when it took $400 MUSD to get to that in a buggy pre-alpha demo that is simultaneously claimed to be released and fun game.
I recall numerous posters talking smack about ED being a mile wide and an inch deep and I've seen nothing but an inch wide and inch deep from SC. And ED has spent at absolute most 1/4 the money SC has and the difference in stability and game-play loops and actually working significant updates, couldn't be more striking.
An opinion post won't change my mind. And though my mind would be changed with a significant release of gameplay content that wasn't crashy and did not require 30 minutes of travel just to get to my ship (hello, ED has 'ship recall' function on planet surface so ship comes to me), then I might revisit my overall opinion of the game, but certainly not the opinion that it has been a totally mismanaged and over-spent cluster bordering on scam from the get-go.
So your target is maybe misplaced... some new effect like heat re-entry that is half-implemented doesn't make SC 'fun', it is just pretty looking frosting covering up a cow patty. The cow patty has to change and even then there is a big stink surrounding it that needs to be clearly acknowledged.