If we experiment on live, we WILL end up with extremely unhappy commanders from all ends of the spectrum. There is no debate to that, that is simply what it is.
Additionally, we generally do not turn on PTS unless it's time for a new major patch in the series (1.1, 1.2, 1.3, etc). We currently do not have a method available for you guys to copy your live commander data over to PTS. That is all done via a snapshot.
My views on combat logging and griefing is probably much different than the overall view of the rest of the folks at the office. Targeted harassment and targeted repeated griefing isn't fun, and simply deters a person to return to that mode of play or the game.