Fdev: here is an explanation
Players: n o e
Players: n o e
dito, i'm also heard multiply time 50% integrity warning flying a chieftain, the canopy didn't pop at 50%I don't really buy this "canopy always broke at 50% integrity". I remember having my canopy under 50% in at least 2 occasions, badly cracked but still holding.
after losing my canopy, the modul tab showed always 0% not 50%The MathS works. But it the reality is there's no change for a player. Either way it pops when it loses 15. It's really justa cosmetic change if anything. The number will read 0% instead of 50%. That's all it is really.
Hence why I assume it was a recent addition. Typically, FDev have released a totally unclear, garbled message causing nothing but confusion and have proven incapable of offering clarity. It's genuinely embarrassing now. I don't get tge impression Will understands the situation either.after losing my canopy, the modul tab showed always 0% not 50%
i found an old video that shows the 0%Hence why I assume it was a recent addition. Typically, FDev have released a totally unclear, garbled message causing nothing but confusion and have proven incapable of offering clarity. It's genuinely embarrassing now. I don't get tge impression Will understands the situation either.
That doesn't mean it broke at 0% or wouldn't have broken at 50%.after losing my canopy, the modul tab showed always 0% not 50%
true, I'm still looking for video/screenshot that's show the canopy below 50%That doesn't mean it broke at 0% or wouldn't have broken at 50%.
The evidence needed to convincingly contradict Frontier's statements would be video or screens of a canopy that is both still intact and below 50% integrity.
Might be worth opening a ticket about to get some clarification, because that definitely shows an intact canopy with integrity below 50% prior to the current change.
So your saying one rail gun shot can be enough to break the canopy and that's how fdev intended it? I know that's without MRP but still seems a touch too weak to me. It would be nice if it could at least survive say, 4 shots from a C2 rail and then with MRP it becomes stronger from there. I think it needs more than just returning the integrity to 30. It could do with double that or some engineering recipes or something just to bring it in line with other ships modules.That test simply shows that a canopy is treated as an internal for breach chances. A weapon that doesn't breach does all it's damage to the hull. Against a ship with full hull the breach chance of a rail is 40%. If that breach is successful you see that ( ) 'internal damage' status icon and the module being hit takes ~95% of the rails damage (they have extremely high portion of breach damage, which sometimes confuses people because a hit to a module often means it does virtually no apparent hull damage).
Any successful hit to a 15 integrity canopy that has no MRP mitigating damage with a C2 railgun will pop it because a C2 railgun does more than 40 damage a shot and even if you've got ~60% thermic and kinetic resists, that still enough to destroy it outright.
Cracks definitely appeared before 50% before and there could be at least two stages of cracking before failure.I'm certain that I repaired canopies from less than 50% many times, and that there was at least one (possibly 2) pre failure crack that could appear.
I wonder if the cracks would first appear at 50% rather than it being a total failure at that point, and possibly once the cracks appeared it could rng fail.
Yes. Had it happen plenty of times, long before the current change. With more standard hull resistances, a medium rail gun is perfectly capable of doing more than 30 damage to a module in one shot.So your saying one rail gun shot can be enough to break the canopy and that's how fdev intended it?
I mean I've had the canopy breach at the beginning of a fight whilst I've still had 90% hull plenty of times and that explains why. I'm a bit befuddled that fdev designed it that way or maybe there wasn't much design involved at all and it just ended up like that.Yes. Had it happen plenty of times, long before the current change. With more standard hull resistances, a medium rail gun is perfectly capable of doing more than 30 damage to a module in one shot.
On my cutter with 2 mrp there were at least 3-4 stages of increasingly cracked canopy before breach, but I was running afmu and repair limpets in cz and didn't really payed much attention. Still, I think it was the cutter when I witnessed the 7% canopyCracks definitely appeared before 50% before and there could be at least two stages of cracking before failure.
Interesting point, not to mention that percentage changes as mentioned don't really tell us much, example maybe it was like:I think they described the problem wrong, using percentages to describe issue hasn't helped.
If it broke once it went down by 15 points to 15, and never went any lower........ then.... changing to 15 to get to 0 makes sense.
But explaining it in percentage terms makes the math not work.
Are we experiencing quick canopy breakage since change?
So in the end it was much to do about nothing on these forums.Hello everyone,
We just wanted to bring awareness to a post that was made on this thread here regarding the integrity of the canopy following the launch of the April Update.
Prior to the April Update, the canopy used to break when it was at 50% integrity, however, we have fixed this so it correctly breaks at 0% integrity bringing it in line with all the other modules. Therefore, to maintain the canopy’s current functionality, we halved its integrity. This means that the canopy should be reacting in the same way as before the April Update.
We’ve tested internally and found this to be the case, however, if there are any instances where you are seeing an issue, please let us know.