There is no point in fixed frags, chaff doesnt work from close range, and the the damage penalty is stabilized by more hit on target.
Yes. I noticed in another thread that @ALGOMATIC started, that some PvP-ers criticised him for using gimballed frags, on the basis that if you're within 500m you should be able to hit with fixed (or indeed, at any range).
I agree with Mr Algomatic. Although I was not by any means the first to use an all frag loadout, I think I made some contribution to popularising the same a long time ago with (for any who remember it) my quite well-received '
Fraggy McFragface' series.
The reason I used 4 x gimbals on that FAS was that against an evasive opponent most firing opportunities are taken off-line and (obviously) at close range, hence that the firing angle can be very far from the ship's direction of travel. The relative movement of the target at close range is very great. The modest reduction in gimballed damage is more than made up for by the arc of fire and tracking advantage.
Example: I boost towards FdL. FdL boosts forwards and laterally (hence, quartering diagonally) across nose of my ship. More of the triple-burst of the gimballed frags will hit the FdL than fixed would in this situation, irrespective of piloting ability, because neither with FA-off nor FA-on can a pilot move the ship itself through the same arc as the gimbals, at the same speed.
(I do accept that you need to roll a lot to get the most out of the lower frags, though. I also used to try to get above my opponent using vertical thrust at a time when many PvP-ers didn't use thrusters half as much as now.)
However, all of that said, the reason I wouldn't dream of running an all-frag loadout nowadays is that the skill of the PvP player base is so much higher than in early 2015. There are simply too many pilots capable of avoiding all or almost all of the damage of frags. I always try to remember what Derath maintained, when he was ED's No.1 PvP-er back in the really early days
: "Outfit to fight the best, not the worst, and you'll beat the worst anyway."
I probably have enough footage to put up a vid called, "
Why frag-ramming doesn't work", simply showing me taking next to no damage from completely helpless frag-rammers. And I'm usually travelling forwards and sideways, not backwards. In fact, I'll add it to my 'ED to do' list...
EDIT:
^^Yeah.