TW3 IS huge. I took 1.5 months to finish and I did cut short on some Skellige places and paced a bit quickly through the Gunter O'Dimm DLC. I never mastered powers and used the tricks that seem to work for me: dodge, sword and shield power. Occasionally another utility spell. I just couldn't handle swapping powers in melee, nor tossing grenades, nor using the crossbow. I started very late using any oils and barely did I use any potions. Were there scrolls? I likely didn't use them much either. Consumables are difficult, I hoard them for bad times. And if I'm having bad times they rarely make a difference. I used upgrades of weapons and armour but grew tired of constantly upgrading - a recurring theme in RPGs.Witcher already felt RPG on super steroids. There's reason why I never started Witcher 3 - it just feels so huge.
Now this game feels 100 times Witcher 3. This is just positively insane. CD Projekt are positively nuts.
CDP, please take on Massive Effect type of RPG, pretty please?
When I started the last DLC I was in for a surprise and barely didn't want to end it anymore. What a finish to an epic game. 10/10 - you gotta invest time but it's basically worth every minute.
I have good things to say about DoS2. I liked the combat, story was interesting. At 1.5 months (of which I had wasted 2 weeks starting all over trying out characters) I learned that I had barely finished half of the game and quit. It was just too long.
Cyberpunk is indeed an action RPG, if you like these kind of games it is maybe for you. Think Grand Theft Auto in other setting.