Edit: If the latest patch has addressed the reasons you gave a thumbs-down review, please take the time to update your review. The devs seem to have addressed quite a few issues.
Original Post:
All seem to be related to 2.1. Just in case no one is watching steam.
IMO they should have kept them as separate products, then ED would get all positives and then only Horizons would get the negatives. The original game was amazing.
Edit: Oops they are still separate products, my mistake.
Edit: Some have challenged my data, I added a reply with mire info here:
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showt...s-down/page2?p=4131463&viewfull=1#post4131463
Steam reviews are....questionable, at best they can be a guideline but they are made by "normal" people not professional reviewers that generally work to remain neutral in their stance.
As such remember that all steam reviews and votes, good or bad can be very biased. So yeah...
lol watch this thread get filled with pro 2.1 fanboys defending a lost cause
Without wanting to insult, your stance that those that enjoy 2.1 are 'fanboys' and defending a lost cause, isn't exactly any better?
Personally I think 2.1 is fine, AI is fine, it can be tricky and dangerous, but it can also be defeated. Which on the AI part, is at least how a game should be in my book, there should be parts of the game that are difficult and filled with risk and potential loss of ship and such, quite a few posts don't seem to like this, which is up to them as personality.
And on the whole random roll thing, people seem to continually be evaluating the result compared to what they 'want' meaning in short the best, instead of comparing it to the stock items they have, or current mod that they have. Which yeah, I don't know what to say to.
Add that in almost any other game with stats and loot, there is a similar random system, and people don't complain because they check if it is worth using, or doesn't use it. Main difference is you do not see the random rolls or range like you do in Elite. When people can't see what stat ranges they can get they are apparently not prone to getting upset about not getting the best, but make due with what they get and hope to get better over time?
And no, I am not a "fanboy", ranting and raving without reason, but maybe it is because I view is that of a programmer, so I already know how most mechanics work and can see the reasoning behind them?