I don't like the new ice worlds.

I think there are differences between promo materials and in-game Odyssey... but why do people keep using comparison shots apparently taken at noon with the star overhead, while the promo shots are almost all taken in the sunset zone?

Look at the shadows! The sun in the last image is just out of frame near the limb of the planet. In the shadowless comparison images, the star appears to be straight overhead (or shadows are broken).
LOL, you think that meatball in the first image would look better at sunset?
 

Deleted member 121570

D
I posted a lot of stuff here:

Just like in Horizons, there's boring stuff on planets. It's not worse in Odyssey though. Not at all.
Extreme terrain is another thing, when it comes to totally destroyed surfaces, but other terrain features? Ravines? Sundowns and -rises? Great ground textures, rocks and vistas?
It's all there. I was sceptic at first myself, and maybe I wouldn't mind a new go on terrain creation, but what's there looks really good and much better than in Horizons. And I have seen a lot.

(Disclaimer: I am not talking about extreme features for ship-sports. Really not.)

Oh, there's some pretty shots for sure.
My own playstyle was exclusively extreme surface flying, so needless to say - Odyssey was a complete game-breaker. Knowing they're force-feeding it to everyone too later down the line is the literal kiss of death to ED for me. Fully accept though; that's just me. Such is life.

I do know plenty of folks horrified at the new surfaces too, but I also know plenty who're just fine with them. It's just a shame that the new tech couldn't please everyone at least a bit.
 
Oh, there's some pretty shots for sure.
My own playstyle was exclusively extreme surface flying, so needless to say - Odyssey was a complete game-breaker. Knowing they're force-feeding it to everyone too later down the line is the literal kiss of death to ED for me. Fully accept though; that's just me. Such is life.

I do know plenty of folks horrified at the new surfaces too, but I also know plenty who're just fine with them. It's just a shame that the new tech couldn't please everyone at least a bit.
Horrified because they all have that lowest LOD bug issue and cant see real graphics? For all others with good gpus with >6gb vram planets look great and billion times better than in Horizons. In Horizons they looked like from ps2 era with super simple landscape, now they look truly nextgenish, billion times more advanced, realistic and complex, with many biomes on each planet. Best and most realistic looking procgen planets from all space games so far.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 121570

D
Horrified because they all have that lowest LOD bug issue and cant see real graphics? For all others with good gpus with >6gb vram planets look great and billion times better than in Horizons. In Horizons they looked like from ps2 era with super simple landscape, now they look truly nextgenish, billion times more advanced, realistic and complex, with many biomes on each planet. Best and most realistic looking procgen planets from all space games so far.
Lmao. Sure. Keep on keepin' on :)
I think you probably missed the point a little earlier....
They're literally garbage.
 

Deleted member 121570

D
Your pc is garbage probably.
You seem oddly aggressive and judgemental over other people's hardware. Rest assured, my PC is well above spec, and has more than 6gb vram :D
It's also irrelevant to why I consider the planets garbage - which is 100% to do with the flattening of elevation heights and loss of terrain types.

And yes, your little turret-bound GIF does indeed show pathetically small peaks compared to what we're used to in Horizons.
So whilst not a literal pancake, it's comparatively pancake. With a touch of yoghurt shiny.
 
You seem oddly aggressive and judgemental over other people's hardware. Rest assured, my PC is well above spec, and has more than 6gb vram :D
It's also irrelevant to why I consider the planets garbage - which is 100% to do with the flattening of elevation heights and loss of terrain types.

And yes, your little turret-bound GIF does indeed show pathetically small peaks compared to what we're used to in Horizons.
So whilst not a literal pancake, it's comparatively pancake. With a touch of yoghurt shiny.
I havent seen anything bigger in Horizons with hundreds of times of exploration, so no idea what youre talking about. Maybe you making a judgement too early? 99.9% of Horizon planets I saw were flat pancakes that look like from ps2 era. And in Odyssey I see mountain biomes much more frequently, and theyre bigger than all i saw in Horizons.
 
I havent seen anything bigger in Horizons with hundreds of times of exploration, so no idea what youre talking about. Maybe you making a judgement too early? 99.9% of Horizon planets I saw were flat pancakes that look like from ps2 era. And in Odyssey I see mountain biomes much more frequently, and theyre bigger than all i saw in Horizons.
Literally because space is big. Really big. I mean, you might think it's a long way to the chemist, but that's nothing compared to space.
 
I havent seen anything bigger in Horizons with hundreds of times of exploration, so no idea what youre talking about. Maybe you making a judgement too early? 99.9% of Horizon planets I saw were flat pancakes that look like from ps2 era. And in Odyssey I see mountain biomes much more frequently, and theyre bigger than all i saw in Horizons.
From Horizons, the ridges/canyons here are up to ~12kms tall and gaps less than 1km across:

Day 30 - ridge approach.jpg
 

Deleted member 121570

D
I havent seen anything bigger in Horizons with hundreds of times of exploration, so no idea what youre talking about. Maybe you making a judgement too early? 99.9% of Horizon planets I saw were flat pancakes that look like from ps2 era. And in Odyssey I see mountain biomes much more frequently, and theyre bigger than all i saw in Horizons.
You really haven't explored enough then, is the only thing I can conclude. Would you like some pointers to some high mountains in Horizons that you can then go and compare for yourself? If so, I'll provide you with a good few examples and you can just fly there and see some proper high-range terrain from which to base an informed opinion. All in the bubble too, so not even far to go. :)

They're really not very rare, to be honest. I'm quite surprised you haven't seen any in your hundreds of hours.
 
Found a really nice wide canyon on a rocky world. I felt really immersed hiking through these canyons, and they were pretty huge. I'm about fully convinced that the planet tech is bugged or not rendering properly on the ice worlds or something.

My new favorite canyon from odyssey:
Screenshot (246)-min.png


I still get pictures like this on other worlds, though.
Screenshot (242)-min.png


I'm 50-50 on the new tech right now. I'm lost and confused. @Old Duck thoughts?
 
Ugh, and someone is going to present this and say that the terrain generation accurately reflects reality RL or anything we see in our solar system... [puke face]
That's a strawman, my post is merely a response to show that bigger stuff currently exists in Horizons, and in the bubble no less.

There's plenty of less extreme but easily found big terrain in Horizons that nothing I've seen in Odyssey so far can match for scale.

Huh what?

I was responding to ...
I havent seen anything bigger in Horizons with hundreds of times of exploration,
and showing that much bigger stuff exists in Horizons.

No other point.
 
Found a really nice wide canyon on a rocky world. I felt really immersed hiking through these canyons, and they were pretty huge. I'm about fully convinced that the planet tech is bugged or not rendering properly on the ice worlds or something.

My new favorite canyon from odyssey:
View attachment 230613

I still get pictures like this on other worlds, though.
View attachment 230614

I'm 50-50 on the new tech right now. I'm lost and confused. @Old Duck thoughts?
If you go to ground level (literally, land and go there on SRV) it gets a lot better. Better than Horizon even. The LOD is absolutely terrible, and I'm wondering if they didn't messed up and we have a very low res lod.
 
Back
Top Bottom