Live stream format change - Ed

Disagreed. :)

It would be showing there are alternatives. Private Groups are as much part of the game as gankers. Perhaps starting a stream in Open, and when one of the mouthbreathers show up, he goes: well, I am not really in the mood for not having fun tonight, so I'll just log into the great Mobius Private Group and continue my stream.

Really, this! +virtual rep...
 
Running away from problems will not make them go away.

Hence the upcoming C&P changes.

No. There are groups as I've mentioned(Delta Squadron) who go out of there way to try and protect Ed.

There is a time and place for private but lets not get all kill joy and take all the fun away from Eds streams.

A small group of PvP players seem intend on making everything about them.

"Look ma, they pay attention to me! They acknowledged my existence with a sigh of mild annoyance!"

Its not something to be applauded. Due sympathy must be given, and then the situation must be fixed.
 
Last edited:
Yep, thats what happens when you dont have a Delta Squadron protection wing.

I could link you the several streams which were in open and which were fun and where Ed was protected - not that you'd notice.... because we do a proper job.

Dude, we got it. Delta Squadron is awesome.

Two things though: 1) the two specific livestreams we are discussing here were on PS4 -- do you have PS4 Delta Squadron people? 2) more importantly, the fact that Ed could have asked you for help, does not mean that it's OK to streamsnipe him as soon as he logs into Open, on whatever platform he's playing on. This is just a variant of "well, get better shields" argument.
 
Maybe if Fdev hadn't nerfed player bounty hunting to the ground in 1.3 there would be more incentive to protect Ed from stream-snipers, as he would always attract those large bounty players.

But but but but, isn't it about the fun of emergent gameplay? Its truly wonderful to see the variety of excuses being paddled to be a stream-snipe apologist. :)

They try to. If everyone left open to go private then you are giving them what they want.

I however think we can do better than that.

Lets make Open great again!

Errr, I exclusively play Open. Last couple of weeks in my Viper. Doesnt mean I have to applaud these tragic individuals.
 
Dude, we got it. Delta Squadron is awesome.

Two things though: 1) the two specific livestreams we are discussing here were on PS4 -- do you have PS4 Delta Squadron people? 2) more importantly, the fact that Ed could have asked you for help, does not mean that it's OK to streamsnipe him as soon as he logs into Open, on whatever platform he's playing on. This is just a variant of "well, get better shields" argument.

Just needs a 5min delay on the stream.
 
Even if C&P was in the game, that would still not solve the problem of stream sniping/Ganking Ed/Host/activity.

If the stream is not about ganking, then it should be streamed via a private group to ensure the content is delivered.

When I broadcast a conference for my customers on features in our software, I don't open the office door to let random people come in and disrupt the conference.

Look at live news, there is alway some complete idiot trying to get on the TV 'Hey look it's me' just after attention. Hence why steps should be taken to stop the disruption.
 
When I broadcast a conference for my customers on features in our software, I don't open the office door to let random people come in and disrupt the conference. Look at live news, there is alway some complete idiot trying to get on the TV 'Hey look it's me' just after attention. Hence why steps should be taken to stop the disruption.

Thats actually a good analogy.
[haha]
 
Even if C&P was in the game, that would still not solve the problem of stream sniping/Ganking Ed/Host/activity.

If the stream is not about ganking, then it should be streamed via a private group to ensure the content is delivered.

When I broadcast a conference for my customers on features in our software, I don't open the office door to let random people come in and disrupt the conference.

Look at live news, there is alway some complete idiot trying to get on the TV 'Hey look it's me' just after attention. Hence why steps should be taken to stop the disruption.

All your points have been excellent.

The reason stream sniping still happens during Frontier livestreams is because Frontier has done nothing to make those stream snipers fear Frontier. By that I mean, Frontier should have stomped all over the stream snipers - and publicly - to set a stern example of what to expect if you're wanting to be a stream-sniping scrub.
 
I agree that is the bind Frontier are in, and I don't envy them.

Bottom line though, is that stream sniping and publicly harassing people (whether players or Frontier staff), is against Frontier policy. The only question is whether or not Frontier want to be seen enforcing that policy.

I'm afraid this reflects on what is happening elsewhere in the game when playing in Open. Basically you cannot take part in a CG or visit a high-profile location or you'll suffer from griefing. Frontier (Brett C) has stated "anything goes" in Open; there's no rules against it - although you're saying there are if the victim is a streamer?!. So having some numpty come along and ruin the stream ganking you is pretty much an accurate reflection of what will and often does happen in game. This is the fault of the game not having a viable functioning law-and-order system.

If it did, Ed could stream from a high-security system and not worry. Cause a wanted CMDR wouldn't get far into the system and a griefer would be put down instantly by the Feds. But that isn't the case.

Instead, players have to avoid game modes rather than lawless systems, since it is in effect a lawless game currently. A stream is just an identifiable location to grief, the same as a crash site or CG station.

We've been told that there's no such thing as griefing, that anything goes in Open and if we don't like it, play in Solo. I guess that advice is it's own Karma system.
 
All your points have been excellent.

The reason stream sniping still happens during Frontier livestreams is because Frontier has done nothing to make those stream snipers fear Frontier. By that I mean, Frontier should have stomped all over the stream snipers - and publicly - to set a stern example of what to expect if you're wanting to be a stream-sniping scrub.

Partly this seems to be because DB and the top devs seem very much clueless as to what modern multiplayer gaming is. DB confusion when asked if ED would go to steam (what is Steam, is it a big thing?) for example shows they are rather out of the loop. When you hear them talk about online gameplay they describe fun stuff with zero acknowledgement of what kind of problems online gaming has and how those can be solved.

Even if C&P was in the game, that would still not solve the problem of stream sniping/Ganking Ed/Host/activity.

If the stream is not about ganking, then it should be streamed via a private group to ensure the content is delivered.

When I broadcast a conference for my customers on features in our software, I don't open the office door to let random people come in and disrupt the conference.

Look at live news, there is alway some complete idiot trying to get on the TV 'Hey look it's me' just after attention. Hence why steps should be taken to stop the disruption.

Nah. Using the block feature however that gets their backs up.

This. They dont even need to be super tough, Ed could have just blocked the guy...
 
Back
Top Bottom