You'll forgive me if I don't take opinions in this thread at face-value, as many here have an unhealthy obsession with the game (in a tilting windmills sort of way). But I do appreciate people answering my very specific, objective questions as I work to form my own opinion! If there was a separate "Active Players Of Star Citizen" thread, I would have asked my questions there to avoid triggering folk.
I wouldn't call it an unhealthy obsession with the game. What it could be, at most, is a reaction to and a focus on an abomination that possibly could spread to other games and business. They tout the amounts of money they have made, without producing what was promised. In fact, they're removing stuff from their roadmap, and they just seem to get even more money. Do you want that to happen to SE? Would you be happy if SE had the same business model? Or would you be shocked or upset by that? Or you cant even imagine that happening? Well, all they have to do is start selling pictures of ships and telling you "its coming next year". That's it! The number of threads this has generated here is ultimately a call to attention. CIg should either release the game or just take their money and run. And, I think if they did release it, they'd actually make more money. Or do they think it would flop?
As to whether it's a game or alpha...I've noticed some of the time, even supporters of SC call it a game. Also, others have migrated to it from other games...so they must be migrating to a game. And then there are those who want to critique it, as they would any other game. So, in all cases, if only for part of the time, SC is recognized as a game. So SC is a game, and has been for a while, even if their login says otherwise. That being the case...
#1 - I cant keep calling it a scam, since it's a game.
#2 - SC, as a game, sucks and whatever they're planning to put into it, is impossible. As a moneymaker, though, a it's a huge success but I hope that success doesn't spread elsewhere...or else lots of money being made, with no return, will become the normal.