My CMDR has been in situations where he has repeatedly engaged and destroyed the vessels of one or more other CMDRs, multiple times. Not once was I targeting another player, or attempting to cause them grief. I was having my CMDR act in accordance with his character by responding to wholly in-game events, with in-game actions, in the context of the game's setting.
There is nothing against the rules of the game or in the TOS that can reasonably be interpreted as prohibiting a player from having their CMDR initiate or respond to hostilities against in-game enemies, even if it's the same enemy over and over again.
That is utter nonsense.
I can have my CMDR act in a manner blatantly contrary to their CMDRs' goals or interests, making the most obvious and proper course of action for them to pull him over.
What are other CMDRs supposed to do if my CMDR is causing problems for them? Ignore him? A major part of why I'm in Open is so other CMDRs have a shot at opposing my CMDR.
If I instead behave in an insulting and/or belligerent manner, then menu log to remove any chance at my CMDR facing consequences, there by wasting everyone's time, that is as clear cut griefing as it gets.
Aye.
The thing I find frustrating here is when I play in Open no one attempts to oppose my CMDR much anymore. I'm a pirate, a smuggler, and an outright miscreant. When I pull over people to ask for a few tonnes of cargo, they log out. When I'm in SC no one interdicts me because most people just log.
It's sad that while playing in Open, where I'd expect to find opposition, there just isn't anymore. I have to go out of my way to find people who are willing to interdict me or to find people to rob that realize that I only want cargo. Hell, my group even gives CMDRs a 24hr pass where our group won't come after them if they comply with the cargo demand and people still log out.
Honestly, people just need to grow up. You have Private Groups like Mobius, DRX, and Solo to work with if you don't want to run the risk of player interactions contrary to your playstyle. Why troll the players in Open? It just makes things that much worse for everyone if you go around griefing through repeated murder or griefing through logging.
Both logging and murder hoboing are just as bad as each other. They take legit gameplay options and twist them around just to screw with people for the lulz. It's childish.
edit: Not ragging on you Morbad, btw. People forget the roleplaying part of an MMORPG. Glad to see some haven't!