Dr Smarts perfectly positioned himself, he's been right just often enough to simultaneously infuriate and terrify the superfans so they have to slavishly follow his every word and attack it. It's obvious that most of the time he's just winding them up, but they can never bring themselves to ignore him just in case.
He's turned being scapegoated and subjected to a hate campaign into a hobby.
The thing with Derek Smart is that, when he talks about the technical side of the game, he is usually right. Whether or not you like his games, the truth is he IS a games developer and he has been doing this for 30 years.
He DOES know what he is talking about and about this aspect of SC, he is usually correct and reliable.
It's also evident by now that he DOES have sources inside CIG feeding him information. That is the simplest explanation for some of what he had stated. Indeed, it's the only explanation for some of it.
At the same time, he does seem to take a degree of pleasure in trolling SCs backers. More, the sources he has appear to be unreliable....sometimes they are right, and sometimes wrong. One wonders if the theory that he is being leaked incorrect information is true; given CIG appears to have deliberately changed the name of a ship simply to discredit him, I wouldn't say it is impossible.
But lets give him credit. He HAS pointed out a lot that is wrong with SC, a lot that is wrong with its development and he has been right about a good many aspects.
Sure..he has been wrong about it shutting down but I don't think ANYONE expected CIG to raise $180 million and counting. At the same time, it seems to me that refund requests are increasing, that even the whales are starting to jump ship, while CIG seems more desperate to raise money, so perhaps the end will come sooner than I expected (my expectation being that they'd lose money but would have enough of a reserve to last 3 or 4 more years, long enough to get something out).
In short....for all the negatives people say about Derek Smart, he can be a valuable enough source - so long as you remember he does have an agenda, that he doesn't have a perfect record and that he isn't above trolling SC backers for the LOLs.