We Need to be Better as a Community

Sir.Tj

The Moderator who shall not be Blamed....
Volunteer Moderator
A long time ago I posted this.


Hi Everyone.

Just thought I'd make a quick post on how the forum is evolving as new backers of Elite Dangerous join us here for the release.

Please be patient to new forum members as they join and delve into the forum and the wonderful world of Elite, we all make mistakes and no-one like to be jumped on when this happens. The vast majority of the forum members are fantastic in helping new posters to join in and offer advice. There are couple of points I'd like to make:


  • If a new thread is created on a existing subject/in the wrong area etc. Take a little bit of time to direct them to the existing thread and by all means PM a mod and we will look into the thread, please dont make disparaging comments .
  • If someone creates a post that comes across in a negative manner. Don't respond in kind, instead show them there are better ways to make a point by responding in a positive and constructive manner. sarcastic replies discourages new forum members and will stifle debate and can easily descend into flamewars.
  • If a forum member is unsure of the forum rules or how to post on the forum etc. We have guides you can direct them to that can help them so they can join in and enjoy being part of the great community we are all helping to create.
The Frontier forum is a family orientated place, it may come as a shock to some but Elite is not the only series of games FD have created. ;) Some games are for the younger gamers i.e Kinectimal, who may be intrigued into what Elite is and will browse the main Elite Dangerous forum. We really want to encourage them to join in and become the next generation of Elite players to kick our collective bottoms with their faster reflexes and all that.

Always be mindful of this and post in a responsible manner.

We are all fans of the game and are all on a exciting journey together to help Frontier make the game the very best it can be. The forum is a place to express ideas and opinions have fun and revel in the madness creating a great game. Everyone has a right to be heard and as long as they contribute in the right way they should be allowed to have their voice heard.


Remember many of you were new forum members not so very long ago and the influx of new posters will continue for a while yet as the game progresses through the stages of testing until release and beyond... It can take a bit of time to get used to how Frontier likes the interaction of the forum to be conducted, so show them how to join in by leading by example.

Thanks everyone. :D

T.j

And it's still relativly relevant today
 
ok, but i need some sleep now too! i'll be back, be kind to each other, you monsters!
Rather view them as 'little rascals'.
Remember that this is PG.

Let us define 'toxicity'. What is it in this case?
Little rascals vs old people in belief of power.

Oldie: "Conform. CONFORM!" (Ah cr*p, this adult won't quit! I don't understand. Was I this obnoxious when I was a kid? NO! I was not.... I believe that strongly.)

Rascal: - "Never!" (or at least I got that out of me, next time I sh*t up and do as the rules tell me, but I can not admit that I learned something here)
 
Last edited:
These forums used to be a fantastic place. There's a reason I rarely visit it anymore, and the subject of this thread explains it very well.

It's a shame the toxic behaviour is allowed to exist. But I don't blame the mods, they are doing the best they can do.

It'd be nice to see the forums return to their old friendliness at some point though.

Sidenote: I don't know the thread the OP is discussing (I haven't read it). I'm referring to things in general.
Id recommend reading the thread in question before considering a vid on the subject. It undermines the OP's position here, since most of any toxicity came from the OP there.
 
Sidenote: I don't know the thread the OP is discussing (I haven't read it). I'm referring to things in general.

The bigger issue is people screaming "toxicity" the moment they're met with criticism.
The worst part about it is just how many will jump on that band wagon to see themselves on the high ground.

What used to be commonplace was people calling out nonsense. These days it's time to shut up should anything possibly be seen as negative or contrary.
 
One thing i personally have noticed about toxicity in public life, is that once a person becomes ill, most fervently held ideologies, quick tempers and careless thoughts begin to mellow significantly, you'll rarely find a varied group of people that get on so well, as those in a hospital, because they've been forced to realise what is actually of importance in life, and it turns out, other than a few very basic truths to do with treating others right, there's not much else worth getting hot under the collar for.
 
Sidenote: I don't know the thread the OP is discussing (I haven't read it). I'm referring to things in general.
Honestly Ant, I'd take a quick look. This is an important topic, but it'd be a shame if any serious discussion that might emerge was undermined by its association with that particular thread. Not only is the "toxicity" mild in comparison with some of the vitriol seen elsewhere*, but to my eyes the animosity seems to begin -- whether deliberately or as a result of a language barrier -- with the originator's own early replies. Mileages may vary of course, but I don't think it's a great example of bad "community" behaviour. I've certainly seen worse.

*this is based on my earlier reading of the first two-and-a-bit
pages. It may well have blown up by the time you read this.
 
One thing i personally have noticed about toxicity in public life, is that once a person becomes ill, most fervently held ideologies, quick tempers and careless thoughts begin to mellow significantly, you'll rarely find a varied group of people that get on so well, as those in a hospital, because they've been forced to realise what is actually of importance in life, and it turns out, other than a few very basic truths to do with treating others right, there's not much else worth getting hot under the collar for.
Nicely put Commander, bit like one of Murphy's Laws of Warfare that states there isn't any atheists in a foxhole during an attack! Having been both under fire and in a dire medical emergency, I can vouch that what seemed important before suddenly isn't that important anymore.
 
Rather view them as 'little rascals'.
Remember that this is PG.

Let us define 'toxicity'. What is it in this case?
Little rascals vs old people in belief of power.

Oldie: "Conform. CONFORM!" (Ah cr*p, this adult won't quit! I don't understand. Was I this obnoxious when I was a kid? NO! I was not.... I believe that strongly.)

Rascal: - "Never!" (or at least I got that out of me, next time I sh*t up and do as the rules tell me, but I can not admit that I learned something here)

That doesn't really work if the expectation of conformity is that you must gripe about some really trivial stuff.

Masked swearing is considered bad form
 
Nicely put Commander, bit like one of Murphy's Laws of Warfare that states there isn't any atheists in a foxhole during an attack! Having been both under fire and in a dire medical emergency, I can vouch that what seemed important before suddenly isn't that important anymore.

Yep, its just a video game and a reality check is sometimes required.

One of the reasons I think demands for extra realism in games are misguided. Running over a medpack doesn't cure gunshot wounds, it just stubs your toe and gets you yelled at by a very angry medic.
 

"Three more principles call on individuals to create rich and relevant content to make the web a valuable place, build strong online communities where everyone feels safe and welcome, and finally, to fight for the web, so it remains open to everyone, everywhere."

;)
 
The internet is a great thing.

But its use is fraught with problems.

Own your words, and use them carefully.

It is fine to disagree.

But disagree with the message, not the messenger.

There is also a report button on this forum.

Someone abused you rather than your message?

Use it.

Do not reply back escalating the situation, let the Mods sort it out.

That is what they do not get paid for afterall.
 
The internet is a great thing.

But its use is fraught with problems.

Own your words, and use them carefully.

It is fine to disagree.

But disagree with the message, not the messenger.

There is also a report button on this forum.

Someone abused you rather than your message?

Use it.

Do not reply back escalating the situation, let the Mods sort it out.

That is what they do not get paid for afterall.
This is nice and such. But remember there are kids here. You can't expect every new player to understand. The learning cliff is steep when it comes to new forums and their rules and conformation.
 
This is nice and such. But remember there are kids here. You can't expect every new player to understand. The learning cliff is steep when it comes to new forums and their rules and conformation.
Here I would disagree with this statement.

I do expect people posting on the forum to understand, irrespective of tbeir age.

When they sign up to the forum, they agree to its terms and conditions.

That means they should understand to be polite or expect to be removed from its use.
 
Yep, its just a video game and a reality check is sometimes required.

One of the reasons I think demands for extra realism in games are misguided. Running over a medpack doesn't cure gunshot wounds, it just stubs your toe and gets you yelled at by a very angry medic.

Yep, a sucking chest wound is nature's way of telling you to slow down!

Remember just before I retired from the military, had some idiot - he wasn't a kid, late teens/early 20's I guess, tell me that he could use any weapon in our inventory and use it better than anyone else. When I finished laughing at this pimply faced man/boy he told me he is some high rank in COD and 'used all the weapons in the game at a higher level than I could ever do in real life'. Scary thing is he was quite serious, he actually thought that firing a rifle via a controller is as good as putting lead down range. Tried telling him that real life doesn't have a respawn but even that failed to temper his belief in his own abilities. God I was tempted to take him out to the range, but the unfiltered sound of a rifle being fired would have probably scared him too much lol

If you ever want a laugh, jump on You-Tube and watch any clip about a modern (or at least post WW1) weapon then read the comments. Guaranteed some idiot will jump in and say he used this weapon in some game and it is either 'leet' or whatever. And they wonder why they get laughed at !
 
I posted this in response to another thread, but I think the message is important so I am making it a main thread also, was written in response to a new player who made a bit of a mistake about what he was saying then got a lot of negativity about it :

Having read a lot now of what has been posted in reply to your post, I have the following comments.

It is really not right all the toxicity you have had to endure, and I totally do not accept it. You made a mistake by thinking <whatever not really important>. You said on your post that you were just a casual player. All of the <> you are getting is not right. Just another example of toxicity on this forum. You made a mistake, so what? No excuse for nastiness from those who know better. And we have all been beginners/casual level at one point.

Cant we be better than this, as a community ?

How do you think the OP is going to feel, next time he wants to post something?

Maybe he is going to think twice about it now. Is that REALLY what we want? For voices to be silenced because of all the toxicity that gets thrown around? Because that is for sure what is happening. People need a VERY thick skin to stick around this forum. I know many CMDRs who just wont post here for that very reason, they are fed up with <> that gets thrown their way just for voicing opinion.

Now I am not going to call anyone out, I dont want to embarrass or provoke anyone, and I dont want to get yet another warning for "flaming" aka defending myself when toxicity gets thrown my way.

OP has been put into the "Victim's Dilemma", yet again. Harsh responses elicit both you and toxic poster get a warning and banned from posting to the thread for 3 days + posts removed. Do nothing and mods will just ignore those toxic comments. Happens a lot in life and I call it the "Victim's Dilemma". Someone does something to you and its not serious enough for authority to care but you do something back then you become the criminal and suddenly whole thing is taken seriously. It is a lose-lose scenario.

So what is the solution to all of this, in the context of the Elite: Dangerous official forum ?

The mods have no will to solve it. One can see on the very first page of this thread comments that are clearly disparaging to the OP and his post, and the next a post in response to this thread by a Mod. The moderation team read this comment yet chose to do nothing. Frontier knows these forums have a bad reputation for toxicity yet choose to do nothing.

It is up to us, THE COMMUNITY, to do what we can to solve this problem of chronic toxicity, and what I propose is this :

1. SPEAK UP. If you see someone being denigrated, tone policed, baited, insulted or any of the other words that just mean using words to hurt another person then : SAY SOMETHING. Say it is not right and that you do not agree with it. There is a massive difference between disagreeing with someone thence attacking the premise or logic of their arguments and attacking THAT PERSON as a person. They are alike, yet not alike. Confuse them not.

2. NO NAMING AND SHAMING. This does absolutely no good and just causes fights/flame wars. Dont do it. People might also have a good motive and just made a mistake in their wording, you dont know. Dont call people out, it is just repeating the whole cycle we are trying to break.

3. GIVE THE REASONS WHY TOXICITY ON THESE FORUMS IS A BAD THING
3.1 It is discouraging people from having a voice. Many people are thin skinned and end up banned or just leave these forums because of this. Every voice adds value.
3.2 It is giving these forums a bad reputation. People prefer to post on reddit or face book rather than here and who can blame them? We should be an example to other communities. Compare and contrast to Kerbal Space Program official forums.
3.3 It is causing a lot of anger and bad feeling. Many people who aught be fast friends because of strong shared interest and passion are falling out or getting enmity.
3.4 It makes the forums a generally nasty place, one must always wonder when posting how someone is going to attack, knowing any defence of oneself is likely to elicit a warning
3.5 I know most people dont give a dam about anyone but themselves. But for the odd few who are the exception, knowing the toxicity is upsetting people and making others unhappy aught be reason enough to want to clean these forums up.
3.6 And probably many, many other reasons, I leave it to the ingenium of the individual to work out, state of affairs is good for no-one.

And I know many people will say it cant be done, the will is not there, we wont get everyone on board, etc, etc. It only takes a few respected CMDRs to consistently lend voice when they notice toxicity for things to change for the better. As it was rightly said "One carat of diamond is worth several tons of sand; we dont need the majority". We should be an example in space sim community, not a toxic cess pit.

CMDR Gavin786

I read the OP** you are mentioning and while there were some harsh replies, there wasn't a single toxic one. Well, maybe except your post

** https://forums.frontier.co.uk/threads/strong-suspicion-that-this-game-has-a-hacker-problem.530788/
 
Back
Top Bottom