After having to try and adapt to the new forum - I've decided I flat out hate it and will just be using Reddit now unfortunately.
My issues are
1) I can't look at a very dark background on very light text for long at all. If physically makes my eyes burn like when you look at a bright light and when I look away I can see a shadow image that is very disorienting. I'm not going to install some 3rd party software or browser add-on. I don't run ANY add-ons in my web browsers, don't need ANOTHER security hole, its not an option. So I don't visit any website that forces a dark theme.
2) The topic text is way too big putting too few topics on screen. I liked having the forum up and being able to see the top 25 topics or so on any given forum on one screen while I played ED on the other. Now it is 10. Now I have to constantly scroll/be active on the screen to read through the topics - forcing me to be more interactive with the website to find more information. This is the opposite of what you want for users - you want to present MORE with LESS actions. This is also frustrating (much less so than #1), but I see it as a huge downgrade from the old system.
Now that I think of it - what was so wrong with the old forum software to give us this? Giving excuses for what can't be done sure is a downgrade and not an upgrade.... what am I missing that this fantastic new forum can do that the old forum couldn't?
EDIT: ok so here are the new features, bolded ones that may actually be used (yes, nothing is bolded), some actually are not new, was it worth changing software - no freaking way.:
- Native mobile support with a responsive theme
- New forum trophies
- The developer tracker!
- Personal news feed - follow your friends to see what they're up to!
- A modern-day WYSIWYG editor
- Native Two-Factor support
- Post reaction system - replaces the vBulletin reputation system
- Push Notifications - get notified in seconds on your mobile or desktop
- Rich link previews.
- Post & Thread bookmarking -------------> but you could subscribe on the old one, this is redundant.
- Auto-embed of social posts. Just place the URL in your post, boom - it's embedded! -----------> You could do this with the tools on the old forums, redundant.
- Basic video upload and auto-embed support (limited to MP4, WEBM and OGG currently) -----------> You could do this with the tools on the old forums, redundant.
- Sidebar widgets (on the right side)
- Inline spoilers. When you tab or click on the text, it'll de-spoiler! -----------> You could literally do this with the inline spoiler tag on the old forums, roflomg redundant.
And I'm out until the forum changes at least the theme to support a light background... goodbye.