^^
This pretty much. RDR1 was so well written and executed that it's become a timeless classic (the way San Andreas is).
BTW: I never fully understood John's encounters with The Strange Man when I played the original. It wasn't until Arthur encountered that creepy, unfinished painting while revisiting the old gang hideout at Shady Belle. The way the painting changed depending on when Arthur looked at it. The fact that Arthur was diagnosed with TB shortly afterwards. And then everything clicked with John's encounters in RDR1.
The unfinished subject in the picture was one of the creepiest foreshadowing in any game I've played to date. Because The Strange Man literally hunted down Every. Single. One. Of the Hunters aka what I like to call the violent members who were the killers/enforcers in Dutch's gang by the end of the prequel in RDR1. And sadly, his sh*te list also included Abigail (because her hands were bloody in committing at least one murder we know of in RDR2).
The only gang members who escaped The Strange Man unscathed were the Gatherers i.e. the likes of non enforcers like
little Jack (for being too young and innocent),
Pearson (more sneaky than a murderer),
Charles (more noble than vicious killer),
Sadie (because she was all about the revenge game),
Rev Swanson (for finding redemption),
Mary Beth (sharp intelligence under that quiet demeanor despite being one of the gang's prostitutes. But definitely not a killer),
Trelawny (the most likely gang member who found a way to con The Strange Man and convince him to quit stalking him), and
meek little Tilly---with her humble but noble 1 bat wing contribution to the camp chest
The only loose end that seemed to escape the Strange Man was Karen. Does anyone know what became of her fate? I believe she was last rumored to be hanging out in that rundown hovel village. The one between the Bayou Nwa and St. Dennis.