Discussion What is the most efficient way to crowdsource the 3D system coordinates

HEADS UP

Duplicate coordinates

Code:
HIP 24019	49974.90625	40964.90625	23927.96875
HIP 24020	49974.90625	40964.90625	23927.96875

I hope that's not due to an error in the algorithm....
 
I've just sped read through the whole list, the only other odd one that I can see is

"Jackson's Lighthouse" "50142" "40958" "24035"

Seems a bit odd to be on a 3 way boundary.

there are a lot of easter eggs in there. My favorite being Ix
 
HEADS UP

Duplicate coordinates

Code:
HIP 24019	49974.90625	40964.90625	23927.96875
HIP 24020	49974.90625	40964.90625	23927.96875

I hope that's not due to an error in the algorithm....

I think that might just be a pair of stars very close to one another. In-game both names show up in that area, but separately, if you see what I mean.

I don't think it's genuine. Someone thinko/typo ?

http://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-basic?Ident=HIP+24019&submit=SIMBAD+search
http://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-basic?Ident=HIP+24019&submit=SIMBAD+search

HIP 24019:
FK5 coord. (ep=J2000 eq=2000) : 05 09 45.092 +28 01 49.67 ( Optical ) [ 13.62 5.90 0 ]
Parallaxes mas: 19.01 [1.34]

HIP 24020:
FK5 coord. (ep=J2000 eq=2000) : 05 09 45.473 +28 02 01.04 ( Optical ) [ 41.49 18.04 0 ]
Parallaxes mas: 13.53 [5.26]

The difference in Parallax alone is 52 versus 74 parsecs from Sol.
Edit: Although if you overlap the errors in them you can make them be in the same place I guess ....
Edit2: Oops, and that's parsecs, not ly.
 
Last edited:
Duplicates (same name, different co-ordinates):

Asha
Dala
Kanu
Nari
Sama
Siren
Taka

Confirmed

Code:
Asha	49919.21875	40959.5		24244.5
Asha	49892.78125	41059.21875	24221.09375

Dala	50181.65625	40825.84375	24109.71875
Dala	50009.75	41010.90625	24082.9375

Kanu	50098.4375	40961.96875	23980.71875
Kanu	49962.875	40960.09375	24201.96875

Nari	50127.65625	40777.5625	24050.75
Nari	49972.90625	41155.34375	24195.28125

Sama	50040.84375	40811.6875	24271.59375
Sama	49975.28125	40970.65625	24199.625

Siren	50126.125	40997.625	24049.28125
Siren	50001.125	41007.28125	24027.625

Taka	50112.875	40974.21875	24180.625
Taka	49938.71875	41018.96875	24023.375
 

wolverine2710

Tutorial & Guide Writer
Confirmed

Code:
Asha	49919.21875	40959.5		24244.5
Asha	49892.78125	41059.21875	24221.09375

Dala	50181.65625	40825.84375	24109.71875
Dala	50009.75	41010.90625	24082.9375

Kanu	50098.4375	40961.96875	23980.71875
Kanu	49962.875	40960.09375	24201.96875

Nari	50127.65625	40777.5625	24050.75
Nari	49972.90625	41155.34375	24195.28125

Sama	50040.84375	40811.6875	24271.59375
Sama	49975.28125	40970.65625	24199.625

Siren	50126.125	40997.625	24049.28125
Siren	50001.125	41007.28125	24027.625

Taka	50112.875	40974.21875	24180.625
Taka	49938.71875	41018.96875	24023.375

Is EDStarCoordinator/TGC currently down?
In my "complete list of third party tools" thread I just got a report from a commander "url is broken". I can imagine you are feeding TGC with data right now and this has something to do with it;-)
 

wolverine2710

Tutorial & Guide Writer
It could be VERY lonely out there!!!

EXTREMELY COOL. This is something we can work with!!!
Gonna double check with Michael Brookes if it are again systems with an economy.

Send a PM to Michael Brookes and got a reply back.

wolverine2710 said:
Hello Mr Brookes,

A new and uncluttered PM as the other was getting to long. Thank you SO much for that partial list. Approx 19842-4=19838 systems. ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS. Thanks that you have taken the time to collect the data, really appreciated. Of course what would a PM of mine be without a question or two? ;-)

  1. Are it again systems with an economy?
  2. I assume its just a partial list - as in there are MANY more systems with an economy out there.

I have informed the commanders in the Trade Dangerous thread of the existence of the spreadsheet and will PM the tool authors I know who use those coordinates. Will also put it in my "complete list of third party tools" thread. Sharing is GOOD.

Here is hoping that Gamma is going smooth and that the Release 1.0 Galaxy doesn't change.

PS. Did I already mention that its ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS ;-)

With kind regards,
Jan aka cmdr Wolverine.

His response:

Michael Brookes said:
1. I believe so.
2. It's probably most of them.

There may be changes to the galaxy for release, but it depends on what comes in. So far it's just a few name changes.

Thanks

Michael

Thanks
 
Confirmed

Code:
Asha	49919.21875	40959.5		24244.5
Asha	49892.78125	41059.21875	24221.09375

Dala	50181.65625	40825.84375	24109.71875
Dala	50009.75	41010.90625	24082.9375

Kanu	50098.4375	40961.96875	23980.71875
Kanu	49962.875	40960.09375	24201.96875

Nari	50127.65625	40777.5625	24050.75
Nari	49972.90625	41155.34375	24195.28125

Sama	50040.84375	40811.6875	24271.59375
Sama	49975.28125	40970.65625	24199.625

Siren	50126.125	40997.625	24049.28125
Siren	50001.125	41007.28125	24027.625

Taka	50112.875	40974.21875	24180.625
Taka	49938.71875	41018.96875	24023.375

I've confirmed ingame that "Asha" does in fact exist in two places corresponding to the corodinates given.

If you search you get the
Asha 49919.21875 40959.5 24244.5
aka
Asha -65.78125 -25.5 139.5 (ingame coords)

And if you manually go to
Asha 49892.78125 41059.21875 24221.09375
aka
Asha -92.21875 74.21875 116.09375 (ingame coords)

Then that one does indeed exist with that name as well
 
Confirmed

Code:
Asha	49919.21875	40959.5		24244.5
Asha	49892.78125	41059.21875	24221.09375

Dala	50181.65625	40825.84375	24109.71875
Dala	50009.75	41010.90625	24082.9375

Kanu	50098.4375	40961.96875	23980.71875
Kanu	49962.875	40960.09375	24201.96875

Nari	50127.65625	40777.5625	24050.75
Nari	49972.90625	41155.34375	24195.28125

Sama	50040.84375	40811.6875	24271.59375
Sama	49975.28125	40970.65625	24199.625

Siren	50126.125	40997.625	24049.28125
Siren	50001.125	41007.28125	24027.625

Taka	50112.875	40974.21875	24180.625
Taka	49938.71875	41018.96875	24023.375

Searchable Asha is the 49919.21875 40959.5 24244.5 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Dala is the 50009.75 41010.90625 24082.9375 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Kanu is the 50098.4375 40961.96875 23980.71875 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Nari is the 49972.90625 41155.34375 24195.28125 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Sama is the 49975.28125 40970.65625 24199.625 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Siren is the 50001.125 41007.28125 24027.625 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Taka is the 49938.71875 41018.96875 24023.375 one, the other does also exist.
 

wolverine2710

Tutorial & Guide Writer
Searchable Asha is the 49919.21875 40959.5 24244.5 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Dala is the 50009.75 41010.90625 24082.9375 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Kanu is the 50098.4375 40961.96875 23980.71875 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Nari is the 49972.90625 41155.34375 24195.28125 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Sama is the 49975.28125 40970.65625 24199.625 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Siren is the 50001.125 41007.28125 24027.625 one, the other does also exist.
Searchable Taka is the 49938.71875 41018.96875 24023.375 one, the other does also exist.

I can imagine this scrutinizing of the data is helpful for FD/ED as well. We leave no stone unturned ;-)
Lets make sure that at the end of the day the findings are ticketed!!
All of the sudden this thread is FULL of live again ;-)
 
Last edited:
Here's a truly odd one...

SingleLightTest

It's actually searchable ingame - and leads to the correct coordinates (-0.25, 0.25, 0.25) (right next to Sol)
But there is no star there :)

According to the Info sheet - It should be a type A1 V star as well :)


Test
Test2
Test3
TestRender

are also searchable (with no visible star at the location)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom