You've said that a few times already and, with all due respect, it didn't seem to convince a lot of thoise who voiced their frustrations in this thread. Are you against the idea, while keeping the current riddles (which, again, are really cool but maybe not for everyone), to see FD rely on different new ways (or some they tried already but failed due to external factors) to involve more players in the alien storyline ? Or do you prefer to see it restricted to the participants of the threadnaught ?
Constructive criticism... ha ha ha
I'm not against other ways to get involved no, depends what they are really I would need specific ideas to comment. I think CGs are a poor substitute but are something everyone can get involved in, for example.
My post was following up on the idea that it's one group of players that solve everything and xdeath saying how actually it's individuals. It illustrates that you don't have to be in any group to get involved. Which was why I was trying to point out how if people want to get involved they should.
If you want more people to get involved then you should expect Fdev to release tools, ways for people to get invovled.
Not everyone knows where to find other players, not everyone wants to get out of the game to play the game.
This is another symptom of there being no in-game system for players to commucate in set groups or form groups.
If there were in-game corps/chat/tools/etc I'm sure player-groups would get involved and set goals and motivate the players in that group to participate but as it stands there's no motivation, or organization for the vast majority of the playerbase so you get what you see now. A few well connected players doing everything while the rest of us say "Oh thats cute, I'm gonna keep grinding credits cause that's all there is to do in this game from where I sit".
Like I don't know what the hell they are thinking, they're taking these ideas and concepts from MMO's with guilds and implementing them half-cocked without a guild system and wondering why only sparse pockets of players participate.
It would be like adding party missions with the current wing system.
Sure, like a few people would do them, but most players wouldn't bother because there's no system for finding wings, or groups of friends to play with.
So they want emergent gameplay, groups of players to solve puzzles...They want us to form player-groups but they can't be seen supporting it in-game because of all the anti-Eve crowd...
WhaT!?
Then we're on the same page, excellent.I'm not against other ways to get involved no
Obviously.depends what they are really
First I think we need to be honest and realistic short term. Later, FD would need to come up with something more elaborate, but as far as I'm concerned this would be a huge improvement for now.I would need specific ideas to comment. I think CGs are a poor substitute but are something everyone can get involved in, for example.
I honestly don't see pushing guilds and player group management tools into the game would help.
If someone wants to join a player group they can do so, every player group I've ever been involved with has had discussions out of game. Teamspeak, forums, and so on are standard. Putting better group communication in game isn't going to solve the problem.
In respect to the "alien mysteries", if anything I'd saying focusing on groups would result in more segregation as each group starts competing. I can think of instances of this happening, where a player group drops into the forum thread to announce that their group is getting involved. Of course all their discussions will happen on their private forum. It just then becomes groups competing and so witholding, which then becomes exclusionary. It becomes more about making a name for the group than open collaboration.
You may like the game now YES
and think anyone who doesn't just isn't on par with your "genius level intellect" NO
but how many people do you think have said the same thing but are here now hating on the game six months later? VERY FEW
Will you still be playing six months from now? YES
Do you honestly believe there's enough content for you to keep playing for six months? YES I LIKE OOLITE TOO!
Because some of the people in this thread are people who said the exact same thing you're saying now but changed their tune once they hit a wall MAYBE THEY PLAYED TOO MUCH
and realized there really isn't anything to do and the game isn't structured in a way that is conducive to a thriving long-term player-populated universe. YOU MEAN IT'S NOT EVEY ENOUGH
It's all surface and mirrors and yeah it may keep you entertained for a couple months while you grind out your anaconda and cutter/corvette after you have these ships the game becomes empty and boring, FOR SOME
that's what creates the jaded players that just say " it" and sit outside of their station blowing up newbies in sidewinders. LIKE YOU MAYBE ?
Boredom. They're bored. MMMMMM
Piracy is terrible, missions are terrible, end-game is terrible. NO IT'S MUCH BETTER THAN IT WAS ON THE BBC VERSION
They want a space sim, they believe in ED so they still play once in awhile but when they do they just blow other players up and make their play session miserable, because they're bored. PROJECTION
So like, FD must make all the changed you want or you will kill babies in Sidewinders..nice
Competition breeds progress.
Look at technological progress during wars, or competition of real corporations.
If you ask me I think they'd get solved faster if it was a competition.
Ask what the motivations were of the people who solved the puzzles, they probably would say because they found it interesting but also to get their name on it.
If you're right and no one cares about competition, then why is it when someone discovers something in ED why do they wait to turn it in to a station before telling everyone on forums?
To get their name on it.
Aye one-upmanship.
Thankfully the "alien mysteries" thread is mostly free from all that, and I like it that way.
I'm only partially going into RP mode here, but I see a division, inside the bubble and outside the bubble. All that one-upmanship, group vs group, Imperial vs Federation, power grab, is bubble stuff. For a lot of folk who took an interest from day one it's the polar opposite of what the "alien mysteries" are and should be about.
Which group has the biggest epeen is internal petty human bubble matters, you can keep it. The wider mysteries of the galaxy are outside and above all of that, and are infinetely more interesting. Human politics should have nothing to do with it, hence the open colloboration.
I mean the thread even has SDC members contributing, not that they shouldn't, but y'know who cares, it's all good!
I don't pvp, at all.
But I read threads posted by them, and have talked to people who try to blow me up.
I'm just repeating what they said.
I don't even own a PVP ship. OH OK
You're the only person in this entire thread who has defended the game, REALLY
what does that tell you? GRUMPY THREAD?
You never answered the question about what you're going to do when the player-base is so small that you have to back the game yourself, NOT WORRIED
avoided that question I see...how convenient. HAHAHA LIKE I DID ON PURPOSE? IT MUST BE CONSPIRACY
We're all here discussing this because we want the game to succeed.
People like you want the game to halt fail. PROJECTION
If we didn't care about ED, we'd just quit and go play something else and uninstall the game. SHORT ON HDD SPACE?
People like you don't want the game to get better, PROJECTION
you want it so stay dul EVELESSLY DULL MAYBE
l because that's what YOU enjoy. YEP I LOVE GUILDLESS DULL YTHINGS
You'd be fine if THREAT INCOMING
FDev said "Sorry guys not enough money is coming in, ED updates are halted for the foreseeable future" YUP IT'S GREAT ALREADY
You'd probably say "good the game is fine the way it is, YES
I'm glad I don't have to worry about them changing to to make more $" SO I HAVE TO PAY MY OWN MONEY IF THE DEVS JUST HIRE YOU COZ ONLY YOU HAVE THE ANSWER TO KEEPING THE GAME FREE
Well we want the game to progress and become a living thriving universe full of things to do..LIKE LOTS OF MMO DULL STUFF
Maybe Space Simulator is the game for you?
NO NEVER PLAYED THAT, I LIKE ELITE THANKS.
Then we're on the same page, excellent.
Obviously.
First I think we need to be honest and realistic short term. Later, FD would need to come up with something more elaborate, but as far as I'm concerned this would be a huge improvement for now.
What's impossible / not good for the game or lore
1) use complex new gameplay mechanics (unless they are already secretly developped by FD, but we do not know that)
2) everyone finding the unique ruin site is out of the table for obvious reasons
3) but enough with the "you have less chances to be the finder of something than winning the lottery even if you spend all your time trying"
4) You have to keep up with the threadnaught and the Galnet zillions of useless bulletins to keep up with the story
I'm perfectly fine with your idea of using the CGs. Granted, they're not perfect, but they gather a lot of players regularly. The average CMDR knows them fairly well. They are broadly advertised in the game thus easy to find : no need to keep up with the threadnaught.
So, with that said, here is a very imperfect proposition :
In the case of the ruins, once they are found, FD could have set the Ram Tah CG a little differently. To be involved in the CG , you'd have to prospect on the whole planet with your srv scanner to find rare artifacts with the same game mechanic as the rock prospection (meaning you'll find artifacts everywhere on the planet). Evey tier reached in the CG would free new informations. Not necessarily something ground breaking (could be just lore), but the top tiers would net something more interesting allowing to help with the main ruins puzzle.
I don't like the CGs.
according to the riddles contingent here, only a handful of imbeciles are not having fun with those wonderful outside of the game mysteries ?
Nicely done.
Then we can pretty much scratch my whole post right here. Fine.
As for your example , I cannot possibly comment on it : I have yet to find anything except 5 tips off which led to nothing related to the main story line. Since I spent about 35 weeks IGT mainly exploring, I suppose I have very little luck to find anything and the only option I have left is to wait for the threadnaught to give me the coordinates and youtube to give me the vids of some place where I have no need to go because there is nothing for me to do there.
Which means that we're back to square one and this proves exactly the point of all the frustrated players posting here : FD and their Cannon buddies can RPG as much as they want on their free time, but there are a few players who would like to take part in the Alien storyline of the game they paid for. And would like to see the company work on that (at least once in a while since they are obviously very busy encoding morse code in sound files).
As long as the happy ones are the majority, this is no problem for the game I suppose ?
So FD, can we have an official poll about that ? Just so we can put the whole matter at rest, since according to the riddles contingent here, only a handful of imbeciles are not having fun with those wonderful outside-of-the-game mysteries ? Let's see how many people are satisfied with the way the whole Alien plot is handled at the moment ...
No ? What a surprise ....
Back to the topic at hand. It is very simple to see that many are not satisfied with exploration and discovery in the game. All we have is a button to push to trigger a simplistic response and off to the next thing. Many find it ridiculous that there are so many things to be found and discovered yet there are virtually no tools to find things with.
[Snip a lot of common sense]