Xenobiology study of Thargoid Ship Logograms - Compendium

Here's a thing I've been meaning to do for ages.

There's always been speculation of what that mark on the barnacles, and now in the middle of the Thargoid markings, actually is.

One theory is that it's a representation of a large-scale stellar structure that's important to the Thargoids, and several have been suggested. The two I hear most are Barnard's loop and the Large Magellanic Cloud.

I'm exploring around the edges of the Col70 sector (one possible origin point for the Thargoids, based on the events of Premonition and the triangulated location of the Probe signals, plus it's all permit locked which makes it seem more suspicious!).

So I took pics of both of these structures from that area, colour enhanced them, made them roughly the same scale, and altered the barnacle logo to have a similar appearance so it's easier to compare.

https://i.imgur.com/uBiE5h9.jpg

If the icon on the barnacles resembles either of these two, it's clearly the Large Magellanic Cloud more than Barnard's loop, those odd gaps in it sort-of resemble the LMC's structures. Though it's not a great match for either really.

Just thought I'd add this into this discussion since it might have a bearing on the meaning of that central logo.

Personally I'm feeling that the resemblance is a coincidence, but if it did turn out to be the LMC I wouldn't be stunned either because it's sort-of like it.

As an addendum to this, just noticed the negative space in LMC might fit the logo.

G3cjgDN.jpg


BTW one reason I'm kinda interested in this is that there's ideas about how the Thargoids aren't from our galaxy/space at all - though that's ambiguous and afaik has never really been confirmed one way or the other. http://elite-dangerous.wikia.com/wiki/Thargoids
 
You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to Moribus again.

Right or wrong, I follow the same path. Tried to find something in 150 Gb of pics, it is faster to do it again. Same idea, "negative" of image from specific points of view in space.

 
Very egalitarian society given that all ranks & queens appear at the same rate...

Or the markings have another meaning

I had a similar thought. Why would two or three Thargoids from different queens appear in the same instance? It's a neat way of organizing the markings, but I'm not sure if I'd interpret the inner markings as belonging to a particular queen.
 
Chart Updated to 2.5 following CMDR Nicou's work. They have done extensive work in finding panel images and 1E and 2F just don't exist. They must be what I had suspected. 1Bs and 2As.
xxsU7c1.png


This should be the final chart.

Much thanks to Nicou for creating a great chart:
7aq8q5zoesqz.jpg
 
I just thought of this, but could the sounds Thargoids be making, be them trying to communicate to us in some fashion like a form of Morse code or something? I've seen people talk about the symbols or colors but not about the sounds they make.
 
Last edited:
I just thought of this, but could the sounds Thargoids be making, be them trying to communicate to us in some fashion like a form of Morse code or something? I've seen people talk about the symbols or colors but not about the sounds they make.

Could be. In FFE lore there actually are Thargoid translators invented by the Thargoids specifically for talking to us. Again, from FFE lore they tried to make peace with us several times but for (reasons) humanity ignored that and/or didn't realise what was happening and the war started.

Given that FFE isn't strictly ED lore, but there's been a significant amount of general crossover, it's likely that the Thargoids have been trying to communicate with us in several different ways already.
 
I just thought of this, but could the sounds Thargoids be making, be them trying to communicate to us in some fashion like a form of Morse code or something? I've seen people talk about the symbols or colors but not about the sounds they make.

A few pages back I posted an analysis of the sounds Thargoids make in a peaceful encounter (see link below). The spectrograms don't show any obvious encoded information. In one of the livestream videos they showed a dude playing a saxophone, which is what I think the Thargoid sounds are based on.

https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showt...s-Compendium?p=5991476&viewfull=1#post5991476
 
Speculation: Insignia outer ring = maturity.

Any note in the lore how long do they live? But we would need statistical data how many times each sign appeared in encounters.
 
Speculation: Insignia outer ring = maturity.

Any note in the lore how long do they live? But we would need statistical data how many times each sign appeared in encounters.

No lore info. There's very little on Thargoids at all, even if you take the extensive information available in FFE as fact very little of it relates to the physical creatures. Also it seems a likely assumption that they've RE-engineered themselves to some degree since then.

I personally think all the ships were seeing are "newly born" for want of a better word.
 
Last edited:
Its a strange coincidence that there are only three types of secondary rings, but multiple tertiary ones. Its very similar to how we cataloged the guardian ruins. There were alpha, Beta, and Gamma types and each one of those had various configurations. Not going to say this makes Thargoids related to guardians, just that its strange.

EDIT------------------------------

To make this weirder, there are 19 tertiary symbols. Unless I miscounted. I went off this chart
7aq8q5zoesqz.jpg

Guardian site types Beta and Gamma have 19 different logged configurations, alpha has 17. Adding this because the numbers are extremely similar on two levels now.
 
Last edited:
As an addendum to this, just noticed the negative space in LMC might fit the logo.

https://i.imgur.com/G3cjgDN.jpg

BTW one reason I'm kinda interested in this is that there's ideas about how the Thargoids aren't from our galaxy/space at all - though that's ambiguous and afaik has never really been confirmed one way or the other. http://elite-dangerous.wikia.com/wiki/Thargoids

Not the first time this has been noticed, but if that's the fit, makes more sense that they are from our galaxy, or another on the opposite side of the LMC. It only looks like that from two sides outside of it. Not inside. Since it looks like that from our galaxy, the symbol might denote Thargoids that are based in this particular galaxy. There's a good chance they are an intergalactic species that use really obvious identifiers to organize which of their units are based in which galaxy. So the barnacles and ships assigned to the Milky way bear a mark of the LMC because it looks very much the same in all parts of our galaxy and would not be there in any other galaxy. In short, that inner symbol could be their character for Milky Way
 
First of all: congrats to that amazing work @ all !

I just had following idea when watching the rows of pictograms: what if we or someone (I’d not know how to do this) would make an animated GIF of each column of signs ? For me it looks like a snap-shot of a what-so-ever sign/mark that seems to evolve in a certain way to a certain kind of XYZ (<---- insert whatever-you-want here) . However, for me it looks like the final stage seems to include the fully closed outer ring, maybe it indicates the evolutionary stage of a single Thargoid ? From that, probably if that would fit, one could conclude the behaviour of a single Thargoid and so maybe easier foresee it's or his/her reactions:

a) childhood: naive, nosy but also anxious behaviour
b) teenage: very nosy but also effervesce (is that the correct word ?) and therefore maybe highly agressive
c) adult: relatively calm, eager for knowledge but in a more scientific way, only aggressive when highly provoked
 
One of the guys in the Canonn discord found this on reddit. It certainly looks interesting, but it's missing 1E and 2F

https://i.redd.it/7aq8q5zoesqz.jpg

Even missing some of the confirmed 'grams... this arrangement makes much more sense than some of the others being used here (in this thread).


I would argue that naming the second ring (Queen 1-3) is based on supposition that has no evidence to support it... in fact the opposite seems more true due to the mix of second ring symbols found during multi-thargoid encounters.

There is that "Progression" theme once again, though :D
 
Last edited:
I've got the original screenshots that show those two you've got marked in blue, here you go:

https://i.imgur.com/szd1tDd.jpg

EDIt: This was one of the very first collections posted pretty much immediately after 2.4 dropped.

I would except this photographic evidence without the "official" scanned version as good enough to work with... not just a place holder. It would be nice to have a scan, but hardly required with good photo's...

The paint doesn't seem to "scratch off" on a 'goid... and we would have no way to prove it anyway... keeping it simple then is the way to go unless evidence pops up to show otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom