I think this is the case in a nut shell,
Quote Originally Posted by @ianw
1. CIG hugely over promised and have so far under delivered - seriously under delivered.
2. There is a natural tendency for people to like to give a lot of stick to people who bang on about how great they are going to be and then promptly fail to be great - especially after they have taken a huge amount of money on unfulfilled promises.
CIG have yet to reap the rewards for all those years of banging on about how they will be better than any other game that ever existed. They could of course silence everyone by doing all those things - but right now that doesn't look very likely.
That is actually my main irritation towards CIG and how they "promote" the project. First they go out an mock everyone and his dog, explaining how super advanced they are doing it. Then
they fail repeatably in all the goals they setup for themselves.
I clearly remember posts like; ED is boring, PG is boring SC will be so much more. Seen one seen them all, we will hand craft it all. To we have PG tech
that you haven't seen before ever! That of course will provoke an answer like "Oh really?".
They better show something we haven't seen before, not in I:, not in ED, not in Outerra or any other SIM/ game out there.
Only time will tell.
Scope, yes we know the scope of SC it will be larger and better than everything else out there because CR. [where is it]
However those who actually care to check, will see that games like ED made a huge scope list in 2012, the game was already shaped in the heads of the developers, and we are now seeing these mechanics being implemented slowly and steady, without all the fanfare and drum beating.
http://elite-dangerous.wikia.com/wiki/FAQ
That is why we are very very critical towards the projects and CIG and a developer.