I just don't get it - baffled and on the verge of uninstall - Yes I said it!

Look here FD, let me lay out some facts you already know...

So essentially this is a "why don't you love me, Jenny?" complaint.

Why is some stuff busted still? It's because they can't fix everything at once. And have a bunch of people shouting at them saying "fix it or I will uninstall!!!" so they tend to fight the biggest fires, first. Some of which, are as a consequence of doing what they were told to do. Then not-doing it again because a different fire is started by different people.

As a software product manager, you already know it's not possible to fix everything all at once for all users. But I guess the customer is always right. So I'm sure you'll 'dog food' the fix all the things too, like you say they should. ;)

edit: frontier are well aware exploration needs love; the issue isn't how, I suspect, at this point it's distilling that gargantuan feedback down into something actually deliverable.
 
Last edited:
This statement is a complete load of . FD have adjusted some sliders in the game for pew balance, that's about all. The greater development effort has been towards things that is for explorers.

  • The SUV is far more for exploration than pew
  • Barnacles
  • All the vacuum life forms
  • Everything to do with Colonia
  • Neutron stars
  • Explorer passengers
  • Fumaroles and geysers
  • Megaships
  • Asteroid bases
  • Guardian ruins
  • Thargoids have so far been all exploration


No exploration content, yeah right.

Sorry, and I don't mean to be rude, but you don't understand what we mean by exploration. Colonia is the only item in your list that comes close.
Flame retardant suit now on...
 
This statement is a complete load of . FD have adjusted some sliders in the game for pew balance, that's about all. The greater development effort has been towards things that is for explorers.

  • The SUV is far more for exploration than pew - Broken Scanner for an entire year, still not as good as it was.
  • Barnacles - Story line for Thargoids
  • All the vacuum life forms - With no way of finding them
  • Everything to do with Colonia - Really? How is this exploring?
  • Neutron stars - OK a boost jump and eye candy
  • Explorer passengers - That's a Mission to somewhere already explored and we explorers had to give FD the CoOrds!
  • Fumaroles and geysers - With no way of finding them
  • Megaships - Really? How is this exploring?
  • Asteroid bases - Really? How is this exploring?
  • Guardian ruins - Story line for Thargoids
  • Thargoids have so far been all exploration - Only found next to the bubble and not interactive and certainly not exploration


No exploration content, yeah right.

Your interpretation of exploring is different to mine.
 
Sorry, and I don't mean to be rude, but you don't understand what we mean by exploration. Colonia is the only item in your list that comes close.
Flame retardant suit now on...

Your interpretation of exploring is different to mine.

And what is your definition of pew pew? Spending time in a RNG casino? Which can also be used for FSDs?
FDEV did nothing for pew pew apart from balancing and tweaking some numbers, apart from the failed CQC update they didn't add anything.
 
Posters claiming a Poll is not accurate representation, then stating only 10% use the forum... dear lord! - Hate to break the bad news, but when you take medicine, do you realise it's not been tested on everyone! :eek: - Worse still, probably not tested on you! Scary eh? Well unless you go with the sample of people they did test on... some 0.01% of humans at best :rolleyes:

So lets remove the poll feature? #DontUnderstand

Lunacy I tell ye!
 
And what is your definition of pew pew? Spending time in a RNG casino? Which can also be used for FSDs?

Pooh Pew for me is shooting at ships till they pop - everything else added was to make things pop faster or pop slower - That's how I see it.

Which is why you will continue whining, no matter what FD delivers.

How is any of what I have listed not exploration?

Put the onion head down - I even explained in bold
 
And what is your definition of pew pew? Spending time in a RNG casino? Which can also be used for FSDs?
FDEV did nothing for pew pew apart from balancing and tweaking some numbers, apart from the failed CQC update they didn't add anything.

Agreed,start a pew pew complaint thread, I'll support you.

@ Limoncello Lizard, the list you made becomes totally useless once you have gone 1000 LYs from SOL. Colonia being the exception(unless you are in the rest of the galaxy,I've never been there), even the new Neutron star games mechanic is not used by explorers(requiring plotting a new route after,and repairs).
 
Last edited:
Pooh Pew for me is shooting at ships till they pop - everything else added was to make things pop faster or pop slower - That's how I see it.



Put the onion head down - I even explained in bold

Well you have no idea what you are talking about. You can't even name a single feature that I couldn't take apart like you did with Limoncello's post.

Agreed,start a pew pew complaint thread, I'll support you.
The list you made becomes totally useless once you have gone 1000 LYs from SOL. Colonia being the exception, even the new Neutron star games mechanic is not used by explorers(requiring plotting a new route after,and repairs).

I didn't even make a list. You are talking to the wrong person. It's also besides the point, Limoncello disagreed with a comment that said "all FDEV added was pew pew stuff". That's just plain wrong.
 
Well you have no idea what you are talking about. You can't even name a single feature that I couldn't take apart like you did with Limoncello's post.



I didn't even make a list. You are talking to the wrong person. It's also besides the point, Limoncello disagreed with a comment that said "all FDEV added was pew pew stuff". That's just plain wrong.

My bad,will edit now.
 
Well you have no idea what you are talking about.


I never claimed to be an expert, it there a list somewhere of what pooh pew is? I've only seen videos of people shooting ships - I've done that too! Had no idea there was more to it, maybe i'll take another look - what can you do that does not involve shooting stuff?
 
Here we disagree. He didn't take anything apart, just said it isn't exploration. Just because he says it isn't doesn't make it so.

It's not like he doesn't have a point. But...

'Fumaroles and geysers - With no way of finding them
Megaships - Really? How is this exploring?'

Finding lost Megaships is definetely exploring, and there are even ways to find them ingame!

However saying that the Thargoid storyline is a feature for explorers is very much like saying the SLF is for canyon racing and not for combat. It's true, but a very subjective opinion.
 
I never claimed to be an expert, it there a list somewhere of what pooh pew is? I've only seen videos of people shooting ships - I've done that too! Had no idea there was more to it, maybe i'll take another look - what can you do that does not involve shooting stuff?

The claim was:
"FDEV added more for pew pew than anything else".
Limoncello's claim was:
"That's wrong they didn't add much for pew pew, they added more for exploration."
Your claim is:
"These features are not exploration (or not good enough)"

I am not saying you are wrong, but neither is Limoncello. The whole pew pew bashing needs to stop if people want me to take the lack of love for explorers serious.
 
Look here FD, let me lay out some facts you already know...

The vast majority of your customers play Elite to enjoy the Milky way (FACT) you created based on 'what we know now' and what a blooming fantastic job you did! (FACT) ... some 3 years + ago...
Since then you have slowly but surely degraded your work (FACT), I would not mind if it had just stayed the same! But with each release your masterpiece gets another slice taken out of it. Please try to tread more carefully through the flowerbed you made because it's starting to look like a muddy puddle!

Now I'm a Software product manager by day and I understand the pressures of your boardroom and all the favours you have to pull to satisfy some of the big backers and investors, delivering those features you promised them and no-doubt they are still banging on the table asking when 'whatnot' and 'whatever' is going to be delivered..been there, burnt the t-shirt.

Now you have to strike a balance between what you promised the big investors and what your customers want.. because if you don't you will be delivering 'whatnot' and 'whatever' to a playerless server.. That's the tip of the iceberg though. Your once loyal player base will have gone, many trashing the reputation of FD and moving on to the competition.. Then you know what happens next right? The same investors you tried to appease in the short term will be very cross!

The answer to this problem is to tell your investors to sit the jolly well down and let you work your magic at your own speed and introduce their 'whatnots' and 'whatevers' when you are ready.

Now I understand you have to get the Thargoids out the door (2.4) so i'm not expecting any love in 2.4. But please, in 3.0 or whatever version ID comes next, can you show some love for the vast majority of your customers who backed you from day one... That's right, show some love for the explorers, because right now i'm on the edge and I'm confident i'm not alone. I Can't bear to see the exploration role get any worse, it's heart breaking.

Thanks for listening and spare a thought for the explorers in the planning of 3.0.... I hope to say 'Right on FD!'

Best regards

Nutter

o7
Reading this first part I found myself saying 'huh, what, naaah, what now?' a lot.

(EDIT) For those who know not what I speak of... Here is the poll on prefered gameplay https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php/324892-What-Profession-are-you
And here is a list of things that have got worse

Beige Bug
Terrain Nerf
Adding eye candy but no tools to find it
Not adding any new exploring tools
System Map degraded
Galaxy map degraded, verging on broken
Sky Map Degraded with 'dust'
Total lack of love for explorers

For Starters

Then I read the edit addon and was like 'oooh, yeah, sure - I kinda get where you're coming from'.

You had me disagreeing with you until the edit.

As I'm not really an explorer, I will see myself out ..
 
Last edited:
This statement is a complete load of . FD have adjusted some sliders in the game for pew balance, that's about all. The greater development effort has been towards things that is for explorers.

  • The SUV is far more for exploration than pew
  • Barnacles
  • All the vacuum life forms
  • Everything to do with Colonia
  • Neutron stars
  • Explorer passengers
  • Fumaroles and geysers
  • Megaships
  • Asteroid bases
  • Guardian ruins
  • Thargoids have so far been all exploration


No exploration content, yeah right.

See I can draw a comparison here albeit a hypothetical one.

What if FD produced a load of new ships to destroy, new super special other stuff to pew pew....BUT didn't produce any way to destroy them? That would be rubbish.

Well exploration is a bit like this. Yes we can see the content and stuff but no way to find it other than mark one eyeball and well.....being told it's there through some convuluted puzzle or other (not exploration either).

I guess in my example you could RAM the new stuff to death and be told to be happy with it. But I do7bt you would be :)
 
Look here FD, let me lay out some facts you already know...

The vast majority of your customers play Elite to enjoy the Milky way (FACT) you created based on 'what we know now' and what a blooming fantastic job you did! (FACT) ... some 3 years + ago...
Since then you have slowly but surely degraded your work (FACT), I would not mind if it had just stayed the same! But with each release your masterpiece gets another slice taken out of it. Please try to tread more carefully through the flowerbed you made because it's starting to look like a muddy puddle!

Now I'm a Software product manager by day and I understand the pressures of your boardroom and all the favours you have to pull to satisfy some of the big backers and investors, delivering those features you promised them and no-doubt they are still banging on the table asking when 'whatnot' and 'whatever' is going to be delivered..been there, burnt the t-shirt.

Now you have to strike a balance between what you promised the big investors and what your customers want.. because if you don't you will be delivering 'whatnot' and 'whatever' to a playerless server.. That's the tip of the iceberg though. Your once loyal player base will have gone, many trashing the reputation of FD and moving on to the competition.. Then you know what happens next right? The same investors you tried to appease in the short term will be very cross!

The answer to this problem is to tell your investors to sit the jolly well down and let you work your magic at your own speed and introduce their 'whatnots' and 'whatevers' when you are ready.

Now I understand you have to get the Thargoids out the door (2.4) so i'm not expecting any love in 2.4. But please, in 3.0 or whatever version ID comes next, can you show some love for the vast majority of your customers who backed you from day one... That's right, show some love for the explorers, because right now i'm on the edge and I'm confident i'm not alone. I Can't bear to see the exploration role get any worse, it's heart breaking.

Thanks for listening and spare a thought for the explorers in the planning of 3.0.... I hope to say 'Right on FD!'

Best regards

Nutter

o7

(EDIT) For those who know not what I speak of... Here is the poll on prefered gameplay https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php/324892-What-Profession-are-you
And here is a list of things that have got worse

Beige Bug
Terrain Nerf
Adding eye candy but no tools to find it
Not adding any new exploring tools
System Map degraded
Galaxy map degraded, verging on broken
Sky Map Degraded with 'dust'
Total lack of love for explorers

For Starters

I've said this before and I'll say it again, Frontier need to move to a model where they are doing more regular, smaller delivery of features with point released every 6 weeks.

From what I've heard of 2.4 I think they are moving closer to that. Large scale drops don't allow for smaller bugs and QoL features to make it to release potentially for months, in the meantime players get more frustrated.

I don't expect larger features to drop in these, they most likely will still need to go out in major releases - but if bugs are fixed in point releases then that is less of an issue.
 
See I can draw a comparison here albeit a hypothetical one.

What if FD produced a load of new ships to destroy, new super special other stuff to pew pew....BUT didn't produce any way to destroy them? That would be rubbish.

Well exploration is a bit like this. Yes we can see the content and stuff but no way to find it other than mark one eyeball and well.....being told it's there through some convuluted puzzle or other (not exploration either).

I guess in my example you could RAM the new stuff to death and be told to be happy with it. But I do7bt you would be :)

- Conflict zones suck and are completely unrealistic
- The Engineers suck
- There are no NPC wingmen
- There are no real bounty hunter mechanics
- They didn't add anything meaningful to combat for the last 2 years
- etc.

This argument really goes both ways. And starting a fight between pew pew players and explorers is really stupid when we should just stay together and ask FDEV to improve the game for everyone.
 
Back
Top Bottom