16 hours in and I've hit level 13. Playing on Hard.
Time to be objective and give some thoughts especially on the negatives here.
I'm enjoying the game as a preface, to quote the very first post in the thread - is this the "end of gaming"? Sadly not, not by a long shot I feel.
- it's very "open world", yes I know that's always been the thing but it has that "homogenous" "samey" feeling I get from all open world games (aside from Witcher 3!) This is disappointing for me as after Witcher 3 I sort of hoped for better from CDP than a slightly better job over what say Ubisoft would do.
- Driving is at best an Ok experience, for game that placed alot on its wheeled experience it's so far a basic thing, no game has done driving round a city better than the original Mafia in any case. CDP havent failed here as such and its multi factor thing but it's not exciting me at all.
- Combat, whoa the big one, it's fairly crap really, the AI is largely as thick as I had hoped it wouldnt be. I had limited expectations of this from CDP, the AI largely pounds you but the reverse isnt so true. Many of the AI will on hard knock you in 2 to 3 shots. The same cannot be said for you whatsoever. Luckily (or sadly) the AI has the intelligence of a sprat and displays little to no creativity in taking you on. Many of the weapons give bonuses to certain damage but looking through them in the UI is painful and we go to
....
- The UI...which is truly uninspired and clunky to use. The game telegraphs a lot of information through the menus and UI and how much of it is actually useful or doing anything useful is anyone's guess.
- Looting...the whole place is very unsatisfying from a loot point of view, theres so much of everything nothing feels good to loot. I've picked up the gross national product of India in the form of Trousers and boots but very few stick out as items I'd think of keeping. This is a common problem with open world games. Everything goes into the recycler.
- Missions...thankfully this is one area that has received a little of the old CDP magic. But only just a little. The side missions which people seem to really like just havent lit me up that much. I've done maybe a dozen of them along with similar number of "gigs" and I'm pressed to remember any of them in any way. Theres certainly not the same quality here as we had in Witcher series.
The jobs come to you via the phone (often at worst possible times) and theres no agency to them other than this bloke or that bird want you to sort out their niff naff and trivia, it also doesn't seem to tall you what rewards to expect anywhere, which seem to be majority of the time money. The Car and Bike selling bits from the fixers over the phone borders on Spam also. Anyways I dont think we'll see side quests here with anything like the meat that Witcher 3 was able to put out there.
The little things...
Anyway not an exhaustive list, trying to put this together while making chicken dinner I'm sure you guys will have seen or not seen the above and probably add to it better than I.
A bit meh sadly, a strong 7 game at the moment. Not the end of gaming.
Time to be objective and give some thoughts especially on the negatives here.
I'm enjoying the game as a preface, to quote the very first post in the thread - is this the "end of gaming"? Sadly not, not by a long shot I feel.
- it's very "open world", yes I know that's always been the thing but it has that "homogenous" "samey" feeling I get from all open world games (aside from Witcher 3!) This is disappointing for me as after Witcher 3 I sort of hoped for better from CDP than a slightly better job over what say Ubisoft would do.
- Driving is at best an Ok experience, for game that placed alot on its wheeled experience it's so far a basic thing, no game has done driving round a city better than the original Mafia in any case. CDP havent failed here as such and its multi factor thing but it's not exciting me at all.
- Combat, whoa the big one, it's fairly crap really, the AI is largely as thick as I had hoped it wouldnt be. I had limited expectations of this from CDP, the AI largely pounds you but the reverse isnt so true. Many of the AI will on hard knock you in 2 to 3 shots. The same cannot be said for you whatsoever. Luckily (or sadly) the AI has the intelligence of a sprat and displays little to no creativity in taking you on. Many of the weapons give bonuses to certain damage but looking through them in the UI is painful and we go to
....
- The UI...which is truly uninspired and clunky to use. The game telegraphs a lot of information through the menus and UI and how much of it is actually useful or doing anything useful is anyone's guess.
- Looting...the whole place is very unsatisfying from a loot point of view, theres so much of everything nothing feels good to loot. I've picked up the gross national product of India in the form of Trousers and boots but very few stick out as items I'd think of keeping. This is a common problem with open world games. Everything goes into the recycler.
- Missions...thankfully this is one area that has received a little of the old CDP magic. But only just a little. The side missions which people seem to really like just havent lit me up that much. I've done maybe a dozen of them along with similar number of "gigs" and I'm pressed to remember any of them in any way. Theres certainly not the same quality here as we had in Witcher series.
The jobs come to you via the phone (often at worst possible times) and theres no agency to them other than this bloke or that bird want you to sort out their niff naff and trivia, it also doesn't seem to tall you what rewards to expect anywhere, which seem to be majority of the time money. The Car and Bike selling bits from the fixers over the phone borders on Spam also. Anyways I dont think we'll see side quests here with anything like the meat that Witcher 3 was able to put out there.
The little things...
- bugs, can get over them largely and some are entertaining.
- logic leaps in main missions where characters dont explain or acknowledge certain things that really they ought to. Difficult to explain this as I don't want to spoiler anything.
Anyway not an exhaustive list, trying to put this together while making chicken dinner I'm sure you guys will have seen or not seen the above and probably add to it better than I.
A bit meh sadly, a strong 7 game at the moment. Not the end of gaming.