It's not 1984 anymore. Well, the guys who wanted a copy of the old games are the die hard fans who resist any change now and cheer because it seems they're OK with a boring space truck "simulator" and love to write routes down on paper or into Excel sheets.
Probably they are the loudest die hard fanboy crowd, but I doubt they're the majority today. The game just lacks a living and believable universe. If you're happy with just trucking virtual goods from A to B and spending hours in "super boring cruise" you've already got your simple time sink. Be happy.
I'm to lazy to repeat myself and lots of other people here, so to make it short: The game lacks any depth. Anything that would create a binding with the player. There are NO reason to do anything, it lacks the purpose to do something. Why would I do something for any of the factions? No "face", not even a simple logo, no background story nothing that makes me think "Hey I want to do something for them because...!". The only goal right now is to get more money and the next ship or better equipment. But wait... What can I do better with the next better ship? Right: Making more money by trade or kills. Why would I help any of the three major factions? Besides the fact they don't even feature visual differences you'll have to read plenty of text and you have to follow Galnet to get the story. I personally don't mind doing it but that's like reading a book. I can read it but it won't impact my game. I don't care if I kill Feds or Empire - it's the same and my benefit (Credits) is the same.
Now some fanboy will jump in screaming "BUT ITS ALL ABOUT YOUR IMAGINATION!" Seriously? If I would just like to use my imagination I would read a book and not play a game that lacks any purpose and depth.
I think you've pretty much nailed it there mate
I'm looking for a reason to play the game other than to make a few spacebux driving an internet spaceship.
At the moment I feel like I'm in the preparation stage. Making a bit of cash and testing out different ships/loadouts to support my eventual endeavours - which will more than likely be some form of warfare. The game currently supports this just fine - like others have said - a solid foundation. I'm hoping the new year will bring us more in the way of space adventures though