This alpha has great potential. FD doesn't really realize how much really.
First, the game(when completed) can captivate so many, from so many different tastes. But for that they need to put the same effort on multiple areas. Risk vs Reward should be the core of the game. However trading provides the most mind numbing way to make money, that dwarfs all others, for little risk. However given the original fans of the game, should they alter that there would probably be crucifixions.
Second, this project needs common sense. Data, information, numbers, overlays, lists, logs, history logs of many different types. While it is always the burden of developers to balance realism with suspension of belief, the little things have been omitted which helps either of those who seek the former or the latter. Quests, payouts, quest progression are all "designed as intended"...designed to fail.
Last, but not least, we should recall that this is an alpha. Nobody in the right state of mind would call this a game. This is not even a beta, maybe fanboys will call it a game, but it isn't. Reality is what it is, and the reality of, for example EVE, is that it took along time for that product to become a game that drew so many.
So, this alpha passed for a game may in fact be one of those rare jewels that will be further improved upon, from the little things that are overwhelmingly missing; to the large things as making different professions profitable in comparison, simply connection issues etc. This however shouldn't be confused as many all professions equal, proportionality isn't equality.
This alpha may be one of those rough diamonds that just needs more effort. Or, it may be one of those alphas that sells the brand for quick cash only to join the bin of many failed projects that turned into money grabbing schemes, relying on the original fanbase feelings to milk them for all they are worth. IN the end love is blind, and you can milk that blindman(woman) for a while until they finally decide to open their eyes.
For now, walk into this understanding that it is not a finished game. This is an alpha, at best. If you accept that, the product can become very enjoyable. FD should be advised that competition for this spot is coming, Star Citizen when it comes out will be compared to this game whether people want to or not.