What fishes do you want the most, and above all, why?

I think we could all agree that the Aquatic Pack, definitely lacked species who are 100% aquatic (with third of those being semi). So until Frontier decides to upgrade the exhibit mechanics, I would like to ask which type of fish could fit in this game the best. Including a good explanation for your choices such as endangered status, captive representation, or of its uniqueness. I'm really looking forward seeing what everyone else comes up with.

Just remember that they have to be easy enough, to apply in a basic aquarium system. So cartilaginous fishes like sharks and rays, are not necessary recommended. Also underwater invertebrates a different topic by themselves.

🐟 Well... Let the comments flow!
 
Last edited:
I’d like to recommend freshwater exhibits (potentially bigger then the exhibits we have)
Red bellied Piranha as they are cool and guests would love to see a feeding frenzy
Electric Eels are unique (technically they are a knife fish) and some aquariums show voltage readings.
Ocellated stingrays, many people aren’t aware that some rays live in freshwater
Maybe some of the critters found in river monsters.
sorry I got nothing on status on these fish
I’d say that’s enough South American fish even though there’s many exotic looking freshwater fish
I’ve always loved Carp and koi yet I’m sure there’s some more important Asian fish that would be more important.
 
  • Red piranha --> famous and lives in schools
  • Ocellated stingray --> same reason as the user above
  • Redtail Catfish --> striking appearance and large size, would need a extremely large aquarium though.
  • Florida gar --> primitive and interesting fish, with a more manageable size than its larger relatives.
  • Asian arowana --> endangered
  • Australian lungfish --> very unique
  • Giant Pangasius --> impressive size and critically endangered
 
I only have a few fish that I think would fit in tanks around the size of the exhibits already ingame (most of which are South American and all are river-inhabiting species):
1. Neon Tetra (Paracheirodon innesi) [DD] - A pretty little fish from the Amazon basin, one of the few fish commonly kept as pets that I think would fit within the game due to it's stunning appearance. The only issue is probably their size (they're really small, even for exhibit standards).
2. Red-Bellied Piranha (Pygocentrus nattereri) [DD] - A no brainer for this kind of concept. Piranhas are some of the most infamous fish out there, despite not deserving their reputation. The Red-Bellied species just so happens to be the most recognisable (and my personal favourite).
3. Freshwater Angelfish (Pterophyllum scalare) [DD] - The most common species of it's genus in the aquarium trade. They're also very pretty. (Can be interchangeable with the Altum Angelfish, another species in the same genus, just exclusive to the Orinoco)
4. Electric Eel (Electrophorus electricus) [LC] - I can't really articulate the words on this one, but other people have made decent points for it's inclusion.
5. Banded Archerfish (Toxotes jaculatrix) [LC] - A unique type of fish I included on the list to boost Australasian representation on the list.
6. Glass Catfish (Kryptopterus vitreolus) [DD] - A cool see-through fish from Asian rivers. I don't know if it's possible to do see-through animals within the confines of the game though, so this might be off limits.
7. Red-Tailed Black Shark (Epalzeorhynchos bicolor) [CR] - Unrelated to actual sharks, the Red-Tailed Black Shark are fairly common in the aquarium trade despite being critically endangered in the wild.
8. Clown Loach (Chromobotia macracanthus) [LC] - Literally just here because I think they look pretty.
9. Australian Lungfish (Neoceratodus forsteri) [EN] - A unique type of fish from Oceania that is also endangered! A win-win for it's potential inclusion!

Now, I know a lot of that list is from fish commonly kept as pets, so I thought that I'd spice it up with some larger species that might require something a bit different (unless the aquarium system is completely new and can accommodate these species as well):
1. Alligator Gar (Atractosteus spatula) [LC] - A large and ancient predator of the river systems it inhabits the alligator gar... is really cool. I just really like this fish, that's my reasoning.
2. Giant Arapaima (Arapaima gigas) [DD] - One of the largest freshwater fish in the world, the arapaima is an obvious pick if we're going to talk about bigger fish. They're massive, gorgeous, and would go wonderfully well in an Amazon themed part of a zoo (especially in an indoor aquarium section, obviously).
3. Redtail Catfish (Phractocephalus hemioliopterus) [DD] - This one's just here to complement the Arapaima, still beautiful in it's own right though.
4. Black Pacu (Colossoma macropomum) [DD] - Same reasoning as the Redtail Catfish above.
5. Asian Arowana (Scleropages formosus) [EN] - A vibrant and endangered predatory fish. I think we can all agree that this is the most appealing species of arowana.
6. Sturgeon (Family: Acipenseridae) [LC-CR] - I honestly don't mind what species we get, but I feel like sturgeon would make a lot of sense from the perspective of conservation. So many species are either endangered or critically endangered!
7. American Paddlefish (Polyodon spathula) [VU] - Probably the fish I'm most divided on, mainly because I don't know how many are in captivity. Although, I do think they should get in, both to accompany the Alligator gar and because of how unique they are (especially now that the Chinese Paddlefish is extinct).

They are many other types of animals that could fit in here as well (Manatees, Axolotls, Turtles etc.), but I know that this thread is purely for fish so I'll keep tight-lipped on that until some other thread pops up on the topic :)
 
  • Red piranha --> famous and lives in schools
  • Ocellated stingray --> same reason as the user above
  • Redtail Catfish --> striking appearance and large size, would need a extremely large aquarium though.
  • Florida gar --> primitive and interesting fish, with a more manageable size than its larger relatives.
  • Asian arowana --> endangered
  • Australian lungfish --> very unique
  • Giant Pangasius --> impressive size and critically endangered
Lungfish, piranha and arowana would be on my short list too.

I think paddlefish would be cool for north america. And electric eels
 
For a few sets... going with about 2 exhibits equal 1 habitat for it

Freshwater
Asian Arrowana, Alligator Gar, Freshwater Stingray, American Paddlefish, and Red Bellied Piranha (Exhibit).

Freshwater 2
Arapima, Black Pacu, Koi, Redtail Catfish, Electric Eel (Exhibit)

Saltwater
Bull Shark, Manta Ray, Mola Mola Sunfish, Bluefin Tuna, and Deep Sea Anglerfish (Exhibit)

Reef
Blacktip Reef Shark, Common Eagle Ray, Goliath Grouper. Clownfish/Anemone (Exhibit: Anemone as, basically decor), Blue Tang (Exhibit), Lionfish (Exhibit), and Moray Eel (Exhibit)
 
Small colorful reef fish like yellow tangs or lionfish for an exhibit.
Blacktip reef sharks
Leopard sharks
leopard-shark-02.jpg
 
For a few sets... going with about 2 exhibits equal 1 habitat for it

Freshwater
Asian Arrowana, Alligator Gar, Freshwater Stingray, American Paddlefish, and Red Bellied Piranha (Exhibit).

Freshwater 2
Arapima, Black Pacu, Koi, Redtail Catfish, Electric Eel (Exhibit)

Saltwater
Bull Shark, Manta Ray, Mola Mola Sunfish, Bluefin Tuna, and Deep Sea Anglerfish (Exhibit)

Reef
Blacktip Reef Shark, Common Eagle Ray, Goliath Grouper. Clownfish/Anemone (Exhibit: Anemone as, basically decor), Blue Tang (Exhibit), Lionfish (Exhibit), and Moray Eel (Exhibit)
Small colorful reef fish like yellow tangs or lionfish for an exhibit.
Blacktip reef sharks
Leopard sharks
View attachment 203100
Ehhh, would you two at least explain your selections please??
 
Here're mine. All of these are chosen because I find them interesting:

1. Piranha and their relatives, such as Pacu and Palometa - those are fish my dad grew up around
2. Black Ghost Knifefish - relative of the much larger Electric Eel and something I've wanted in my tank
3. Alligator Gar - the largest one I've seen is one I accidentally fished (although 2 1/2 feet is nothing to Jeremy Wade)
4. Coelacanth? - not sure if they can be in captivity, but living fossils are always cool
5. Electric Eel - do I need a reason?
6. Octopus - I like octopi, but I don't know exactly which species can thrive in captivity, since some die months later and others get too big. If I had a choice, then the Blue Ring Octopus
7. Nurse Shark - I know sharks are out of the question, but what about this small species?
8. Guitarfish - a shark/ray hybrid, practically
9. Lionfish - plain cool
10. Arowana - since Arapaima are huge and can be dangerous, an Arowana is the most logical substitute


Those are my choices
 
6. Octopus - I like octopi, but I don't know exactly which species can thrive in captivity, since some die months later and others get too big.
Octopus generally don’t live long in captivity. Some can live up to 5 years. In particular by the time a giant pacific octopus turns 5 existence becomes painful for them. They stop eating and decide they want to breed and die shortly afterwards, during that time they get seriously aggressive and attempt to escape.
 
ooo...Barracuda.

I also think rays would mostly work just fine (not the larger Oceanic Manta Rays of course). I love stingrays so if they were to do some kind of smaller aquarium set up I'd hope for them. Garfish as well, Lionfish, Pufferfish...

I don't see them doing this but if they were to do deep sea species angler and viper fish.

Sharks I definitely don't see coming, unless they decided to go for "habitat" sized animals. We have the ability to make aquariums now, just no fully marine species to go with it but I'm not sure those habitat sized animals (whales, sharks mainly) would fit the conservation theme.

Overall I'm still thinking we'll see nothing of any of this as they will probably do a separate Planet Aquarium game, I'm guessing.
 
African Cichlids from the Victoria, Tanganyika and Malawi lakes.
uBkLiXH.jpg


Then the South American varieties.

🐠
 
Last edited:
Ehhh, would you two at least explain your selections please??
My first two are all freshwater, going for larger fish that could work and I've seen displayed on their own in larger exhibits. The exhibit animals are smaller ones but big enough to be easily seen. The second two largely follow the same thing, save for the one with larger numbers of exhibit animals because most of the iconic reef fish tend to be on the smaller end, and a lot of the larger fish as deeper water.

If I move out of a just fish thing, there are others that would be mixed in such as octopi and sea turtles along with jellyfish, lobsters, and similar things. Freshwater would also have things like that which move away from the "fish" side of things.
 
I’m not to sure frontier plans on doing fish but it would complement a already amazing game. I’m not sure frontier has to go through the trouble of feeding animations and what not. I think swimming animations and as a habitat fill in would probably be easier for frontier. Ideas that come to mind:
D9B949AE-08DF-4695-AE31-9E1F75104EF3.jpeg

0BCB3FA4-9CE5-4815-A813-E8FADB6F98AA.jpeg

93ED7E01-71DF-4855-B67D-AD12FB87ED38.jpeg

I seen a nice Mississippi style habitat featuring alligator, alligator gar, and big catfish. I’ve also seen hippos with fish and a Florida manatee with gar and catfish.
 
I’m not to sure frontier plans on doing fish but it would complement a already amazing game. I’m not sure frontier has to go through the trouble of feeding animations and what not. I think swimming animations and as a habitat fill in would probably be easier for frontier. Ideas that come to mind:
View attachment 203629
View attachment 203630
View attachment 203631
I seen a nice Mississippi style habitat featuring alligator, alligator gar, and big catfish. I’ve also seen hippos with fish and a Florida manatee with gar and catfish.

Those pictures make me realize I would actually even just settle for realistic looking fish props. I mean, sure moving fish would be even better but it'd be something. I may have to do some more workshop digging. or use what I already subscribed to and make some faux aquariums.
 
Back
Top Bottom