I've never understood why people find it strange that some straight guys like to create female avatars.
They are straight guys so why would they want to spend their gaming time looking at a male character? This is especially true when playing a third person game. Makes sense to me that a guy is perfectly happy watching the butt of a female character rather than watching the butt of a male character.
Whilst some people claim to be confused about this issue, I have to wonder if they might actually in truth be confused about something else entirely...
This kind of heteronormative argument you see everywhere is clearly false, because the exact same people will bang on about how they want immersion and role play at the same time. By that crazy logic, lesbians would only use female avatars to ogle the goodies on screen, rather than represent who they are as a human being.
If you want to 'be' in the game world, why would you pick something that isn't you?
To just say it's because heterosexual men like to objectify women's bodies is a poor, and very sad argument, and says more about the people that do that than anything that they say.
You're not wrong, but... personally, I don't think you're reflecting what's actually going in on these conversations. It's about gender essentialism, but since (male) society doesn't know how to talk about it and is heteronormative, the conversations always end up coded as being about sexuality.
What's with all the guys using female avatars?
This guy (the OP) is probably a gender essentialist. (I'll assume male here, but doesn't need to be... and I'm about to make some more serious assumptions for the sake of making a point.) His biological sex is male, he's probably considered cisgender, but moreover he actually
experiences maleness. He has an actual 'gender identity', in the way that not all men do. Imagining roleplaying a female character in a game is a bit dysphoric. (Calling it gender dysphoria is a bit like calling an itch 'agony', but you see what I'm getting at.)
A
lot of other people don't really experience essential gender identity in the same way, I think. And it's sort of this hidden divide, and a pretty damaging one. Because... take trans people. Kind of by definition, they actually have gender identities. They experience dysphoria 24/7 in their own bodies because the gender identity they experience ain't the body they're in. And because we don't really know how to say "hey, about half (maybe) of people experience gender identity and half don't", trans people are often stuck unable to explain dysphoria to people like me.
Me being someone who has a biological sex, obviously, but doesn't really get the big deal about gender identity. I'll roleplay male characters, female characters, whatever, and it's all the same to me. Gender dysphoria doesn't really make sense to me. But for people
like me, it's really tempting to fight back against the first group by really stressing that hey, we're straight, obviously we like
looking at the other sex.
So... I could be wrong in this instance (maybe some people really
do just want a slice of pornography with their gaming... I mean... Tomb Raider), but I think generally when you see a heteronormative argument pop up like this, it's a pre-emptive defence against other imagined heteronormative arguments. It's all about saying "No,
I'm straight!" (...arguably, the real problem going on here isn't objectifying women, but in this instance it's the implicit assumption that not being straight is 'less'.)
And to the OP: if you don't really have a strong sense of gender identity, you're probably going to play opposite sex characters quite a bit, even a bit more than half the time. Why a bit more? Because you play a same sex character pretty much your whole life. Both men and women regularly find it 'novel' to play the other sex in games... hence the (rough) truism that all female characters in games are played by men, and all women in games play male characters. Though the second half of that is a lot to do with abuse too.
I for the life of me cannot make a male character that doesn't look like a mutated caveman. Because of that, I cannot make a male character that somewhat resembles me, so that leaves me two options: with relatively little effort, make a random, decent-looking female character that doesn't represent me, or spend a greater amount of effort making a horribly disfigured random guy that doesn't represent me.
Ah, well, some of us have ActuallyLookLikeAMutatedCaveman privilege, I guess.