Elite Dangerous is the Largest Empty Sandbox Ever Made

Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
...and the rest of your list is a list of things which have no place in Elite.

Do remember that the fundamental premise of Elite is that each player is just a simple schmuck. Not a central character, a protagonist, secondary character or person of any importance whatsoever. That list breaks the fundamental premise. None of us player characters are main plot hero's and nor should we ever become central characters.

Yours Aye

Mark H

Don't be so quick to dismiss that list. Some of it could be worked into Elite and fit quite nicely.


  • Clans / Guilds is just an official group of players. Like any other registered social group or club, it would fit in the lore
  • Manufacturing would give a reason besides RNGneers or FSD boosts to use the SRV
  • Small player owned structures out in deep space would open up new game play as clans need to move stock / equipment that way and could be a nice group project to build a small outpost away from the bubble


There are ways to get some of it in while holding to the Elite universe and still being an individual. You could also do this in any mode, so Solo players could work towards an outpost either for themselves or as part of a guild / clan
 
Oh yes, more emergent jump-honk :D

You know guys, the decision was taken and we will have guilds, player driven economy, player owned stations etc. It’s a matter of time. You know why? Because FD has all data. Your community, beside how vocal is, is not profitable. With ultimate ship ASP, how much have you spent in frontier store? Now take a look on some SDC video. A lot of ships, all of them painted, colored weapons and engines, ship kits. MMO players are buying cosmetics for a lot of ships to look cool in the eyes of others. Most of you have LTEP, one or two ships and you play in solo.

You are certainly filling the 'what do assumptions make...' void beautifully.
 
I don't think that's entirely true Jason, I've had more than my fair share of beefs with SDC but, as you'll see from my post in that thread you linked, I thought their proposal was pretty good. The thing is it involves far to much evasion and carrot and not enough stick, it's not about wanting to avoid progress but stearing clear of progress that is only beneficial to criminals.

And the problem SDC, scrub that, any of us have when posting here is our posting history and our action and preferences in game. SDC can't expect a clean slate when suggesting something considering their previous actions any more than a Mobius member can. Rightly or wrongly we all do it, it's happening from both sides in this very thread and in recent posts, SDC shouldn't expect a waiver simply because of a well presented but flawed idea.

That's weird i've never seen you in-game in the last 3 years. Are you sure you are not hidding in solo? PVP on the forums ain't part of the real game brah.
 
Last edited:
That's weird i've never seen you in-game in the last 3 years. Are you sure you are not hidding in solo? PVP on the forums ain't part of real game brah.

I'm certain of it Sole, was on for three hours yesterday evening, no 'brah' action though not even from the missus!
 
That's weird i've never seen you in-game in the last 3 years. Are you sure you are not hidding in solo? PVP on the forums ain't part of real game brah.

And how many others playing this game have you not "seen in-game in the last 3 years"? What does that even matter?

With P2P instancing it's possible there's a great many people you haven't seen. Why does that mean they're all "hidding in solo" as you put it?
 

ALGOMATIC

Banned
Be honest, what bloody skill does it take to pop a parked up explorer vessel?, or wing up with three buddies in engineered to the nines FDL's and pop a multi role Python or trader T6?

Some of you bang on about 'skill' and 'cutthroat galaxy' yet go to great lengths to avoid any of that yourselves. Some of the PVP pilots in this game are very, very good at what they do but there is also a flock if pretenders who are taking the safe space, easy mode route as much, if not more than any solo player.

If this directed at me I can easily prove you wrong, if its not directed my way - carry on.
 
OP is right. Elite is great to show to friends in VR. Apart from that, it's pretty dull. I would love the ability to build a base of my own and manage trade routs etc.
 
If this directed at me I can easily prove you wrong, if its not directed my way - carry on.

It was partially directed at you because at the time of that post folk were discussing the difference between PVP and popping a parked up Asp E. You brought 'skillz' (facepalm), into it at that stage so I'll ask you again, what skill is there in popping a parked ship or a 4 on 1 FDL wing gank on a T6???
 

ALGOMATIC

Banned
It was partially directed at you because at the time of that post folk were discussing the difference between PVP and popping a parked up Asp E. You brought 'skillz' (facepalm), into it at that stage so I'll ask you again, what skill is there in popping a parked ship or a 4 on 1 FDL wing gank on a T6???

This doesn't require skill, never said it was. I ussually talk about pvp content where I mention skills.
 
OP is right. Elite is great to show to friends in VR. Apart from that, it's pretty dull. I would love the ability to build a base of my own and manage trade routs etc.

Trade routes would be a difficult one, with external tools calculating profit per tonne and shortest routes from Data from players,
As fast as you find a route, it's already advertised to more than enough other players that it is dead in a few days.

See while people harp on about player own bases, and I'm not opposed to them if folks want them, then I'm happy to throw my support to the idea (for what it is worth).
Fixing yourself to a location seems like a bad idea to me if your primary income is from trade. As you may have to keep moving to match the new trade routes.

Now some sort of clan/guild carrier ship that could follow CGs about or move to the latest trade routes you want to work would be nice.
 
Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom