Hi Eliza,
Following this process, why wouldn't people just skip the FSS then? Or do you suggest the ADS should only work after you scanned everything with the FSS first? If so, this won't satisfy the FSS opponents... If not, the FSS is entirely redundant, and everybody would just ADS honk.
Hi, Mangal!
I tried to implement the "Best of both worlds". As far as I got it, the reasonable "anti-fss"-crowd complained about that the FSS gives too much body-data to the player. They don't doom the FSS in the first place. There are alot of, let's call them "professional explorers", who simply want a REASON to cruise through the system. And to be honest, I can understand them. The old ADS-Honk didn't gave you nothing but the position of the bodies present in the system. You had to cruise to the bodie to examine it to the fullest. Now you have to do nothing but to "fiddle with knobs". Please don't get mie wrong. I like the feel of the FSS, but it simply gives away too much information. Lots of credits without the real need to " have earned" them.
The FSS is a "tourist-tool" to get as fast as possible to the desired destination, enjoy the sightseeing, and grab a mountain of cash.
The "Profesionals" like me, okay...I'm "only" a "semi-pro", are REALLY enjoying the need to cruise to a bodie to explore it to the fullest. It's like the old need of humanity to get to Moon/Mars IN PERSON. Why would NASA / ESA / Space-X trying to get a (Wo)Man to Mars if the Rovers can do all the job for pretty pictures.
So Yes... You have to use the "old Honk" to get a positive solution of the body-position nothing more, If you want a general information about the bodies discovered you have to "fiddle with knobs" / "whack the moles". But if you want more (credits), you HAVE TO put some effort in. First you have literally only discovered the body ("look there is something at the horizon"). You want to explore it? Get your "lazy butt" into the gravity well of that rock. Now you are an explorer and you earned the title. Lastly, if you are really a sucessor of Alan Shepard, begin to improve your handicap to find the REAL GOOD STUFF (poi).
As the FSS is now live it only fits the tourists if any. And sorry, those gals/guys, like the OP complaing "I don't like it" and "This is not MY (lol) game anymore", ARE only fragging tourists. They simply don't deserve the title "explorer". But thats only my opinion about this topic
LTDR: My proposal about FSS and ADS is not redundant per se.