There’s another possibility. I think everyone so far has assumed “Princess Astrophel and the Spiralling Stars” refers to the “Astrophel and Stella” sonnets by Philip Sydney, however it might also be an association instead of a single entity, i.e. “Princess Astrophel” and “The Spiralling Stars”. Someone recently posted that they thought the earlier clue pointed towards the Maia region, and of course that is now in the Thargoid area of influence. What if the “Spiralling Stars” part of this refers to the display in a Thargoid Structure?


Could also refer to Spiral, Helix, or Cat's Eye stars, notably spiralling star sectors.
 
unfortunately I can not remember which website/youtube vid/thread I had read it as it was almost 1 and a half years ago, but the information is out there and I am just passing on what I remember seeing and/or reading. I am sure someone out there will either prove my memory wrong or not.
 
I'm fairly sure that someone in FD said that the system containing Raxxla had been visited, although this may be misinformation. Michael Brookes definitely said that there was no need for a second galaxy in the game until we have explored all of this one, bit that doesn't rule out the possibility that a star gate might be possible to another distant, possibly otherwise inaccessible location in our galaxy. The Dark Wheel is supposed to have travelled through this portal.... However, I'm not convinced fDev would have put code into the game for this rather niche circumstance. If Raxxla turns out to be an abandoned settlement, well, it would be better to travel in hope than to arrive.
 
unfortunately I can not remember which website/youtube vid/thread I had read it as it was almost 1 and a half years ago, but the information is out there and I am just passing on what I remember seeing and/or reading. I am sure someone out there will either prove my memory wrong or not.
Well... technically it’s not going to be possible for anyone to prove that your memory is wrong. Also, your memory might be right, but the person who said it might have been wrong. What I will say though is I have seen the same kind of stuff many times and it’s always been someone who’s mixing up things Drew said about the FR mystery with things about Raxxla, or mixing them up with something else entirely.
 
I'm fairly sure that someone in FD said that the system containing Raxxla had been visited, although this may be misinformation. Michael Brookes definitely said that there was no need for a second galaxy in the game until we have explored all of this one, bit that doesn't rule out the possibility that a star gate might be possible to another distant, possibly otherwise inaccessible location in our galaxy. The Dark Wheel is supposed to have travelled through this portal.... However, I'm not convinced fDev would have put code into the game for this rather niche circumstance. If Raxxla turns out to be an abandoned settlement, well, it would be better to travel in hope than to arrive.
The first bit’s a ‘a bloke down the pub reckons’ story. Everyone’s heard it. No one has ever been able to give an actual source for it.

Also, the closest there is to a canon source of info is that The Dark Wheel never found Raxxla.
 
please for the love of science can we stop thinking that raxxla is behind a permit lock or other such nonsense, having researched raxxla, the formidine rift and other mysterious goings on in ED before ps4 launch. it was said that raxxla is the only planet apart from the core systems that is not procedurally generated (it was placed in a certain spot by FDev) it has been in the game since day one and DOESN'T need any special permits or equipment to get to where it is.

Nonsense? How is this nonsense? Cite your sources for this misinformation that you’re spreading because I’m quite positive that no one has ever said this about Raxxla.

Can we also drop the “someone has visited the Raxxla system” rumor as well because that’s all it is is an unsubstantiated rumor.
 
Well... technically it’s not going to be possible for anyone to prove that your memory is wrong. Also, your memory might be right, but the person who said it might have been wrong. What I will say though is I have seen the same kind of stuff many times and it’s always been someone who’s mixing up things Drew said about the FR mystery with things about Raxxla, or mixing them up with something else entirely.

The rumor of Raxxla's honked status is old and has never been confirmed. Not that it's even important at this stage.

We can not assume that Raxxla can be found by regular exploring(scanning). It's possible that it can be found that way but, Raxxla could well be in a highly trafficked system. We have no idea of the level of obfuscation.

The same goes for permit locks. We can not assume either way. All we know is that some at FD know how to get there(Raxxla). If it's locked, there should be a way to obtain the permit or to bypass it.
 
The rumor of Raxxla's honked status is old and has never been confirmed. Not that it's even important at this stage.

We can not assume that Raxxla can be found by regular exploring(scanning). It's possible that it can be found that way but, Raxxla could well be in a highly trafficked system. We have no idea of the level of obfuscation.

The same goes for permit locks. We can not assume either way. All we know is that some at FD know how to get there(Raxxla). If it's locked, there should be a way to obtain the permit or to bypass it.
Exactly. However, I don't even think we're safe to assume that Raxxla is currently accessible through in-game mechanisms. It could, for example, include permit locks which there aren't currently ways to obtain, and which require FD action to lift (we've certainly seen Permit Locks being put in place which there's no known in game way of getting a permit for.)

On the other hand, of course, all it would take to hide it from being inadvertently found currently is for it to not show up as 'Raxxla', particularly if there's an atmospheric world involved.
 
please for the love of science can we stop thinking that raxxla is behind a permit lock or other such nonsense, having researched raxxla, the formidine rift and other mysterious goings on in ED before ps4 launch. it was said that raxxla is the only planet apart from the core systems that is not procedurally generated (it was placed in a certain spot by FDev) it has been in the game since day one and DOESN'T need any special permits or equipment to get to where it is.

me personally I think that raxxla could one of 2 things either it is a unique looking planet around a very old star near the bubble, and possibly has a large unique station in orbit around it, or then again it could also be a rather bland megaship 3 million light seconds away from a neutron star. only David Braben and a select few others know exactly where and what raxxla is, and until someone can show the proof of finding it then, I for one will keep searching for as long as it takes.

It’s very safe to assume Raxxla is behind a permit locked system. There are many minor factions protect their main systems behind permits, why would Raxxla be so vulnerable? Also we can’t say if it’s in the game from the beginning it should still be accessible with the old mechanics. Formidine Rift story evolved as the game develops and new mechanics were added as the game progresses. I hope Raxxla is not a Coriolis station you can just safe disengage.

After Horizons it might be put down to a planet/moon surface and if we can’t find it by then, they may relocate it on an atmospheric planet.


BTW Is there any updates on that “Rogue Planet systems”? They are in the game files but none discovered ever as far as I’m aware of.
 
Last edited:
It’s very safe to assume Raxxla is behind a permit locked system. There are many minor factions protect their main systems behind permits, why would Raxxla be so vulnerable? Also we can’t say if it’s in the game from the beginning it should still be accessible with the old mechanics. Formidine Rift story evolved as the game develops and new mechanics were added as the game progresses. I hope Raxxla is not a Coriolis station you can just safe disengage.

After Horizons it might be put down to a planet/moon surface and if we can’t find it by then, they may relocate it on an atmospheric planet.


BTW Is there any updates on that “Rogue Planet systems”? They are in the game files but none discovered ever as far as I’m aware of.

Yes, exactly this. All the circumstantial evidence points to Raxxla being permit locked somewhere. My guesses are in the Col 70 sector or Polaris. The rumor of Raxxla has been around since the very earliest days of interstellar travel which means it’s either in the Bubble or not very far outside it. If that’s the case then it’s very likely that someone would have stumbled across it by now, as the vast majority of the Bubble systems have been discovered. Same goes for much of the systems going out to the Pleiades.

Also, I doubt that they wanted Raxxla to be discovered before it was “ready” to be discovered. Hence tossing a permit lock on the system it’s in to safeguard against this.

I suspect that they want the new discovery scanner system to play a role in its discovery as well. Why add the Codex with a Raxxla entry at the same time as adding the new discovery scanner mini game system? This is just a hunch of course but I think it will play a role.
 
Last edited:
It’s very safe to assume Raxxla is behind a permit locked system. There are many minor factions protect their main systems behind permits, why would Raxxla be so vulnerable? Also we can’t say if it’s in the game from the beginning it should still be accessible with the old mechanics. Formidine Rift story evolved as the game develops and new mechanics were added as the game progresses. I hope Raxxla is not a Coriolis station you can just safe disengage.

After Horizons it might be put down to a planet/moon surface and if we can’t find it by then, they may relocate it on an atmospheric planet.


BTW Is there any updates on that “Rogue Planet systems”? They are in the game files but none discovered ever as far as I’m aware of.

Can’t permit lock something you don’t know where is. ;)
 
Yes, exactly this. All the circumstantial evidence points to Raxxla being permit locked somewhere. My guesses are in the Col 70 sector or Polaris. The rumor of Raxxla has been around since the very earliest days of interstellar travel which means it’s either in the Bubble or not very far outside it. If that’s the case then it’s very likely that someone would have stumbled across it by now, as the vast majority of the Bubble systems have been discovered. Same goes for much of the systems going out to the Pleiades.

Also, I doubt that they wanted Raxxla to be discovered before it was “ready” to be discovered. Hence tossing a permit lock on the system it’s in to safeguard against this.

I suspect that they want the new discovery scanner system to play a role in its discovery as well. Why add the Codex with a Raxxla entry at the same time as adding the new discovery scanner mini game system? This is just a hunch of course but I think it will play a role.
Well, as per one of my posts above, all that it takes for it to be in the bubble and not found is for nothing to come up identifying it as Raxxla. Which is actually how it really should be - how would your ship’s systems know that the body you’ve just scanned is Raxxla? (Assuming that Raxxla is a body.)

Personally I doubt Col 70 as a location, given that it’s already tied in to Thargoid (and Guardian) stuff, and hasn’t been permit locked all along. It’s also a strange location for anything really major as it goes, given the strange shape of it due to all the unlocked regions inside it. (Which in fairness could actually also make it a better candidate as it’s a less obvious target for something compared to, say, Regor.)

Something else going on with Polaris too, IMHO. Maintaining a standard level of obfuscation of in-game history across different sections of the playerbase would be a good reason for locking Polaris, for example. Having said that, there’s no reason it couldn’t be serving multiple purposes of course.

Also, the time of the earliest references doesn’t necessarily have much bearing on location. There’s nothing to say the references are based on Raxxla itself being found.
 
Last edited:

Scytale

Banned
So are you suggesting that even FD doesn’t know where Raxxla is because if so ????????

I think Herr Professor-Doktor is suggesting that Astrographics doesn't. Then neither your NavSystem does. Then "permit" is senseless.


Search results


 
Last edited:
Can’t permit lock something you don’t know where is. ;)
If I understand the lore correctly, all permit locks are put in place by the Elite Federation of Pilots (some obviously at the request of superpowers or local factions). That means that the system containing Raxxla cannot have been permit-locked _purely_ because it contains Raxxla, unless the Elite Federation of Pilots know where it is. It could, however, be incidentally locked off as a result of being inside a forbidden region. I think FD have confirmed that none of the regional permits are obtainable (I think it may have been a response to a question on a AMA or launch livestream for a patch, those are the ones I remember more clearly) so this is one possibility for a near-Bubble location that could not have been discovered (although Col 70 Sector and some surrounding locations were explorable at launch and only locked in 2.1). It could also be in an individual system locked off for another reason, which might then mean the permit is obtainable by some means.
.
I don't think the possibility of Raxxla being in a permit-locked location (obtainable or otherwise) should stop people from looking for it. Especially with the new mechanics, there might be clues to be found, either in space from beacons (or installations) or on the surface of planets and moons at abandoned settlements or crash sites. Knowing how to find and recognise the clues is the hard part - once you have them in hand they might be easier to solve. The fact that there are separate _categories_ for The Dark Wheel and Raxxla in the Codex suggests to me that there might be more than one entry in each to be revealed and that it might take something a bit unusual, or lucky, to get that information. The Dark Wheel were explorers and legend-seekers, so in a sense we are all here already members, just without any formal induction. All we can do is continue to play that role and see what we find.
 
You still remember those days being harmless, in that loan-sidewinder? Tanya would ask you to haul some cargo from Romanek's Folly, likely to see if you can jump into witchspace without passing out, I guess she had some other reasons too. You were instructed to choose the arrival system from contacts panel and go there, but, however you could check galaxy map also. And that map looked almost as if it was pointing somewhere, like a treasure map. Not the kind of galaxy map that opens up from where you are.

Now it probably means nothing, and you shouldn't take it too seriously, but I guess it wouldn't hurt to scan a few systems, since many of you are exploring around there these days anyway.
 
There is absolutely no evidence as to the location of Raxxla, or even what it is, circumstantial or otherwise. We have been clearly told that there will be no clues.

Everything known about Raxxla is detailed in the first post of this thread, with the sources to prove it; everything else is supposition, hypothesising, misinformation, personal belief, or wishful thinking. Some of the hypothesising has been based on lore reasoning on the fsd ranges which seems fairly plausible.

FD have not said it has been honked, that is an urban myth/false news/trolling; iff anyone can find the official source for this then I will change my mind on this point and I’m sure Macros will be very willing to add it to the OP, but we have been demanding for this source over the duration of this thread and none has been supplied....please do not propagate unfounded myth.

We know Raxxla has been in-game since the original gamma release, so iff it is a planet then it cannot be landable since Horizons brought that capability into the game; or at least it could not have been landable at the outset, but I guess FD could have updated it over time just as they upgraded the original FRift Zurara from a derelict Anaconda to a derelict megaship.

I personally do not think FD would implement this important part of the game only to hide it behind a permit; that would not be playing fair with us. I do think there is a way to find it, but it is clearly not straightforward (but since this is a personal belief I could of course be wrong, but I doubt it). I seem to remember someone, I think it might have been DB, in a recent livestream saying that the FSS might help in the location of Raxxla; I guess if that is a correct recollection then it was in the chapter 4 release vid.

Clearly FD will have put some reasonable effort into the creation of Raxxla, since it is so important to the player base. I think they will not have been constrained by what they have decided is non-canon lore, though I have difficulty in knowing what is, and what is not, now ED canon. I like the idea of a Borg-like textured planet, though I suspect it will turn out to be a derelict Coriolis station and the pic on the Codex will be either the entrance or an internal detail. I think there will turn out to be several people in FD who know about the details. Graphics dept, and probably sound dept, will have been involved in its design, as would Michael Brookes as the original Exec Producer and of course DB as the CEO and driving force. I can’t see these two guys doing everything themselves, however they may have been the ones to decide where it is located and how it might be discovered. They both seem to like puzzles, which gives me some level of confidence in my belief that there will be no permit lock but some tortuous puzzle.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom